How Kenya came undone

2008-02-01 00:00

They came at night by the hundreds, shooting villagers with arrows and attacking them with knives, axes and farm tools. The killings were a warning to the rest of the village: leave now, or die.

“These people were our neighbors, I knew them, but what I have seen is something that I cannot explain,” says Julia Muthoni, an elderly widow who found refuge in the city of Nakuru. “We Kikuyus are being targeted because we voted for the re-election of President Mwai Kibaki. Even before the election, they threatened us, saying that whether Kibaki wins or not, Kikuyus are going to be evicted.”

Not many weeks ago, Kenya remained an oasis of stability surrounded by nations at war. The tourist-friendly country is East Africa’s economic engine, a hub for global trade and a base for international humanitarian work. It has been a model of what other African countries could achieve if they worked hard, developed their economies and embraced free democracy. So the explosion of violence that has left more than 750 people dead and forced a quarter of a million to flee their homes since the disputed December 27 presidential election came as a shock to many. But under the placid surface, Kenya boils with deep ethnic resentment that some observers say has been ignored for too long.

“The matchbox was lit [by the vote], but the fuel was there,” says Njeri Kabeberi of the Centre for Multiparty Democracy in Nairobi. “There has always been ethnic tension within Kenyan society.”

While the most recent spark for the violence was the deeply flawed elections in which Kibaki was declared president, the underlying source of the country’s tension is a perception that one ethnic group — Kibaki’s Kikuyu tribe — has unfairly benefited from the nation’s wealth solely because of its proximity to people in power. Resentment between Kenya’s ethnic communities is chronic, observers say, but mistrust of Kikuyus has been building since Kenya’s first president, Jomo Kenyatta, took power after independence from Britain in 1963.

Under Kenyatta, himself a Kikuyu, Kikuyus rose to high positions in government, took over major firms and bought much of the farm land sold off by departing white settlers in the fertile Rift Valley. But it took a sense of betrayal to produce the violence of today, experts say. In 2002, a broad coalition of opposition leaders from different ethnic groups overthrew the 24-year dictatorship of President Daniel arap Moi, a Kalenjin. The new government signed a memorandum of understanding to share power.

But in 2003, Kibaki revoked that agreement and went back to the old habit of filling government positions — including, crucially, the Electoral Commission of Kenya — with members of his own ethnic group. Furious at what they considered a betrayal, and cut off from access to power, former allies such as populist opposition leader Raila Odinga — a member of the Luo ethnic group who claims that he won the December 27 vote — broke from the government and started a campaign for majimbo, Swahili for self-rule, and resistance to Kikuyu domination.

“This violence wasn’t a surprise,” says Waiganjo Kamotho, an attorney and political observer in Nairobi. “For months out in the Rift Valley, we’ve been hearing people saying ‘nyorosha’, which means, ‘We’re going to put you in your place’.”

In the election, voters cast ballots along ethnic lines. Kibaki’s support came from Kikuyus. Odinga drew mainly from his Luo tribe, but a coalition of politicians from smaller ethnic groups added to his base.

For most Kenyans, this tribal fight is not just about the presidency, but also about land. And the Rift Valley — Kenya’s bread basket — is the main battlefield.

“In Kenya, the state has the ability to allocate land, which is a major source of wealth,” says Jacqueline Klopp, an Africa expert at Columbia University in New York. “Kenyatta and Moi did it. Kibaki was a little better, but all allocate land and use it for political patronage.”

Under strong-arm leaders such as Kenyatta and Moi — both of whom controlled all branches of government and stifled the media — this cozy relationship between presidents and their tribes caused little violence. Kikuyus bought land in the ancestral areas of the Kalenjins, the Maasais, the Luos and other tribes, set up trading businesses and prospered. But when Moi bowed to pressure to allow a multiparty system, opposition politicians used the success of the Kikuyu “settlers” against them. In Kalenjin areas, Kalenjin politicians built up a base of support by feeding resentment toward Kikuyus, calling them “settlers” who had “stolen” ancestral lands. Some politicians used radio broadcasts to spread hatred against Kikuyus and said that the time had come to remove the “weeds” from the land.

Stoked with hate, the ethnic clashes began in earnest, particularly in the parts of the Rift Valley where Kikuyus had settled. Between the elections of 1992 and 1997, more than 2 000 Kenyans were killed and 300 000 Kenyans were displaced, most of them Kikuyus.

Politicians have used the belief that Kikuyus control the economy as a battle cry, pitting Kikuyus as the perpetual “haves” against the Luos, Kalenjins and other tribes as the perpetual “have-nots.” Odinga has primed those feelings with a call for majimbo which, for non-Kikuyus, means a return to ancestral lands.

“The Kikuyus are greedy,” says a Luo security guard. “Who owns all the big businesses? Kikuyus. Who owns all the big farms? Kikuyus. And who are all the top leaders in Kibaki’s government? Kikuyus. When they go into our land and take our property, people are going to push back. It’s our turn.”

Kikuyus view majimbo as a danger to the future of the country. “The Luos are lazy,” says a Kikuyu taxi driver. “They don’t invest. They don’t create. They don’t know how to run a business. And look at the violence they are creating. Do you think they should be running this country?”

This year, the violence has spread far beyond the Rift Valley into almost every urban centre, tearing the social fabric of a cosmopolitan society that had made Kenya a regional economic force. Foreign tourists have cancelled bookings and the Central Organisation of Trade Unions estimates that nearly 500 000 workers will lose their jobs.

“They have basically destroyed the local trade and now that they can’t buy food in the market, they are discovering to their shock and horror that they need each other,” says Richard Cornwell, a senior analyst at the Institute for Security Studies in South Africa. “Unless this is handled, this will be a slow civil war that doesn’t really break out, but it’s insidious. It’s always there.”

In the town of Nakuru, Keffa Magenyi Karuoya already feels the effects of that slow civil war. Since 1991, he has been displaced three times. A Kikuyu, he has been working with a network of community activists from different tribes in the Rift Valley to advocate for peace and to seek food aid and shelter for newly displaced victims.

“It is very frustrating,” says Karuoya. “The people coming from Eldoret, they can’t go back.” Eldoret is the mainly Kalenjin town where a church full of Kikuyus was burned two weeks ago, killing at least 30 people. But Kikuyus are not the only victims. “Just down the road, there are 3 000 Luo families camping out. The long-term issue, where this is going, that is my main concern.”

Kikuyus are now carrying out reprisal killings. On January 20, members of the Mungiki sect — a militia formed to protect Kikuyu interests — swept through a Nairobi slum attacking non-Kikuyus.

Musalia Mudavadi, an opposition parliamentarian, blamed the police for failing to control the Mungikis. “Today, some of our leaders have been appealing for calm, but the government has not withdrawn the ban on the right to assemble, the right to talk, and they have not withdrawn the shoot-to-kill order.”

— The Christian Science Monitor.

Join the conversation! encourages commentary submitted via MyNews24. Contributions of 200 words or more will be considered for publication.

We reserve editorial discretion to decide what will be published.
Read our comments policy for guidelines on contributions. publishes all comments posted on articles provided that they adhere to our Comments Policy. Should you wish to report a comment for editorial review, please do so by clicking the 'Report Comment' button to the right of each comment.

Comment on this story
Comments have been closed for this article.

Inside News24

Traffic Alerts
There are new stories on the homepage. Click here to see them.


Create Profile

Creating your profile will enable you to submit photos and stories to get published on News24.

Please provide a username for your profile page:

This username must be unique, cannot be edited and will be used in the URL to your profile page across the entire network.


Location Settings

News24 allows you to edit the display of certain components based on a location. If you wish to personalise the page based on your preferences, please select a location for each component and click "Submit" in order for the changes to take affect.

Facebook Sign-In

Hi News addict,

Join the News24 Community to be involved in breaking the news.

Log in with Facebook to comment and personalise news, weather and listings.