South Africa shining?

2010-07-21 00:00

AS the glow of the World Cup dims and those of us who didn’t have to spend the tournament in Blikkiesdorp start to settle into the ordinary grind, everyone from the captains of industry to the Communist Party is urging us to build on the momentum.

No one in their right mind could conclude that we don’t need momentum. In a country with systemic unemployment, an atrocious school system for most pupils, creeping and increasingly communal modes of authoritarianism, millions still living in shacks and a state that has failed to meet its most basic obligation, which is to keep people safe, it is clear that a lot of things are broken and need urgent fixing.

But momentum needs direction and neither Jacob Zuma nor the contemporary African National Congress is any good at what George H. W. Bush called “the vision thing”. Aside from a new elite excitement about the prospects for big and bold projects such as King Shaka International Airport and the Gautrain, which has led to fevered suggestions that we might bid for the poisoned chalice of the Olympic Games, we’re pretty much back to business as usual. The president’s relatives are splurging money and making dodgy business deals, politicians are wasting public money on cars, gratuitous self-promotion and hotels, the unions are accusing the Eskom management of more reckless expenditure, there is talk of censorship at the SABC and xenophobic flames threaten to flicker into evil bloom.

But the popular enthusiasm for the World Cup often bubbled up outside of the projects of Fifa and the state. And what is really new after the World Cup is the new sense of vision in society itself. After the World Cup everyone knows that the state is perfectly capable of putting up a stadium or keeping tourists safe on the Durban beach front if it puts its mind to it. Knowing that the state can do what it sets its mind to can put a sense of social resignation to rest and open up all kinds of possibilities.

It is now quite obvious that we could, if we wanted to, easily electrify shacks to stop the relentless winter fires, ensure that women can walk safely through our cities after dark and that there is a decent library­ in every school. And the sense of collective belonging and participation in our society that was engendered by the event could lead to a sense that we need, for the first time since 1994, to take the priorities of ordinary people seriously.

The World Cup has also shown us that, if we can organise a World Cup as well as Germany, we can centre our own aspirations, think big and think beyond the often self-imposed limitation of a subordinate, third- rate society out on the global periphery­. If that means we reject the idea that people should have to accept RDP houses as the limit of housing delivery, that’ll be a wonderful thing. But this desire carries a danger. It is one thing to ask a question such as “why should our cities be any less engaging and impressive than those elsewhere?” from the perspective of ordinary people. It is quite another to ask this from the perspective of elites.

Before the tournament, our development path was veering towards a toxic cocktail of social conservativism, authoritarian nationalism and crony capitalism that was producing an increasingly violent state-led project of class segregation resulting in gated, privatised, themed and often spectacular spaces for elites and peripheral, and grim, wholly inadequate and sometimes even semi-carceral spaces for the poor. If the Blikkiesdorp transit camp in Cape Town is the most notorious example of the latter, any number of malls, office parks, casinos­ or golfing estates could be used to represent the excesses of the former. In response we have one of the highest rates of popular protest in the world.

We are not unusual in this. Across the global South elites are increasingly tempted by an authoritarian mode of capitalism through which they can attempt to expel the poor from a visible presence in society and to leverage themselves into a world-class modernity by creating gated and spectacular islands of Dubai­ across their cities.

The nature of the excitement that is being felt in some quarters about the new sense of possibility for South Africa after the World Cup runs a real­ risk of fuelling an even more ruthless pursuit of islands of Dubai across the country at the expense of more places like Blikkiesdorp. District 9 could become a much better window into our society than Invictus­.

Long before the tournament, it was no secret that our elites were inspired by the momentum of their counterparts in India. That was where Lindiwe Sisulu got the idea to reintroduce the transit camp, an abomination last seen under high apartheid, to South Africa. But India should be a lesson to us rather than an inspiration.

In 2004, Indian elites were brimming with self-confidence on the back of the IT boom and they saw a real chance to take their place in the world. The right-wing Hindu nationalist­ Bharatiya Janata Party coined the phrase “India Shining” and, with a degree of millennial fervour, announced a new era in which the shackles of the colonial past would be thrown off. Cities would become world-class and the value of rural land would be unlocked for industrial development. Elites turned, in other words, to colonising their own country. In 2007, Arundhati Roy wrote: “What we’re witnessing is the most successful secessionist struggle ever waged in independent India — the secession of the middle and upper classes from the rest of the country. It’s a vertical secession, not a lateral one. They’re fighting for the right to merge with the world’s elite somewhere up there in the stratosphere.”

Today India is wracked with popular­ revolt and ruthless state violence­. Poor people’s movements and armed, and often brutal Maoist groups are involved in very different struggles against the state and capital­ (which in Bengal means struggle against the Communist Party­). By some estimates, the Maoists­ control a third to a quarter of the landmass. “India Shining” has turned into a sort of civil war.

As our captains of industry, the Communist Party and politicians all exhort us not to lose momentum in the wake of the World Cup, it is essential that we resist the temptation to acquiesce to the cosy fantasy that momentum in any direction is equally good for all of us. We need to have a serious conversation about where we want to go rather than just assuming that the pace of our movement is all that matters.

Are we aiming for more private jets at King Shaka International Airport and more regular opportunities to watch Paris Hilton smoking zol in Port Elizabeth or is our first and immediate priority the creation of the circumstances under which ordinary people can live a decent life?

• Richard Pithouse teaches politics at Rhodes University. This article first appeared on the website of The South African Civil Society Information Service (

Join the conversation! encourages commentary submitted via MyNews24. Contributions of 200 words or more will be considered for publication.

We reserve editorial discretion to decide what will be published.
Read our comments policy for guidelines on contributions. publishes all comments posted on articles provided that they adhere to our Comments Policy. Should you wish to report a comment for editorial review, please do so by clicking the 'Report Comment' button to the right of each comment.

Comment on this story
Comments have been closed for this article.

Inside News24

Traffic Alerts
There are new stories on the homepage. Click here to see them.


Create Profile

Creating your profile will enable you to submit photos and stories to get published on News24.

Please provide a username for your profile page:

This username must be unique, cannot be edited and will be used in the URL to your profile page across the entire network.


Location Settings

News24 allows you to edit the display of certain components based on a location. If you wish to personalise the page based on your preferences, please select a location for each component and click "Submit" in order for the changes to take affect.

Facebook Sign-In

Hi News addict,

Join the News24 Community to be involved in breaking the news.

Log in with Facebook to comment and personalise news, weather and listings.