W. Cape farm violence - the truth

2013-03-19 00:00

FROM years of experience, I know that when I am in a political pressure cooker, it is best to allow the heat to subside and some steam to escape before analysing what happened.

The recent farm strikes that shook the Western Cape for most of December and January are a case in point.

Let’s look at what really happened, not because the crisis is behind us, but because we are in a lull between storms. Noseyman (Nosey) Pieterse, who emerged as a key figure behind the strikes, is mobilising for the next round of the “rural struggle” he claims to lead. Pieterse wears several hats. He is simultaneously a farmer, the president of an association of BEE farmers in the wine and spirit industry, as well as a trade union leader, organising workers in the industry.

Before I begin, let me be clear: the life of a seasonal farm labourer is a very difficult one. Thousands of poverty-stricken people come to the Western Cape from across Southern Africa (particularly Zimbabwe, Lesotho and the Eastern Cape) for the fruit-picking season, desperately seeking work in one of the few remaining sectors that employ unskilled labour.

This is fertile ground for exploitation. And so it is easy to see how the dominant (but entirely misleading) narrative arose: “heartless white farmers and labour brokers make ‘super profits’ by using ‘divide-and-rule’ tactics to drive down workers’ wages as their lives deteriorate”. It is easy to see how this narrative fuelled the rage that led to the destruction of tens of millions of rands worth of farm infrastructure.

And one can discern the ANC’s interest in fuelling this narrative. It was a golden opportunity to drive a wedge between two strong sectors of DA support — farmers and farm workers — while seeking to position the DA on the side of heartless farmers and the ANC as the champion of exploited workers.

Except that the truth was the exact opposite. Here are some of the key facts (that explode this narrative).

• The workers’ protests started on a farm called Keurboschkloof, previously a model farm in the Western Cape where workers were paid far above the minimum wage. When the farmer, Pierre Smit, died, his farm was taken over by a black economic empowerment (BEE) consortium that immediately cut workers’ wages from an average of R14,51 to R10,60 per hour.

• This, understandably, elicited protests by workers, further aggravated by the fact that a former ANC councillor, who is also a labour broker, tried to bring in scab labour at the behest of this BEE consortium to replace the protesting workers.

• Braam Hanekom (nephew of an ANC Cabinet member) and his organisation Passop sought to unionise the workers for the Cosatu affiliate, the Food and Allied Workers’ Union (Fawu).

• He was challenged by Pieterse, a rival unionist, who claimed the sole right to organise workers in the area.

• When the protests spread to the Royal Mushroom Farm and Normandy Farm in mid-October, I was tipped off about an ANC strategy to “bring Marikana to the farms of the Western Cape” — a phrase used repeatedly by the ANC, and particularly Tony Ehrenreich, who combines a role as Cosatu provincial general secretary and the ANC caucus leader in the City of Cape Town.

• And as the protests spread, ANC Western Cape leader Marius Fransman made his presence felt, announcing “die Boere gaan k*k”, while the Minister of Agriculture, Tina Joemat-Pettersson, also visited the area and used inflammatory language.

• But the one minister actually responsible for labour matters, Mildred Oliphant, remained abroad for weeks, and did not bother to cut her trip short despite the protest against the minimum wage she had set.

So the truth is exactly the opposite of the prevailing narrative.

In fact, the best option available for unskilled, seasonal farm workers in South Africa is to secure a job with a farmer like Pierre Smit, who is not a rare exception in the Western Cape. In fact, research by Ben Stanwix of UCT’s Development Policy Unit shows that, on average, farmers pay significantly higher wages in the Western Cape than other provinces.

This is one of the reasons why tens of thousands of desperately poor people leave their homes in far more fertile regions across Southern Africa to seek work in the Western Cape.

The truth also reveals a number of profound ironies.

• Irony number one: while the ANC was slamming “heartless white farmers”, many of them were actually paying their workers more than the minimum wage that had been set by the ANC Minister of Labour, Mildred Oliphant, in consultation with Cosatu.

• Irony number two: when the workers went on strike in protest, and the ANC was slamming labour brokers for playing a role in exploiting workers, a former ANC councillor, Nelie Barends, who is also a labour broker, tried to provide the BEE farming consortium that took over Keurboschkloof farm with scab labour. In fact, throughout the period that the ANC was slamming labour brokers in the Hex River Valley, its own members were playing a key role as brokers, supplying seasonal labour to farms.

• Irony number three: as the ANC, Passop, Fawu and Pieterse claimed to be representing the interests of the workers, they were actually at war with each other, a conflict which seriously jeopardised worker interests, causing serious divisions and infighting between different groups of workers, usually divided on an ethnic basis. But they all shared one common goal: to convince workers that their “war” was actually with the farmers.

• Irony number four: while the ANC accused farmers of fanning xenophobia, it has actually been driven by labour brokers representing differing groups of workers, and exploiting the fault lines caused by ANC policy.

• Irony number five: while the ANC claims to be against labour brokers, it was the farmers, together with the Zimbabwean workers, who really fought to get rid of these broker intermediaries. This was vehemently opposed by the labour brokers, dominated by ANC public representatives, who were determined to defend the super profits they earned from placing workers.

• Irony number six: the ANC and its various allied organisations were happy to drive the conflict between the Basotho, Zimbabweans, and local labour to extend the unrest throughout rural areas, in their attempts to present the Western Cape as being exploitative, racist and ungovernable.

Why should anyone believe me? Go and read the primary academic research such as Ben Stanwix’s article “Minimum wages and compliance in South African agriculture”, as well as a discussion document by Jan Theron (co-ordinator of the Labour and Enterprise Policy Research Group at UCT) titled “Changing employment trends on farms in the Hex and Breede River valleys”, and the research paper “Violence, labour and the displacement of Zimbabweans in De Doorns, Western Cape” written by Jean Pierre Misago of the University of the Witwatersrand’s Forced Migration Studies Programme that contain some in-depth interviews on this matter.

There is much information out there if one is prepared to join the dots. The best of all of these is an article titled “Oogsten in Afrika”, published in the magazine Quote in October 2012, which quotes Anton de Vries, the Dutch co-founder of the BEE consortium that took over Keurboschkloof farm (that cut worker wages as soon as they took over), saying he had set up a venture to profit from land reform. He boasted that it was an official partner of the ANC national government and has contacts at the highest levels, which is its greatest asset.

The reality is that while most farmers pay significantly higher than the minimum wage, they are struggling to make ends meet because of the low return on their product.

For example, a Capturing Gains research project revealed that when it comes to the final retail price for table grapes from Hex River Valley exported to the United Kingdom, 42% goes to supermarkets, 32% to distributors, while only 18% is retained by the farmers, who must cover all their costs from this return.

Instead of falling prey to the ANC’s divide-and-rule tactics, farmers, farm workers, civil society and the government need to work together to address this highly distorted value chain and increase profitability on farms so that the individuals putting in the hard work start reaping the benefits.

• A longer version first appeared on SA Today, the online newsletter of the leader of the Democratic Alliance.

Join the conversation!

24.com encourages commentary submitted via MyNews24. Contributions of 200 words or more will be considered for publication.

We reserve editorial discretion to decide what will be published.
Read our comments policy for guidelines on contributions.

24.com publishes all comments posted on articles provided that they adhere to our Comments Policy. Should you wish to report a comment for editorial review, please do so by clicking the 'Report Comment' button to the right of each comment.

Comment on this story
Comments have been closed for this article.

Inside News24

Traffic Alerts
There are new stories on the homepage. Click here to see them.


Create Profile

Creating your profile will enable you to submit photos and stories to get published on News24.

Please provide a username for your profile page:

This username must be unique, cannot be edited and will be used in the URL to your profile page across the entire 24.com network.


Location Settings

News24 allows you to edit the display of certain components based on a location. If you wish to personalise the page based on your preferences, please select a location for each component and click "Submit" in order for the changes to take affect.

Facebook Sign-In

Hi News addict,

Join the News24 Community to be involved in breaking the news.

Log in with Facebook to comment and personalise news, weather and listings.