Are we now marketing crime?

2012-11-05 07:29

Chris Moerdyk

The culture of crime or rather, the habit many South Africans have got into of simply living with crime, is already presenting marketers with all sorts of new opportunities.

With the line between right and wrong having become inordinately fuzzy these past few decades, many South Africans are in effect, now committing crimes without realising for a moment that they're actually transgressing the law.

For example, boards of directors now seem quite happy not to prosecute their senior executives who are caught with their fingers in the till, taking backhanders from suppliers or otherwise ripping off the company. It is almost standard corporate practice today for the two parties to come to an arrangement whereby the perpetrator simply resigns often with a sizeable golden handshake and signing a deal never to talk about what he has done while the company agrees to forget about it.

The rather misguided thinking behind this being that the management of any company seen to have been ripped off by one of its own would not look good and that the resultant PR from any expose would be damaging to the brand.

Culture of corruption

Then we have an increasing culture of corruption in corporate circles with the use of backhanders to get business seemingly becoming more and more acceptable.

At the lower end of the scale, upright law abiding citizens think nothing these days of overtaking on solid white lines, chatting on cellphones while driving, screwing the taxman, inflating expense accounts and all sorts of other things they don't consider for a moment are wrong but which, in fact, are all crimes.

It has got so bad that taxi drivers go on strike and organise protest marches when police quite legitimately stop them for committing blatant crimes in terms of road rules and the roadworthiness of their vehicles.

Now, there are two distinct and very different ways in which marketers can take advantage of this national mindset.

One is to leverage this rather cavalier attitude the consumer has in terms of embarking on campaigns that are blatantly misleading but which nevertheless become acceptable because the consumer simply accepts that in this modern day and age no-one is honest anymore and no-one can be trusted. With the result that they almost expect to have to deal with snake oil salesmen.

The other option is to assume that what is actually going on in the mind of the consumer is that while it is quite alright for an individual to talk on a cellphone while driving, overtake on white lines, dodge the taxman and indulge in all sorts of other petty criminal activity, there is a deep seated anger and resentment at the amount of crime going on in the country. Which sounds contradictory but it isn't. It's human nature.

Desperate for someone to trust

Now, this means that the majority of consumers are actually desperate for someone to trust and that any company that can demonstrably market itself as a trustworthy company, will have customers flocking to its doors. Ironically, those companies that push the envelope of morality to its limits are also largely successful because they appeal to ego and greed.

What is fascinating however is that many of these companies don't seem to realise that they are sailing close to the ethical wind.

Certainly, the way ahead is going to be both fascinating and challenging for South Africa's marketers. The opportunity to play fast and loose with the truth will be abundant but it will by no means be easy. Some will get away with murder while others will be dismayed to be rejected by consumers for something that looks far less dodgy.

I can certainly see a lot of frustration in South Africa in future as marketers try desperately to grapple with a consumer mindset that on one hand is screaming blue murder about the level of crime in South Africa and on the other is feeling very little about breaking all sorts of laws as they go about their daily lives.

Brand loyalty

But, I believe that astute marketers will forego the short term benefits in leveraging the fact that so many consumers have simply opted to live with crime and accept that the people who flog them things are shady and slick.

Instead they will base their strategies on the fact that the fundamentals of marketing have not changed in hundreds of years and that the best and safest way forward is simply to strive to offer the best quality and service.

Brand loyalty, after all, has proved time and time again that it beats the hell out of brand acceptance. The former is generally for life and the former here today and gone tomorrow.                     

- Follow Chris on Twitter.

Send your comments to Chris

Disclaimer: News24 encourages freedom of speech and the expression of diverse views. The views of columnists published on News24 are therefore their own and do not necessarily represent the views of News24.

  • parys.fotograaf - 2012-11-05 09:52

    Screwing the tax man is a patriotic duty of you ask me. He does not work for the people, but for those who oppose all freedom of the people. In RSA context, he is simply used to rob the taxpayer.

  • stephen.j.dickson.3 - 2012-11-05 10:03

    A lot of businesses like the Banks, Insurance and Security companies all have a vested interest in crime. They don't want to see an end to it cos they use it as an excuse to fleece the public. Take for example when you apply for a job. The first question normally asked is "Do you have a Bank account?" Why you ask? Because no one pays salaries or wage packets in cash like in the past anymore because of the cash in transit heist and bank robbery scourge nowadays.Thus your money is paid into a Bank of your choice ( There's no difference here,they're all as bad and crooked as each other) where the payer is charged a deposit fee for paying you and then you get charged when withdrawing.The Banks love this cos its money for nothing.Same with Insurance and Security companies. If there was no crime there would be no need for these rip-off artists. They are all lower than a shark turd's shadow on a bottomless ocean........bottom line.

  • TheyTookMyNickLaZynEko - 2012-11-05 10:07

    is it not criminal for our tax monies to be misused?

  • stephen.j.dickson.3 - 2012-11-05 10:18

    South Africa : The Crime Capital of the World and Olympic Gold Medal Winner for all things crooked,criminal,corrupt,unjust,deceitful and pathetic.........bottom line. Should they ever decide to re-name the country, which I'm sure one day they will, then may I reccomend the use of Crimemany (my personal favourite) or Corruptia.

  • mart.botha - 2012-11-05 11:48

    Not necessarily on topic, but I cannot believe that a nation who came through apardheid would fall for the marketing of China, the Chinese and their 'Made in China' products, when China has an absolutely abysmal human rights record often likened to the treatment that black people suffered in those dark years. Memories and principles fade when money is brought into the equation which makes it all the more disappointing.

      attie.stone.3 - 2012-11-05 18:06

      Way of the world mantlekilo; They [the world bodies] 'recently' voted for the olympics to be held there. It's not about principles...It's about interests ["Human rights" support statements are propaganda for many of those in power].

  • Montagnes.Bleues - 2012-11-05 11:57

    Stop and THINK! Every single one of these issues STEMS FROM TRIBAL ZUMA'S SNIGGERING and GIGGLING indifference to anything correct. Go back even to when he held that creatures arm up high stating it was a future leader, and sniggering and snorting in glee when the leader of the opposition was treated so shabbily as the tribal goons generally do to SA women. Now broaden out from there a bit and see the lines tying him back to every single outrageous unethical and controversial and or criminal trend.................. see how indifferent and vehement the KZN ANC zulu's have become in their arrogance too

  • strikeback.strikeback - 2012-11-05 19:44

    We market crime and reward bad behaviour. We even give striking workers a "hardship bonus". Where will this end?

  • SharonE - 2012-11-05 20:19

    I found this link that explains how government benefits from crime, it is no small wonder then that crime prevention is not their number 1 priority..

  • gordon.turner.37 - 2012-11-06 08:16

    Chris ignores that many business models of big companies are criminal. Start with phone and data charges and end with loan sharks disguised as furniture shops. We hold up the directors of these companies as great men with vision and ingenuity.

  • flysouth - 2012-11-07 10:51

    Should someone sit down and do the calcs, I believe they would find that crime is the largest contributor to GDP on the basis of security measures purchased and replacement items purchased. In addition the amount of tax gained by government through VAT is enormous. Since the ANC is an immoral organisation without principles led by immoral leaders without principles, this all suits this government quite well, even though the charge of 'living off the proceeds of crime' is one that could be levelled!

  • pages:
  • 1