Mostly sunny. Cool.
Serena Williams (Getty/Gallo Images)
Multimedia · User Galleries · News in Pictures
Send us your pictures · Send us your stories
Confident and tough are out of the question, but when we show emotion, then we're over-sensitive and weak. Let's not respond by becoming what the world thinks is acceptable, writes Heidi Matisonn.
The word "unbecoming" is usually applied to
behaviour – we talk about it being unbecoming of X to have done Y when we mean
it was inappropriate, unsuitable, unseemly, even unacceptable of X to have done
Y. I think the word has taken on an even greater power: it is used to belittle,
demean, and disempower women.
Women are held to a different standard from men. We
are expected to be becoming, to be appropriate, to be seemly, to be acceptable.
Men, not so much. Take confidence: a confident man is attractive, a leader, a
man among men. A confident woman? She's bossy, domineering, doesn't know her
place – or my personal favourite – feisty. Speaking your mind, having the
courage of your convictions, not being demure – all very unbecoming – if you're
So confident and tough are out of the question, but when
we show emotion, then we're over-sensitive and weak. Yet when former US president
Barack Obama cried after one of the school shootings that took place in
America, no-one called him over-sensitive, or emotional, or weak. They focused
on the great message he sent that it's OK for men to cry.
Speaking of presidents, why has no one batted an
eyelid at the 25-year age gap between Melania and Donald Trump whereas the one
between Emmanuel and Brigitte Macron caused such a stir? An older man with a
younger woman – he's virile. An older woman with a younger man – there's
clearly something wrong with her.
Perhaps nowhere do these double standards play out
more explicitly than in sports. From a young age, it is expected that boys will
play – and excel – at sport. Girls, well, they can dabble in a bit of this and
that. But if they get too good, watch out – first thing we'll do is question
their sexual orientation. Or worse, expect them to chemically modify their
genetic make-up to conform to the standards becoming of other women. Compare
Caster Semenya's treatment to Michael Phelps: as Monica Hesse wrote in the
been reading about the unique genetic blessings bestowed upon the greatest
swimmer to ever live. Phelps possesses a disproportionately vast
wingspan, for example. Double-jointed ankles give his kick unusual range. In a
quirk that borders on supernatural, Phelps apparently produces just half the
lactic acid of a typical athlete — and since lactic acid causes fatigue, he's
simply better equipped at a biological level to excel in his sport.
thinking of those stories, because I'm thinking about the ways Michael Phelps
was treated as wondrous marvel. Nobody suggested he should be forced to have
corrective surgery on his double-jointed ankles, nobody decided he should take
medication to boost his lactic levels."
starkly contrasted with how the IAAF has treated Caster Semenya, whose body
allegedly produces testosterone at a higher level than most women: it has ruled
that if she wants to continue to compete, she must take medications to lower
decision, when described as discriminatory, was justified in a statement that
read: "discrimination is a necessary, reasonable and proportionate means
of achieving the IAAF's aim of preserving the integrity of female athletics."
"Integrity of female athletics"? What does
that even mean? I'll hazard a guess: it means that women need to look a certain
way on the sports field – while men do not.
Think about endorsements: no-one seemed to care what Tiger
Woods, Wayne Rooney or Ronaldinho looked like (just as well). It's skill that
counts. Take tennis for example. In 2013, the top three earners in men's tennis
in terms of endorsements were Roger Federer, Rafael Nadal, and Novak Djokovic. They were also the top
three players. In 2002 Anna Kournikova
was reportedly making $10m a year in endorsements, even though
she had never won a professional singles tournament.
In 2015, Forbes listed
Serena Williams as no 55 on its list of power women. At that stage, she had won
$72m in prize money, more than double what Maria Sharapova, had made. Yet Maria
Sharapova was number 2 on that list
because, according to
Forbes, Serena Williams "can't quite match Sharapova in endorsement deals".
Why? Well, Forbes suggests that "the Russian standout's good-looks may
play a factor in working deals".
the view of Merlisa Lawrence Corbett, who writes that the "Kournikova era
ushered in a new type of tennis star. Instead of making a name through
conquering the courts, women could reach tennis stardom by looking good and
playing 'good enough'."
herself has admitted that she has encountered constant body shaming since she
came on to the scene: "It was hard for me," Williams said in an
interview in 2018. "People would say I was born a guy, all because of my
arms, or because I'm strong. I was different to Venus: she was thin and tall
and beautiful, and I am strong and muscular ? and beautiful, but, you know, it
was just totally different."
But it's not just looking like ladies – women sport
stars have to act like ladies too apparently: that is, restrained, retiring,
Here's another contrast:
The USA Women's Soccer team were criticised for
celebrating each goal in their 13-0 defeat of Thailand in the recent FIFA Women's
World Cup – the women faced backlash for embarrassing their opponents and being
unsportsmanlike. But in the 1995 Rugby World Cup, when New Zealand crushed
Japan 145-17, the All Blacks were praised for "not taking their foot of
the gas" and showing respect to the Japanese players by playing hard for
the full 80 minutes.
rugby is one of sport's great success stories, experiencing unprecedented
growth around the world. Participation levels are at an all-time high with 2.7
million players globally – making up more than a quarter of the global playing
population – and a 28% increase in registered players since 2017. For the second year running, more young girls have got into
rugby globally than boys and more than 40% of rugby's 400-million fan base is
When you go
on to the Women in Rugby website, the first thing you see are four words,
written in 10cm high, uppercase red letters:
TRY AND STOP
and you see some rules:
RULE: TRY. SECOND RULE: TRY AGAIN.
LIFE WILL HURT SOMETIMES.
THIS GAME WILL GIVE YOU STRENGTH.
TO NEVER GIVE UP, GIVE IN, OR GIVE AN INCH.
WHATEVER YOUR SIZE, SHAPE, OR STORY.
THERE'S NOTHING YOU CAN'T TACKLE.
NO LINE YOU CAN'T BREAK.
NO OBSTACLE YOU CAN'T GET OVER.
OR POWER STRAIGHT THROUGH.
THERE'LL BE JUDGERS, DISAPPROVERS, NON-BELIEVERS.
FEAR LESS. PLAY MORE.
BECAUSE ONCE YOU'VE STARTED, YOU CAN'T BE STOPPED.
Now, I'm not saying all women should rush out and join a women's rugby
team. I'm certainly not planning to. (I'm much more of a watch-the-game-on-TV-while-drinking-a-beer-and-screaming-at-the-ref
kind of rugby woman.) But the sentiment is one I approve of: try and stop us.
The world can carry on with the unreasonable standards and unfair rules.
Persist with the unrealistic expectations and unnecessary demands. Continue to
call our behaviour unbecoming. Let's not respond by becoming what the world
thinks is acceptable. Let's respond by giving the world the finger.
- Dr Heidi Matisonn is a lecturer at the School of Religion, Philosophy & Classics at the University of KwaZulu-Natal.
What makes a great Formula 1 driver? Is it their natural 'raw talent'?
According to an international fashion authority.
How does mom's anxiety affect baby?
Audi’s crossover and SUV offering has received a notable consolidation.
Here's how you can slash that price in half.
Highclere Castle is now open to the public.
Here's what to watch in local cinemas.
A quick dinner when you simply can't bother making pasta from scratch.
Cape TownHyperion DevelopmentR10 000.00 - R30 000.00 Per Month
Western CapeElite SourcingR15 000.00 Per Month Per Month
Cape TownTumaini ConsultingR600 000.00 - R700 000.00 Per Year
R 1 650 000
Apartments / Flats
R 14 250 000
R 3 395 000
We subscribe to the Press Code.
You choose what you want
News24 on Android
Get the latest from News24 on your Android device.
Terms and Conditions
24.com Terms and Conditions - Updated April 2012
Creating your profile will enable you to submit photos and stories to get published on News24.
This username must be unique, cannot be edited and will be used in the URL to your profile page across the entire 24.com network.