The dignity of the state capture commission has been held up by Zondo's personal approach. Even the most reluctant witness could not gather the rudeness to withdraw.
The problem with South African democracy is that we hold our
soccer and rugby coaches to higher standards of accountability than we do our
This doesn’t just hold true for our leaders serving in
government and the ANC, but holds more disproportionately true for our
opposition, particularly the DA.
The strength of our democracy is determined by the strength
of our opposition and their ability to contest actions and ideas enacted by the
ruling party. So even if you’re not a supporter of the DA, their political
position and the things they stand for, it is still quite strongly in your
interest that we have a stronger DA, for the sake of our democracy. Now more than
Much like we do with the private sector, we don’t seem to
care to hold opposition parties to account, or at least not as much as we do
the ruling party. Presumably because the ruling party has a mandate that
opposition parties don’t hold. But this couldn’t be more fallacious. By their
mere existence in the democratic space, opposition parties have a mandate
equally as heavy, because they have offered themselves up to the concern of
improving South Africa and our democracy and we ought to hold them to that standard.
In the DA’s case, not only are they the biggest opposition
party, they’re also not just an opposition party. Holding office in several key
metros and municipalities (under several coalitions), the DA is a ruling party
But why the sudden concern with the DA?
The DA has become an opposition unto itself in almost
exactly the same way the ANC has. It silences internal critical voices, exonerates
problematic key figures, backbenches its strongest and most important leaders
and refuses radical change – by holding onto the old white boys club.
Crucially, for the DA to demonstrate that it takes South
Africans and their plights serious, it needs to make a concerted effort to
start being truly representative of South Africans by undertaking a radical
transformation project. 75% of the DA’s parliamentary body is still male, that
means only 25% of the DA’s leadership is female, despite having had a female
figurehead. This is disgusting standards for any party that seeks to lead South
Africa. It gets worse. A staggering 80% of the DA’s parliamentary caucus is
white, holding only 20% black Africans on the bench.
In a country that is predominantly black, where most of the
problems disproportionately affect black people and where the poverty is
largely a black struggle – as Cyril Ramaphosa puts it, the poverty in this
country bears the long face a black women – it is mind boggling how the DA’s
representative body can be so unrepresentative. More disgustingly, only but 9% of
that representative body is black and female.
Surely this is not displaying of a party serious about
representing South Africa? Importantly, continuing this demographic mismatch,
the DA can forget about growing any further – especially given that there now
exist a young vocal and energetic black alternative in the opposition politics
spectrum, namely the EFF. The EFF’s growth comes from exactly their ability to
look as representative of the poor majority of this country.
This transformation project is simple. Break up the old
white boys club. Importantly, then, it means the DA needs to start employing
more black talent and leadership – leadership that is young and female.
Even then, the DA needs to place that young black leadership
in critical parliamentary positions. It makes no sense that the chief whip, the
opposition’s voice in Parliament that gets the most airtime, remains a white
voice. John Steenhuisen is the very face of the white monopoly capital that
Jacob Zuma talks about and people will continue to believe his insincere
characterisation of it because people continuously see John Steenhuisen and his
Backstreet Boys Gang insincerely challenge the political moment.
With the talent of Phumzile van Damme as chief whip and
potentially Hlomela Bucwa as her deputy, the DA’s voice becomes one that black
voters in this country can take serious when they challenge the political
Outside of Parliament, the DA continues to face a moral
crisis by exonerating problematic figures within the party. Helen Zille remains
the most recognisable and influential figure in the party and her utter racism
and sheer arrogance towards the pain and suffering of black people in South
Africa continues to cost the DA its growth. Leaders in the party who came to
her defence since her Twitter blunder exonerated her and displayed the true
sentiments of the party regarding colonialism and its impact on black people.
The DA loses nothing by getting rid of Ouma Helen, but in
fact, would gain a lot more respect and support from people who were and are
uncertain of the DA’s colour line. Importantly, Ouma Helen’s disciplinary
hearing should have been an expedited matter give the sensitivity of the case,
her Twitter account confiscated and she should have been put on immediate
suspension pending the outcomes of her disciplinary hearing. When the DA,
specifically Mmusi Maimane failed to do that, the DA displayed that it is an
opposition unto itself.
I would love to see a DA that is stronger, more sincere and
proactive because it is only then that the ANC will take itself serious and
take us serious. But the ANC remains unshaken by the DA because the DA is doing
as much damage to itself as it does to the ANC.
Importantly, for a party that governs in metros, cities and a province (and potentially another province after 2019), the DA is not just an opposition, so we need to hold the DA to the same standards we do the ANC. This means we may need to march for the removal of Ouma Helen as much as we do the removal of Oupa Jacob. We may need to march for the transformation of the DA’s racial make up as much as we would the Gupta’s state capture.
- Dickson is a socio-political analyst and an award winning competitive debater currently ranked Africa's nr. 1 debater. Follow him on Twitter: @Oliver_Speaking.Disclaimer: News24 encourages freedom of speech and the expression of diverse views. The views of columnists published on News24 are therefore their own and do not necessarily represent the views of News24.
24.com publishes all comments posted on articles provided that they adhere to our Comments Policy. Should you wish to report a comment for editorial review, please do so by clicking the 'Report Comment' button to the right of each comment.
Volkswagen‘s double cab, the Amarok, is now available in a special edition.
Craig Anderson a lecturer in Statistics answers how likely this is to happen.
You don't even have to break the bank to enjoy a friction-free summer.
Here's how the five best-paid Formula 1 drivers in 2019 justify their earnings.
In case you’re having a bad day.
Automobili Lamborghini celebrated Monterey Car Week with an array of supercars.
The island of Curaçao!
An authentic display of gravitas and empathy.
Cape TownAmazon Development Centre SA (Pty) Ltd
Cape TownTracking Talent
Somerset WestFinovate PeopleR15 000.00 Per Month Per Month
R 2 495 000
R 2 995 000
We subscribe to the Press Code.
You choose what you want
News24 on Android
Get the latest from News24 on your Android device.
Terms and Conditions
24.com Terms and Conditions - Updated April 2012
Creating your profile will enable you to submit photos and stories to get published on News24.
This username must be unique, cannot be edited and will be used in the URL to your profile page across the entire 24.com network.