Obama was uplifting, but didn't say anything new

2018-07-22 10:10
Former US president Barack Obama speaks to a packed audience at the 16th annual Nelson Mandela Lecture at Wanderers Stadium in Johannesburg on Wednesday. PHOTO: Frennie Shivambu /Gallo Images

Former US president Barack Obama speaks to a packed audience at the 16th annual Nelson Mandela Lecture at Wanderers Stadium in Johannesburg on Wednesday. PHOTO: Frennie Shivambu /Gallo Images

Multimedia   ·   User Galleries   ·   News in Pictures Send us your pictures  ·  Send us your stories

What a privilege to be at the 16th Mandela Lecture given by former US president Barack Obama. Obama confirmed himself as a great orator as he wove a story perfectly aligned with Mandela’s life and politics. He gave us a grand overview of world history from when Mandela was born in rural Eastern Cape, touching on the end of colonialism, the fall of the Berlin Wall and the release of Mandela from prison, up to today. We were reminded of the incredible progress during these 100 years, how Mandela “came to embody the universal aspirations of dispossessed people all around the world” and inspired Obama to “consider the small role [he] might play in bending the arc of the world towards justice”. Then he came to the backlash that now threatens to return us to “an older, a more dangerous, a more brutal way of doing business”. It was a backlash seen in the 9/11 attack, a politics of fear and resentment, and a return to strong-man politics with those in power undermining the core institutions of democracy. With this Obama set us up for the conclusion built around the challenges of today that he is confident the youth of today, as Mandela was in the past, can meet with a belief in “equality and justice and freedom and multiracial democracy built on the premise that all people are created equal”.

The speech was uplifting and well received, he was at his best, as was Mandela, in extolling the positive common values of humanity and the power of being decent people: “We should treat one another with care and respect.” He reminded us that we are not born hating people who are different from us and “if they can learn to hate, they can be taught to love for love comes more naturally to the human heart”. It was hard not to get a caught up by his message as he implored us all to “follow Madiba’s persistence and hope” and to “resist that cynicism”. Who could object when he called on young people to “keep believing, keep marching, keep building, keep raising your voice”.

Despite the fine oratory, I found myself questioning Obama’s narrative. I wondered what exactly went wrong with the path of progress he told us about and what exactly we need to “keep building”. The history was of necessity sweeping, but the fundamental flaws are not due to brevity, they are reflective of a particular world view that is part of the problem. His progress was a Western one combined with the fall of dictators in Africa and Asia. Russia and China were mentioned only negatively with comments such as China bristling at criticisms of its human rights record and needing to “stop taking intellectual property and hacking our servers”.

Obama repeated an assumed linear path of progress that links liberal democracy, human rights, economic liberalisation, innovation and scientific breakthroughs. One of the great results of this, he said, being that “suddenly a billion people were lifted out of poverty”. As much as this is a common narrative, it has also been strongly challenged by many historians and other scholars. The reality of how and where those billion people were lifted out of poverty contradicts his core argument as at least half of them are in China, which has not embraced liberal democracy and human rights. Yet there was no mention of China’s contribution or learning from their successes.

In explaining the “backlash”, Obama contradicted his own story of how much had been achieved, acknowledging that “for far too many people, the more things have changed, the more things stayed the same” and that there has been an “explosion in economic inequality”. Governments and powerful elites, Obama told us, failed to address the contradictions. What he didn’t give us is any analysis of what could be done differently today to avoid such a failing in future.

Obama called on us to counter the return to the bad old days, with a return to the good old days of “an inclusive capitalism” combined with government regulation and people paying taxes so that we can have education for all, worker’s rights, universal healthcare and the break up monopolies. And the rich should be willing to pay taxes because, “there is really only so much you can eat, only so big a house you can have”. Popular sentiments indeed, but very short on analysis of what drives accumulation and what blocked such initiatives in the past.

Part of what was so alluring about the speech is that Obama mentioned many of the pressing challenges we know about: inequality; climate change; billions or even trillions of dollars being moved around the world at the click of a button; the rich and powerful out of touch with the people; technology threatening jobs; the concentration of political power following the concentration of wealth; corruption; etc. But, there was little substance and nothing new. He gave no indication of how nation states could, under these circumstances, effectively tax the rich, no new idea for how to shift power from the economic and political elites towards the majority of people. There was also the irony of him telling us about how wealth buys political power as he shared the stage with our millionaire President Cyril Ramaphosa and our favourite billionaire Patrice Motsepe. Yes, he implored us to stand for what is right, to embrace common human values, but there were people doing this before, we had movements in the past, we had Mandela (we had Obama) and all the while the serious problems he pointed out grew.

Obama did not explain how it is that he, as a person who believes in equality and justice and human rights for all, enforced trade deals that destroyed jobs in the US and elsewhere, ordered the murder of droves of people – and those who happened to be near them – who never had access to justice, or how he financed and condoned the brutal and murderous persecution of Palestinians. He didn’t tell us what power was at work in such decisions and how that power could be overcome. There could be very useful lessons from such a discussion, which he is uniquely placed to assist us with.

Most disappointing for me was the extent to which Obama stuck with old binary positions and only one right economic model. He said we “stand at a crossroads” with “two very different visions of humanity’s future”, we have a choice between right and wrong, between democracy or authoritarianism, between state socialism or capitalism. He argued that we know what works, “look at the history books”, but he didn’t mention that the best of social democratic successes, that he was clearly referring to, never reached more than a small part of the world’s population, nor did he explain why these successes were being rolled back long before 9/11 and before Donald Trump came to power. Indeed, we should look at history, but not a one-sided history and not to find blue prints, rather to avoid repeating the same mistakes. There is no reason to believe that the outcomes of Obama’s “inclusive capitalism” will be any different from the outcomes of capitalism in the past. He said a lot of good things about what is needed for democracy, but nothing about how the economy could be structured differently from how it is now and was in the past.

I clapped and cheered for some of Obama’s well-made arguments and we should certainly respect the dignity and rights of all people, but please let us not buy this American dream, even when so well packaged. It is not working well for most black Americans or for poor and middle-class Americans, let alone for people in poverty in the rest of the world. It is not working well for the environment. We need to move beyond binary options to change the terms of the debate and seek new ways of living with one another and our planet. As Obama said, we need to go to the grassroots, but this should not be only for the political engagement he talked of. We need to learn from the majority of people across Africa who are creating their economic lives under difficult circumstance. We can especially learn from those who are resisting inclusion into the corporate capitalist order. It is these people, at the grassroots, who are perhaps reimagining in practice a more human economy that doesn’t leave them depending on grants or the benevolence of billionaires. We need to build on people’s ideas and everyday activities to ensure the majority are the owners and primary beneficiaries within economies that meet their aspirations.

- Wegerif is a postdoctoral fellow at the human economy programme at the University of Pretoria


What did you make of Barack Obama’s Mandela Lecture speech? SMS us on 35697 using the keyword OBAMA and tell us what you think. Please include your name and province. SMSes cost R1.50

Read more on:    nelson mandela  |  barack obama

Join the conversation!

24.com encourages commentary submitted via MyNews24. Contributions of 200 words or more will be considered for publication.

We reserve editorial discretion to decide what will be published.
Read our comments policy for guidelines on contributions.

Inside News24

Traffic Alerts
There are new stories on the homepage. Click here to see them.


Create Profile

Creating your profile will enable you to submit photos and stories to get published on News24.

Please provide a username for your profile page:

This username must be unique, cannot be edited and will be used in the URL to your profile page across the entire 24.com network.


Location Settings

News24 allows you to edit the display of certain components based on a location. If you wish to personalise the page based on your preferences, please select a location for each component and click "Submit" in order for the changes to take affect.

Facebook Sign-In

Hi News addict,

Join the News24 Community to be involved in breaking the news.

Log in with Facebook to comment and personalise news, weather and listings.