It is sad when a party loses talented people. It is sadder when one has worked for decades to build a party to see it teetering on the brink of a major setback.
Morning clouds. Mild.
UNDER FIRE Sars commissioner Tom Moyane. Picture: Deon Raath
Multimedia · User Galleries · News in Pictures
Send us your pictures · Send us your stories
There really is no plausible legal path for Tom Moyane to continue litigation, although one suspects that will not deter him, writes Sergeant at
findings of the Nugent commission are accepted, it may be brought to bear that Tom
Moyane played a huge role in the degradation of SARS and hence the increased
pressure on the public purse due to declining tax collection.
this decline has greatly affected the poor by causing an increase last year in
VAT and ensuring less money for critical forms of state investment.
But he is a
determined man and even a loss at the Constitutional Court has failed to derail
his continuing litigation strategy.
READ: Moyane: We accept that this is the end of the road - for now
question to be addressed is: what is the aim of this litigation after the Constitutional Court dismissed Moyane's bid to get his job back?
To answer this question it is necessary to go back to a judgment of Judge Hans
Fabricius on 11 December last year.
approached the high court to prevent the president from implementing
recommendations contained in an interim report of the Nugent commission, the
relief of which included the reinstatement of Moyane as commissioner, albeit
that he remains suspended with pay, the prevention of an appointment by the president
of a new commissioner and the prohibition of any further reports being issued by
the Nugent commission.
a second part of the relief sought which included the suspension of the Nugent commission,
and a declaration that the decision by the president based upon the Nugent commission
to fire Moyane was legally invalid.
Fabricius was only required to deal with the first part of the relief. In
dismissing the application in respect of the interim relief sought in the first
part, Fabricius found that the president was legally entitled to dismiss a commissioner
provided he conducted himself within the confines of legality. Procedural
fairness was not a requirement in such a case.
In this case
the judge held that not only was the president entitled to have regard to the
interim report of the Nugent commission but he was "indeed obliged to do
so… indeed the president would have been acting irrationally, if he had not
acted on the interim report (of Judge Nugent)".
the court held that Moyane cannot demonstrate a right of reinstatement particularly
in a case such as this one where a special relationship of trust must exist
between the president and the commissioner. It was against this order that Moyane
appealed to the Constitutional Court which, in dismissing his appeal, held that
there were no prospects of success.
It is trite
that the appeal is against an order and not the reasoning employed by the court.
So Judge Fabricius' reasoning may not have been what motivated the
Constitutional Court to find that there were no prospects that Moyane could
legally prevent the president from firing him and appointing a successor.
ALSO READ: Trevor Manuel heads up search for new SARS boss
contends that the second part of the relief initially sought by him was not
determined by Judge Fabricius and hence the decision of the Constitutional
Court to hear the appeal was only confined to the order so granted. In other
words, it is still open to Moyane to argue that the Nugent commission which by
now has handed in its final report should be suspended and that its rulings
should be set aside.
further relief sought that Minister Pravin Gordhan should not be involved in
the Nugent commission, presumably in respect of being a witness at the commission
and the appointment of advocate Azhar Bham SC to chair an inquiry into the
status of Moyane. Both these latter forms of relief have clearly been overtaken
But so it
would appear has the relief against the Nugent commission. At best for Moyane
he could raise arguments about the commission's composition but given that the
final report has been delivered, it is difficult to see what live legal issues
plausible basis for relief would be that the president made his decision to
remove Moyane as a result of the interim report written by Judge Nugent and
hence acted irrationally. But that was the real aim of the relief that Judge
Fabricius dismissed and it was in respect of that order that the Constitutional
Court held there were no prospect of success.
the added consideration that Moyane's term of office was due to end in
September 2019. As there is no legal basis to argue that he was entitled to
another term, his only possible remedy is to sue for damages in respect of
benefits until the end of his term.
In summary there
really is no plausible legal path for Moyane, although one suspects that will
not deter him. Interestingly, not even the punitive cost order against him in
the North Gauteng High Court case has deterred him.
a new commissioner may be installed soon and save for actions which some NGOs
have sought against Moyane, he may not be seen litigating for much longer.
- Serjeant at the Bar is a senior legal practitioner with a special interest in constitutional law.Disclaimer: News24 encourages freedom of speech and the expression of diverse views. The views of columnists published on News24 are therefore their own and do not necessarily represent the views of News24.
Motshekga says parents can opt out of the LO curriculum.
Here are the risks:
We need them back.
What do they have in common?
A deeply personal look behind-the-scenes.
Study reveals scary revelation on kids and screen-based media.
Between Germany and Japan, here's which automaker's car is better.
The criminalisation of revenge porn has been realised in South Africa.
Western CapeO'Dwyer Personnel
George - KnysnaADA Recruitment & HR Solutions
Western CapeWillearnR33 000.00 - R40 000.00 Per Month
R 7 900 000
R 4 995 000
R 6 900 000
We subscribe to the Press Code.
You choose what you want
News24 on Android
Get the latest from News24 on your Android device.
Terms and Conditions
24.com Terms and Conditions - Updated April 2012
Creating your profile will enable you to submit photos and stories to get published on News24.
This username must be unique, cannot be edited and will be used in the URL to your profile page across the entire 24.com network.