MyNews24 is a user-generated section of The stories here come from users.

Lukhona Mnguni
Comments: 38
Article views: 1721
Latest Badges:

View all Lukhona Mnguni's badges.

If Oscar was a black man

26 February 2013, 18:22

The media often never misses an opportunity to conduct a court of public opinion when a criminal incident involving high profile persons is being heard in the real courts. This is partly due to the commercialisation of our society; it is all about news that sells. A shock and disbelief that a darling of the nation and global community could be guilty of having shot his beautiful model girlfriend in cold blood has caused a global media frenzy.

What is at stake here is Oscar Pistorius’s reputation, safe to say many feel that Reeva Steenkamp’s no longer matters following her death. Oscar’s reputation is being protected so much that a dedicated public relations’ consulting company, including British spindoctor Stuart “celebrity PR veteran” Higgins, was hired by the family. This is to ensure that the PR team conducts a swift medial trial.

The problem with the court of public opinion is that it has no controls to dispense fair justice and usually concludes on one’s guilt or innocence way before a court trial concludes on the verdict and this can put the judiciary in a compromising position with the public. That is if the court trial’s outcome is contrary to that of the trial done by the media.

Mail&Guardian journalist, Nickolaus Bauer, wrote that “The story of a beautiful blonde allegedly murdered by a disabled national icon will certainly sell more newspapers and magazines than covering another corruption scandal, another sexual assault or another murder in South Africa.”

Some media still maintains that there is an allegation that Oscar shot Reeva. This is no longer an allegation, it is established fact; the argument is now left to consider the reasons behind the shooting, whether it was deliberate or accidental. With hindsight, one can emphatically say the media played a role to protect Pistorius’s image at all costs during the bail application hearings, to retain his right to be deemed “innocent until proven guilty” at all costs.

Here the media barely cared about being sympathetic towards the family that lost a daughter from this alleged criminal act. Whenever the prosecution’s bail application arguments seemed to be weakening, thanks to the flounder Investigating Officer Botha, the media pronounced those weaknesses as though it was already a trial and the weaknesses proved Oscar’s innocence. That is why the Chief Magistrate Nair, when granting bail to Oscar, repeatedly emphasised that “Just because Botha was weak, it does not mean the state’s case is weak”.

When Anene Booysen’s brutal rape happened in Bredasdorp, the media assumed an activist role to highlight the scourge of gender-based violence directed to women. On the Pistorius matter, even though logic gives a fair possibility that Reeva Steenkamp was a victim of gender-based violence, the media has failed to let this story carry the baton from the story of Anene Booysen to further highlight that gender-based violence knows no race, class or prestige.

One would say, “but Pistorius has not been found guilty of intentionally killing Reeva”; however, equally the Anene Booysen’s accused rapists and killers have also not been found guilty, yet the media already portrays them as guilty – simply because they are black and poor, which increases their probability of guilt, whilst Oscar’s race and riches decrease his probability of guilt for such heinous acts.

Black incidents are treated as just another addition to the horrible national statistics of violence and brutality; meanwhile white incidents are treated as events worth bringing the nation to a halt until they are resolved as soon as possible. Examples of those cases are those involving Bees Roux, Eugene Terreblanche’s killing, the Modimolle Monster and now Oscar Pistorius. Famous court cases featuring black people are usually mainly those involving corruption, to show how badly prepared to govern, black people are; whilst corruption cases involving white people as wrongdoers are under reported.

Let us observe the different media narratives in the court of public opinion. Jacob Zuma had to explain himself in the rape saga, he had never been found guilty of any crime before; people simply did not like him because there were other allegations, such as corruption, to his name. Yet, in the court of public opinion, there was a thread of argument that was already pronouncing on his guilt.

Pistorius has also never been convicted of any crime before, but equally there are serious allegations of a short temper, violent and aggressive behaviour, yet the media treats him as a victim of circumstances (a consideration that was flatly dismissed on reports regarding Zuma during the rape trial), incapable of having been angered by Reeva to a point that he could have killed her. Anger, violence and crime have a black face and a male gender in this country.

That is why people (both black and white) start protecting their bags at the sight of “dodgy looking” black men on the streets, but if the “dodgy looking” person is white, they tend to feel some pity for them and even seek to enquire what is wrong with him.

In the Eugene Terreblance case, perpetrators were black. The media wanted them to be found guilty for such an inhumane act of bludgeoning Eugene. The media felt that no matter how aggrieved by Terreblanche the employees might have been, they had no right to kill him that way. In the Bees Roux (the Blue Bulls rugby player) matter, the media placed great focus on what was the conduct of the traffic officer.

Was it a corrupt “dodgy” cop or not, who wanted to rob Bees of his riches? Eventually, Bees Roux’s riches got him off the hook of justice by offering R750 000 to the black and poor family that had just lost a breadwinner to a senseless crime. Here the tables had turned swiftly because the perpetrator was suddenly a white man. It is some cultural shock for the media when a white person commits a crime, so much that the media’s own prejudices begin to show up glaringly.

Black perpetrators are turned into villains and white perpetrators are turned into victims, almost in all incidents. When a black, powerful, well-known person is involved in a criminal incident such as Oscar’s, the media is quick to take the position of “he must face the music as quickly as possible”, with the intention of teaching society a lesson.  The lesson is branded as “no one is above the law” even the powerful and rich get to be punished.

The media then behaves like a syndicate that is acting in the public’s interests and that of justice by almost being on the prosecution’s side with the intention to “bring down” this black powerful man. In this instance, we are made to believe that the media stands for justice with a bias towards those who are victims of the alleged crime. Then you get an Oscar Pistorius real life saga and the tables turn so quickly you hardly realise what is going on.

The media finds nothing odd with bringing down a black man, yet it allows white criminals to go unscathed. In the Jackie Selebi trial, the media found nothing worth questioning about our criminal justice system’s ability to give a white criminal (druglord) amnesty. Glen Aggliotti was given amnesty for serious crimes that affect communities that are gripped by a drugs’ problem, which contributes significantly to the spread of violence, murders and other criminal acts. Aggliotti was set free in exchange for information that would bring down this black and powerful man for having received bribes to the tune of about R165 000.

As I have argued, black incidents are a mere addition to the already horrific statistics. In April 2012, one of the most bizarre and outrageous incidents of rape occurred and the media barely covered it; its media life was very short lived.

A schoolboy of 15 years, raped and gouged out an eye of an eight year old fellow schoolgirl in sugarcane fields on their way back from school to their village, around the Gingindlovu area of KwaZulu-Natal. There was never a follow-up as to how the boy is being dealt with by the criminal justice system and whether or not rehabilitation will be a consideration for the boy.

During the Oscar Pistorius week of hysteria, in Durban, a man who was cheating on his wife is said to have fetched the side-girlfriend he was cheating with and brought her to his house and he shot her, then the wife and finally he shot himself. That story of course did not make much of news and I bet my life it would not have made much news anyways, even if the Oscar media madness were not there.

The incidents of such horror involving black lives are hardly noticed, part of the reason why Anene Booysen’s rape story made the news locally and abroad, save for its brutality (women have had their genitals mutilated across the country in many places), was because it happened at the backdrop of India’s worldwide reported gang rape.

Anene’s incident simply happened at a time whereby the global spotlight was on South Africa’s unbelievable statistics on rape and gender-based violence – it is amazing how when suddenly the perpetrator is white, rich and prominent, the spotlight has shifted and no longer highlights gender-based violence but worries about Oscar assuming status of “a fallen hero”.

If you are reading this piece from a media site, I commend the publishers for not censoring it. As a parting shot, just imagine in your head how the media would be reporting this Pistorius story if the person who shot Reeva was not Oscar but a rich or prominent black man. What if Kenny “Mr Sushi” Kunene was the male involved in this saga? Would the story be told in the same manner? Keep wondering….

Disclaimer: All articles and letters published on MyNews24 have been independently written by members of News24's community. The views of users published on News24 are therefore their own and do not necessarily represent the views of News24. News24 editors also reserve the right to edit or delete any and all comments received. publishes all comments posted on articles provided that they adhere to our Comments Policy. Should you wish to report a comment for editorial review, please do so by clicking the 'Report Comment' button to the right of each comment.

Comment on this story
Comments have been closed for this article.

Read more from our Users

Submitted by
Confidence Seleme
Who's writing your life story?

Just because someone suddenly feels inferior or intimidated because of your progress, it doesn’t mean you must stop progressing. You cannot let someone else write your story for you.  Read more...

0 comments 127 views
Submitted by
Narike Lintvelt
Surviving Metrorail's 'Amazing Ra...

Over the past three weeks I have spent anywhere from three to five hours per day commuting; every day like an Amazing Race challenge to get to work and get home. Read more...

0 comments 736 views
Submitted by
Reginald Nkadimeng
AfriForum has ulterior motive in ...

I think AfriForum is motivated by extreme prejudice in launching this particular case against Julius Malema. Read more...

0 comments 836 views
Submitted by
Sifiso Mkhonto
Black tax: a responsibility, not ...

Many young black professionals are faced with the pressure to redress the legacy of apartheid through black tax. This is their privilege and should not be seen as a burden. Read more...

0 comments 337 views
Bantu education in a post-aparthe...

One of the legacies of apartheid that continues to haunt the black people of South Africa is the legacy of the Bantu Education system. Read more...

0 comments 3171 views
Submitted by
Victor Brink
Implement traffic laws and save l...

Dear Minister Nzimande, please, for the love of our society, protect the people you are responsible for by implementing the laws your department is mandated to uphold. Read more...

0 comments 620 views


RSS feeds News delivered really simply.

E-mail Newsletters You choose what you want

News24 on Android Get the latest from News24 on your Android device.

SMS Alerts Get breaking news stories via SMS.

Interactive Advertising Bureau
© 2018 All rights reserved.
There are new stories on the homepage. Click here to see them.


Create Profile

Creating your profile will enable you to submit photos and stories to get published on News24.

Please provide a username for your profile page:

This username must be unique, cannot be edited and will be used in the URL to your profile page across the entire network.


Location Settings

News24 allows you to edit the display of certain components based on a location. If you wish to personalise the page based on your preferences, please select a location for each component and click "Submit" in order for the changes to take affect.

Facebook Sign-In

Hi News addict,

Join the News24 Community to be involved in breaking the news.

Log in with Facebook to comment and personalise news, weather and listings.