MyNews24 is a user-generated section of The stories here come from users.

Seun wa Moutse
Comments: 8
Article views: 3463
Latest Badges:

View all Seun wa Moutse's badges.

Julius Malema - 1; Thandi Modise – 0

26 June 2014, 09:17

Julius Malema was very impressive last week in Parliament. ANC comrades were not. It’s worth reflecting on what happened, and why the ANC is clearly shaken and stirred.

It is too soon to have a firm overall view of the performance of Economic Freedom Fighters (EFF) in Parliament. Only after enough parliamentary activity has taken place can we assess whether they get the business of parliamentary oversight, and the crucial but arduous task of crafting the best possible laws.

But we had our first sighting when the EFF responded to President Jacob Zuma’s State of the National address last week. And they did very well.

EFF leader Julius Malema delivered an excellent response. At first people were skeptical: they thought he wouldn’t. We were all wrong. If we have a red beret, we would have to eat part of it, and keep the rest for a more final decision about the EFF after enough time has passed. They still have to demonstrate consistency and impact in terms of parliamentary accountability role.

First, and most importantly, the content of the speech was good. It critiqued – quite literally – the president’s analysis of the state of the nation, such as poor economic outcomes achieved (or not achieved) under the watch of President Zuma.

Malema is spot on. You cannot talk about radical socio-economic policies as your galvanizing vision without thereby conceding that until now it has not been a primary aim of your government.

Malema rattled Zuma so much it was left to ANC veteran Yunus Carrim to comically tell us all in his speech what the definition of ‘radical’ is.

It was a desperate two pronged definition to the effect of now drilling down and with renewed focus on the energy. In other words: doing your job as the government is radical. Go figure.

But the point is that Malema was framing the discussion, and that’s debate impact.

The speech was also poignant rhetorically. Any decent debate coach will tell you the best humor is humor that carries insight while getting laughter from an audience. Humour without insight is called a Leon Schuster film. Humour with insight is called The Trevor Noah show. Malema was – and this isn’t always true to him – more Trevor that Leon last week.

The best example is when he made fun of Zuma for asking us to clean up our country in the name of Nelson Mandela. To well-earned laughs, Malema pointed out that the request was the only part of Zuma’s speech during which the old-timer slowed down, looked up and repeated himself, because the rest of the speech was to serious in subject matter for him, Zuma to depart from script!

And for good measure, he added that he had no intention of listening to Zuma because clean-up projects are gimmicks.

He’d rather honour Madiba with a public service project that changes the structural injustices in our communities. Funny and bang on target analytically.

I’m recalling this detail, by the way, not because Malema clearly was memorable for me. I’m also recalling it because the coverage of the speech, especially in the printed media, reduced the speech to a spectacle. That is lazy political reporting.

Even a fake revolutionary, is capable of a good day at the political office.

Which brings me to the main media coverage about Malema’s walkout - The key reporting was simply that he had walked out, with the EFF caucus following suit.

But two points needed to be made in the analysis of that drama. First, Malema gave a compelling response about the ANC government massacring people might seem reasonable.

But that’s too quick. Do we find it unreasonable to say the National Party government killed black kids in Soweto in 1976? No. We are all clear that Verwoerd’s people were responsible for enforcing laws that trampled dignity. The distinction between an NO government and the police officers employed by an NP government holds no water in terms of fair comment.

Malema made the point with great clarity. He pointed out that when the police reduce crime, the ANC want credit as government. So why not also credited with police who commit crime?

But no, the content of this retort was less sexy in the media than repeated footage of the walkout.

This brings me to Modise. I have to credit her for remaining calm, for not taking a decision instantly but sleeping on it. Frankly, if Baleka Mbete had chaired the session, the tone would have been more adversarial.

But Modise got the decision wrong. It’s not a reasonable limitation on free speech in Parliament to ask Malema to withdraw the statement. Firstly, his defense is fair.

Secondly, and more importantly, there is greater space for provocative political dialogue in Parliament than outside it.

In terms of parliamentary privilege, he was within the legal bounds of what can be said in the rough and tumble of parliamentary debate. Her threadbare citing of free speech and limitation clauses masks a deep misunderstanding of the social space afforded MP’s to say the kind of things Malema said.

So the walkout wasn’t diva behavior. It is a case of Julius Malema 1 and Thandi Modise 0.

If there were anyone who should be embarrassed, it is the senior ANC leader, Lindiwe Sisulu, who threw cheap racial insults around and was generally obnoxious rather tan – as Dr Pallo Jorda did – try to win the argument. If Sisulu becomes president I would seriously consider emigrating,

But it’s not just the ANC who should be shaking – providing that Malema remains consistent.

I have spoken on Malema, but also Maimane had his debute speech, when he ironically spoke well. But it is Malema who broke the sound barrier. The competition between opposition parties, though, is as healthy as their collective watching of the ANC.

Who would have thought that channel 408, the parliamentary channel, could become so popular? One business person told me: ‘If that channel was up for sale, I would buy it!”

But he would have to start the hastag#thankyoueff.

Disclaimer: All articles and letters published on MyNews24 have been independently written by members of News24's community. The views of users published on News24 are therefore their own and do not necessarily represent the views of News24. News24 editors also reserve the right to edit or delete any and all comments received. publishes all comments posted on articles provided that they adhere to our Comments Policy. Should you wish to report a comment for editorial review, please do so by clicking the 'Report Comment' button to the right of each comment.

Comment on this story
Comments have been closed for this article.

Read more from our Users

Submitted by
Jan Badenhorst
Matric results in less than a mon...

The matric results for the 2017 matric class will be available to students at their schools, in the newspapers and online, on 5 January 2018. Read more...

0 comments 434 views
Submitted by
Tendani Siala
It is all over for NDZ

All things considered I still say an NDZ win will be nothing short of a miracle. But as we all know miracles rarely happen these days. Read more...

0 comments 6468 views
Submitted by
Balt Verhagen
South Africa IS an exceptional Af...

The present mis-rulers who are everywhere on the run had gone out of their way to repeatedly emphasise that we are ‘just another African state’ thereby showing that they are no worse than the others who failed their people.  Read more...

0 comments 776 views
Submitted by
David Rose
Can you read the situation?

The overwhelming majority of parents are not readers. This is not to say that they cannot read, but that they do not read. Reading is a foreign activity for most parents and this does not help their children's literacy. Read more...

0 comments 97 views
Submitted by
Thandisizwe Mgudlwa
Ramaphosa must lead the 'New Deal...

The New Deal would need to focus on crafting a new path after diagnosing the ills and commit all stakeholders to work together towards the most glorious future for all South Africans. Read more...

0 comments 189 views
Submitted by
Jerry Rodrigues
Cristiano Ronaldo: the greatest f...

It was inevitable - a NEW Cristiano Ronaldo bust has been revealed that actually looks like him. Read more...

0 comments 401 views


RSS feeds News delivered really simply.

E-mail Newsletters You choose what you want

News24 on Android Get the latest from News24 on your Android device.

SMS Alerts Get breaking news stories via SMS.

Interactive Advertising Bureau
© 2017 All rights reserved.
There are new stories on the homepage. Click here to see them.


Create Profile

Creating your profile will enable you to submit photos and stories to get published on News24.

Please provide a username for your profile page:

This username must be unique, cannot be edited and will be used in the URL to your profile page across the entire network.


Location Settings

News24 allows you to edit the display of certain components based on a location. If you wish to personalise the page based on your preferences, please select a location for each component and click "Submit" in order for the changes to take affect.

Facebook Sign-In

Hi News addict,

Join the News24 Community to be involved in breaking the news.

Log in with Facebook to comment and personalise news, weather and listings.