MyNews24 is a user-generated section of The stories here come from users.

Comments: 3
Article views: 1021
Latest Badges:

View all MikeHampton's badges.

Man Beats Knysna Cops in Court

25 July 2014, 13:08
On July 24 2014, Johann Burmeister defeated the controversial case of theft (of a laptop) that was brought against him by the Knysna SAPS. It’s more than just a win. It’s an insight into the failure of police procedure and the abuse of power that is suppose to protect the public. It's confirmation of conspiracy.

On being found not guilty by Magistrate Derek Torlage, tears of relief and joy beautified the faces of both Johann and Denise, his wife who won the hearts of the public as she fought in newspapers and online to clear her husband's name. There were tears of anger too.

The situation smelt from the beginning because the facts available did not add up. Once all the facts were available, in court, they didn't add up either.

The 3 days of court drama carried every human emotion, from on-the-edge-of-your-seat expectation and anger (at witnesses trapping themselves in lies) to frustrating boredom as the the same witnesses seemed to mutter inanities such as "I dunno" (when they should know) a thousand times. Most importantly, there was overwhelming happiness and justifiable self-righteousness at the end.

Day 2 of the trial had Warrant Officer Christopher Appels in the dock first. His shift had followed after Sergeant Maurice Grootboom's and thus he'd signed for the evidence and property. Like Grootboom, he also claimed that Burmeister had the laptop. He then signed everything over to SAP13 clerk, Sergeant Carmen Coetzee who would later claim the same. So did her superior (and also SAP13 clerk) Warrant Officer Abraham Coetzer. Their superior, Captain Patrick Gogwana, followed suite.

Advocate Eduard Bruwer expressed the view of all in the public gallery when he stated that "something smelt rotten" about this case. He emphasised it later with a quote from Hamlet, "Something is rotten in the state of Denmark."

The State's 'witnesses' felt rehearsed; badly rehearsed but rehearsed nonetheless. They all, with the exceptional exception of Captain Michelle Lesch, stated that ex-Warrant Officer Johann Burmeister was trustworthy and honest... and used that as their defense why they failed to follow their "standing orders", the rules and regulations governing their conduct and action.

At the heart of the matter was the definition of "outstanding", a term used on the register to denote property that had not being disposed of e.g. destroyed or returned to its owner. Advocate Bruwer proved unequivocally that it meant not disposed of but still in the possession of the police.  At one point he even stated that "it was too coincidental that Appel's interpretation matched Coetzee's". Captain Lesch, their superior, in detail, confirmed that Bruwer understanding of the word was correct.

The biggest condemnation of five of the witnesses is that they had, at some point, whether in receipt or audit, signed that the laptop was in their possession. Gaining that admittance was a difficult task for Advocate Bruwer who was forced to nauseatingly repeat questions so many times that it's unlikely onlookers will ever forget them. The witnesses dug themselves a hole that they should be prosecuted for.

It was a liar's parade that had onlookers comparing tell-tale signs they noticed such as facial ticks, hand wrenching, looking away and, especially, the constant lowering of voices to inaudibility as their sentences trapped them.

Magistrate Derek Torlage's voice may have sounded emotionless but his words weren't. In his judgement he stated that all of the witnesses, with the exception of Captain Michelle Lesch, had admitted to either fraud or perjury. 

How much has this frivolous case of falsehoods cost the taxpayer? Beyond the case itself, how man police hours were abused and wasted the past 8 months.

Arguably, there was a conspiracy i.e. a bunch of cops broke the rules and supported a clearly false case against Johann Burmeister whilst the evidence pointed at others.

It's uncomfortable add-on facts that senior police from the George Cluster, under which Knysna falls, were involved to some degree, whether by action or association i.e.

1. Colonel Marnewick is the boyfriend of Sergeant Carmen Coetzee, the officer who was far more qualified to be a suspect

2. Colonel Jeffrey Matiwani ordered the case be opened against Burmeister

3. Colonel Derek Daniels, Head of CIF (Criminal Intelligence) appeared in court, allegedly illegally recording proceedings and strangely interacting with Coetzee in the corridor outside. Witnesses said that he seemed like he was coaching her. She stated that he was only a colleague and that he had asked to hug her and she'd given permission. Does that sound like a colleague?

Sergeant Sergeant Coetzee seemed to be getting special treatment. She was left as the last witness and, even then, Prosecuto Thibedi oddly stated, without reason, that it wouldn't be fair if the case continued as there wasn't enough time left. Essentially, he was asking for another court date which would take months to get, this despite the fact that she was coming from out of town and had sat on a hard bench outside the court room for 3 days. Despite the fact that it was only 11.33am! Bruwer immediately counter-attacked by promising Magistrate Torlage that he would finish with Coetzee the same day. He kept his word despite Thibedi, for the first time, questioning her slowly and at length. This was noticeable as he'd likely spent less than 5 minutes on each witness so far. Even the magistrate had spoken longer. Thibedi was out of his trench hole and Bruwer was a bomber.

It must be asked why Thibedi gave this case sufficient merit for it to be prosecuted when it was obvious it had none? Was he ordered to?

After Sergeant Coetzee had finished testifying, admitting to two lies within the first 5 minutes, even Thibedi was forced to admit to Magistrate Torlage that he had no case.

The most blatant missing witness was Colonel Matiwane who, in his own testimony in the internal disciplinary hearing, had stated that he'd made the decision to open the case against Burmeister. Although he should have been a star witness for Prosecutor Thibedi, he wasn't called. Bruwer never called any witnesses as he believed, as was proven, that he'd won the case without them.

The biggest impact, beyond Burmeister's involvement, is that rules and procedure (i.e. the standing orders) are not valued or adhered to in the Knysna SAPS station, from the lowest to the highest rank. The registries are not treated as gospel and events are not being recorded in the Occurrence Book (OB) which is supposed to be the police station's ultimate diary. Particularly, in this case, Sergeant Carmen Coetzee and her superior, Warrant Officer Abrahams Coetzer, must be investigated. Not only is the missing laptop in question but what happened with a R16 000 gold armband too. These disturbing situations will give weight to rumours that cops are selling stolen goods in Knysna.

This case is going to keep tongues wagging and reinforce the public's distrust in the police. The hope of many is that this will force an investigation into the running of the station, with subsequent punishment and leadership replacement returning justice to the streets of Knysna. However, there are even more who believe that this telling event will be whitewashed.

Disclaimer: All articles and letters published on MyNews24 have been independently written by members of News24's community. The views of users published on News24 are therefore their own and do not necessarily represent the views of News24. News24 editors also reserve the right to edit or delete any and all comments received. publishes all comments posted on articles provided that they adhere to our Comments Policy. Should you wish to report a comment for editorial review, please do so by clicking the 'Report Comment' button to the right of each comment.

Comment on this story
Comments have been closed for this article.

Read more from our Users

Submitted by
Annette Nel
Water crisis: City of Cape Town h...

Unluckily, the toilets have to be flushed or epidemics will be the next problem. I understand the drought, but I'm sorry, you as government have left it to late. Read more...

0 comments 3105 views
Submitted by
Shaun Nel752
Fees aren't everything

Higher levels of employment and university graduates that have the necessary skills for employment both locally and abroad is not impossible.  Read more...

0 comments 308 views
Submitted by
Lawrence Fengu
Dealing with Zimbabwe's fault lin...

Zimbabwe has been a ticking time bomb for almost two decades and, in that period, SADC actions have merely been a futile exercise of papering over the cracks. Read more...

0 comments 249 views
Submitted by
Ken Sibanda
Why Robert Mugabe should not agre...

Military rule in Africa has done nothing but cause continued human suffering in all parts of the world. Read more...

0 comments 5565 views
Submitted by
Michelle Swanepoel
Praise for Mugabe is baffling

The country is run by fear. If you want too look at a father of independence, then look at Mandela. Read more...

0 comments 1310 views
Submitted by
Langa Khumalo
The Last Massacre, Zimbabwe's im...

The final pieces have been set, the fool's show goes on and the horror that is about to happen in Zimbabwe will be historical if not biblical. Read more...

0 comments 3880 views


RSS feeds News delivered really simply.

E-mail Newsletters You choose what you want

News24 on Android Get the latest from News24 on your Android device.

SMS Alerts Get breaking news stories via SMS.

Interactive Advertising Bureau
© 2017 All rights reserved.
There are new stories on the homepage. Click here to see them.


Create Profile

Creating your profile will enable you to submit photos and stories to get published on News24.

Please provide a username for your profile page:

This username must be unique, cannot be edited and will be used in the URL to your profile page across the entire network.


Location Settings

News24 allows you to edit the display of certain components based on a location. If you wish to personalise the page based on your preferences, please select a location for each component and click "Submit" in order for the changes to take affect.

Facebook Sign-In

Hi News addict,

Join the News24 Community to be involved in breaking the news.

Log in with Facebook to comment and personalise news, weather and listings.