PLEASE NOTE:

MyNews24 is a user-generated section of News24.com. The stories here come from users.

 
Sean Brennan
 
Comments: 88
Article views: 0
 
 
Latest Badges:


 
View all Sean Brennan's badges.
 

Science lessons for atheists

10 July 2015, 12:57

Space

Throughout history the misuse of the concept of space has wreaked havoc in physics. Judging by the many strange comments on articles at MyNews24, confusion about this insidious ‘thing’ called space is rife.


Before I begin, I wish to state unequivocally that space is nothing.  I also wish to also state that I am not saying that there are no known or as yet undiscovered particles in our universe amongst the spaces between larger entities.


To understand how we think of space, let us look at the history of the concept.

The ancient Greeks had assumed that the universe was finite. But when the Greek atomists put forth the idea of empty space as a separate reality, distinct from matter, they were driven to accept the idea of an infinite universe. For what could possibly limit the extent of empty space?

If empty space was nothing and yet a reality, there didn’t seem any sense to the claim that it could stop. After all, nothingness has no edge or boundary, so what could possibly stop, or end? Those clever Greeks didn’t want to look like idiots and say that the nothingness only extended so far and beyond that; was really, really nothing,(like their present economic situation)


Go to this link, and ask yourself; what is all that black stuff, outside of the galaxies, stars and space that surrounds this artists inflating universe depiction?

http://cdn.phys.org/newman/gfx/news/hires/2015/bigbang.jpg

Many misconceptions arise because the people that study our universe have to think of it as an entity in order to get their heads around this thing and depict it as such to explain their theories.

I think that they cause more confusion than anything else when it comes to the common man’s understanding of the concept of the universe. Does keeping the common man happy and correctly informed rank very highly on theoretical physicists agendas?


It was Aristotle that recognized that we do not start off with the concept of empty space. We rather start off by observing entities, (objects), their relative arrangement, and the changes in the arrangement. These observations then give rise to the concept of place, or position. The concept of space then merely means a sum of places.


Let’s look at an example. You have an empty room, and you ask your wife what she wants to do with the space. This is a perfectly valid use of the concept of space. What you mean is; you have a sum of places; how are we going to place items in respect to one another within the surrounding walls of the room. What you definitely don’t mean is; that we have space here, do we want to move this space to the kitchen, where more space would be handier, or should we leave it where it is!


This example may sound stupid, but Aristotle showed that it was this very same silliness that characterized his predecessor’s views on space. They treated space as if it were a thing with its own separate existence apart from bodies. What really is happening; is that the concept of space derives from the earlier concept of place, which refers to relationships among physical entities. Space does not exist apart from bodies (objects), simply because relationships do not exist apart from entities that are related. The distance between the tip of your nose and your screen as you read this, is a space.


What exists, are entities, (objects). Attributes, actions and relationships are attributes, actions and relationships of entities. Talk of empty space that exists independently of entities makes no more sense than talk of movement without things that move, or colour without things that are coloured. There are no regions containing disembodied relationships; a place is always a place of something.


In addition to rejecting the idea of a void, Aristotle rejected the possibility of actual existing infinities. Infinity is not a quantity; it implies the existence of something indefinite, without identity. To say that there are an infinite number of atoms, or an infinite amount of space, makes no more sense than to say that you have a jar of sweets that contains no particular number of sweets. To be; is to be something in particular - so infinity is out. “The universe”, is a finite term. This is the essence of Aristotle’s view, whom I think had it all pretty much worked out and correct.


Later on in history we find claims being made as to the attributes that space is said to possess. See if you recognize these attributes. It is independent of matter; it is ubiquitous, but not perceived; it is infinite, eternal and immutable. Now where have we heard this before? Does this remind you of anyone? Think on this, it doesn’t’ have to be someone you know personally :) Yip, you got it - God. Is this just another name for the concept of nothing?


If you think of the universe, as you would of an apple, or the artists impression of the mathematical big bang model you viewed, with nothingness around all of the stars and galaxies; with you sitting there ‘outside’ looking in on it, you have a really lousy concept of the universe. You are taking a perspective of being outside of ‘everything’; this is not a helpful picture. Where would you even get an idea like this?


This is what William Lane Craig and other theists do when making their Kalam argument claims, where they conclude;” Therefor the universe was created by an uncaused cause outside of space and time ”. How can these people rationally take a perspective of anything being outside of the universe? Don’t their followers and fans think?


What could the boundary of man’s concept of everything possibly be made of, for these idiots to claim the existence of an “outside”? Lines an artist has drawn of a mathematical concept? Did they spend too long staring at women’s breasts?


The universe is the total of that which exists—not merely the earth or the stars or the galaxies, but everything. The word ‘universe’ defines what we humans refer to as everything. Obviously then, there can be no such thing as the “cause” of the universe, or something outside, of the universe.


The universe is not a philosophical entity. It does not exist as a being. Rather the universe is the conceptual set of all material beings. The claim that ‘the universe had a beginning’ implies that the universe is both an entity in itself and an entity humanly knowable as an entity in itself. It is not, if you believe it to be, then please direct us to a diagram or drawing of this thing called a universe which we all recognize as such.


No one claims that the universe is now an entity in itself. No human has even sense knowledge of the universe as a thing. The universe, as the set of material things, is an abstract concept, not an entity of human experience and knowledge.


If something is said to be ‘outside’, like this proposed God; this God must be a something, rather than a nothing, and must be somewhere, rather than nowhere. It is then obvious that the proposed entity, (God) is a distance away from something else, (that is part of everything). Therefore the static distance between these entities becomes space and part of “the - everything”, which we refer to as the universe.

Do theists realize that they credit their God for building an eternal prison that He himself cannot escape from?


Is the universe then unlimited in size? No. Everything which exists is finite, including the universe. What then, you ask, is outside the universe, if it is finite? This question is invalid. The phrase “outside the universe” has no referent.

The universe is everything. “Outside the universe” stands for and means “that which is where everything isn’t.” There is no such place. There isn’t even – nothing, “out there”: there is no -“out there.”


As science has pushed on in its understanding, theists have moved their God from a place called heaven in the sky above the Promised Land,(a rocky barren dry place in the middle east without oil) ; to what they foolishly believe is a safe place, that is not a place at all, a place away from rational inquiry.


I do not know whether, “a God” exists or not. But what I can be sure of is that the God of William Lane Craig and others that is claimed to exist outside of space and time cannot exist. This is not something we must merely believe, we can actually KNOW it, because it is impossible that such an irrational thing exists, as impossible and irrational as the existence of cubic spheres.

Next i will look into Einstein’s space, and the concepts of space-time and fields.

References:

http://faculty.arts.ubc.ca/ssavitt/Courses/Phil462A/Aristotle%20on%20Space.pdf

What is Space by David Harriman. (Lecture/adaptation)

 https://einstein.stanford.edu/index.html

Leonard Peikoff. “Philosophy: Who Needs It” (book)

http://www.catholicstand.com/kalam-cosmological-argument-fails/

Disclaimer: All articles and letters published on MyNews24 have been independently written by members of News24's community. The views of users published on News24 are therefore their own and do not necessarily represent the views of News24. News24 editors also reserve the right to edit or delete any and all comments received.

 

24.com publishes all comments posted on articles provided that they adhere to our Comments Policy. Should you wish to report a comment for editorial review, please do so by clicking the 'Report Comment' button to the right of each comment.

Comment on this story
88 comments
Comments have been closed for this article.

Read more from our Users

Submitted by
Just Say It!
At last a president and finance m...

I have long maintained that a country like this deserves only the very best leaders, and at last things seem encouraging. Read more...

0 comments 1644 views
Submitted by
Frank Hubbit
Does the Office of the Public Pro...

In 2012 my adopted son, then 15 years old, told me that he had been sexually assaulted at school by a male teacher. To this day the public protector has not been helpful. Read more...

0 comments 657 views
Submitted by
Sorna Govender
Caster – you're a winner

We South Africans will support you overwhelmingly and without any hesitation in your appeal process. Read more...

0 comments 284 views
Submitted by
Ken Everett
The rainbow nation: One but divid...

It is my fundamental belief that everyone is 'sectarian', to a lesser or greater degree, either by nature or by nurture. Anyone who denies this is quite simply a liar. Read more...

0 comments 367 views
Submitted by
Sir-Vincent Mathosse
The only gift I'll accept from Ra...

The only notable achievement of ubaba Zuma’s government from my perspective was his ability to contain the HIV virus and the reduction of deaths as previously stated.  Read more...

0 comments 517 views
Submitted by
Michael Holmes
A sober look at the election opti...

In the Western Cape, we have the lowest unemployment figures and the cleanest governments in the whole of the country. Read more...

0 comments 3996 views
 

services

Press Code We subscribe to the Press Code.

E-mail Newsletters You choose what you want

News24 on Android Get the latest from News24 on your Android device.

Terms and Conditions 24.com Terms and Conditions - Updated April 2012

 
Interactive Advertising Bureau
 
© 2019 24.com. All rights reserved.
There are new stories on the homepage. Click here to see them.
 
English
Afrikaans
isiZulu

Hello 

Create Profile

Creating your profile will enable you to submit photos and stories to get published on News24.


Please provide a username for your profile page:

This username must be unique, cannot be edited and will be used in the URL to your profile page across the entire 24.com network.

Settings

Location Settings

News24 allows you to edit the display of certain components based on a location. If you wish to personalise the page based on your preferences, please select a location for each component and click "Submit" in order for the changes to take affect.




Facebook Sign-In

Hi News addict,

Join the News24 Community to be involved in breaking the news.

Log in with Facebook to comment and personalise news, weather and listings.