Cyber bully gets jail over photos

2011-01-19 08:33

Philadelphia - A cyber bully who forwarded explicit online photos of a teenage boy to the teen's school was sentenced to 45 days in federal prison on Tuesday.

Matthew Bean, 20, was part of an "electronic mob" trying to drive the boy to suicide, federal prosecutors charged. The victim staved off the humiliation and is now in college, authorities said.

US District Judge Anita Brody nonetheless called the crime "extremely malicious", and hoped it would teach the victim and others "the stupidity of sexting".

The teen victim had posted the sexually explicit photos of himself when he was 12 or 13. They surfaced five years later on a dubious website that had caught Bean's interest, the FBI said.

Members of the site worked to identify the naked teen. Bean admitted he then forwarded the photos to teachers and administrators at the teen's Philadelphia-area school in January 2009, posing as a school parent concerned "about such beastly behaviour".


The private school, which was not identified, called authorities who tracked down the sender.

"I hadn't really cared about myself for a long time," Bean told Brody before she sentenced him on Tuesday. "I know that my embarrassment, the embarrassment I brought my family, is nothing compared to the pain I caused him."

The victim was not in court.

Prosecutors compare the case to the Rutgers University student who killed himself in September after his roommate allegedly used a webcam to spy on his sexual encounter and the Missouri woman charged in a MySpace hoax directed at a 13-year-old girl who committed suicide.

"You have to be blind to what's going on in this world not to know the effect of cyber bullying on present-day society," Brody said.

The web group involved in Bean's case posted taunts about the victim, including "let's make this kid want to die", according to court papers.

Bean had been adopted from Guatemala as a baby into a high-achieving family - his grandfather led the real-estate section of a major Philadelphia law firm and his father is a real-estate executive. He struggled in school, used drugs and fought with his parents, who sent him to several intensive, out-of-state programmes, his father said.

"Although he has enormous resentment, we felt we were doing this to keep him safe," George Bean testified on his son's behalf.

Fleeting clicks

The son had faced five years under the initial child pornography indictment, and 18 to 24 months under the negotiated stalking plea. Assistant US Attorney Michael Levy did not push for that long of a term, but asked for at least some incarceration.

The judge agreed, while acknowledging concerns about the safety of the slightly built, young-looking defendant in prison. She did not object to an alternative placement as long as it was a custodial setting. Bean must then remain on federal probation for five years.

Defence lawyer Donald J Goldberg called the crime a few fleeting clicks of the computer, albeit ones that would haunt Bean all his life.

In a cyber bullying case in Florida this week, two teenage girls were charged with creating a Facebook account in a classmate's name and posting a faked nude photograph of her. They each face a felony charge of aggravated stalking under a 2008 state law passed after a student suicide blamed on bullying.

The victim was ridiculed by classmates after the pages became active, authorities said.

Bean, in a court-ordered psychiatric exam, explained why it was easier to bully someone online.

"The internet seemed safer to me, not as dangerous as handing out the photo at someone's school where you might get punched," he said. "We weren't thinking. We were reacting, the beehive mind."

"Like a riot, people were just joining in and going with the flow," Bean said, according to court papers.

  • Anarchy - 2011-01-19 09:40

    Public whippings will sort all these idiots out.

      only.fools.fall.for.419 - 2011-01-19 10:20

      fair call

      Janaman - 2011-01-19 10:59

      if you can prove that they really wanted to drive the teen to suicide then i would say this is a attempted murder and thus the sentence should be according, but the whipping idea i like!

  • Logs01 - 2011-01-19 09:59

    This makes me think of some of these "trolls", 'trouble instigaters' and a$$^*/#s that like to stir emotions, "create" trouble, arguments and fuel racism whenever they can, with their so called "comments' on the news24 forums. Makes them "feel" like "men" when they have a keyboard in their hands, but cannot be touched or identified. They think they are "the man" when commenting while hiding behind a screen and keyboard, that gives them 'balls" and makes them feel SO "strong". They are nothing more than spineless wimps that will shit themselves and run, the first time you say "Boo" to them.

      LJ Graey - 2011-01-19 10:48

      That's kinda rich coming from someone who's clearly just as anonymous as those he/she is trying to ridicule, don't you think?

  • Sythe - 2011-01-19 10:18

    Cyber bullying/sexting....the new trend it seems. Do not ever post compromising photo's of yourself on the will come back to get you. And don't give young kids fancy phones with access to net etc.. unless they are closely monitored. Thank you.

  • only.fools.fall.for.419 - 2011-01-19 10:52

    what about racist ranting on News24 commentaries? Surely that's just as evil a menace to decent folk.... just like cyber-bullies are cowards hiding behind the anonymity of the web, so too do racists use the cover of News24 to air views that would not be acceptable public statements in any civilised country. i agree with Logs01 - real men don't need to hide. Stand by your convictions in public, at least you'll be respected

      Schmalcolm - 2011-01-19 14:16

      It's a tough line to call. Sometimes extreme points of view can enhance public debate. It's the limited moderation of news24 that compels me to respond and add comments. To compare this to posting a minor's naked picture online without consent, is not really relatable

  • pages:
  • 1