NPC warns SA on cost of nuclear power

2012-08-15 14:36

Cape Town - The National Planning Commission in its revised plan repeats a warning on the cost of nuclear power, government's preferred alternative to fossil fuels, and instead advocates a diverse mix of energy sources.

The plan, handed to President Jacob Zuma in Parliament on Wednesday, advocates investigating shale and coal bed methane reserves as a cheaper alternative.

"If gas reserves are proven, and environmental concerns alleviated, then development of these resources and gas-to-power projects should be fast-tracked," it states.

"Even if economically recoverable resources are much lower than currently estimated, shale gas as a transitional fuel has the potential to contribute a very large proportion of South Africa's electricity needs."

The commission also calls for building the necessary infrastructure to import liquefied natural gas, and for an increase in hydro-power imports from the region.

Renewable energy

The update of the original plan released in November, largely confirms its original predictions of the energy targets the country needs to meet by 2030. This includes acquiring at least 20 000MW of renewable energy, and decommissioning 11 000MW of ageing coal-fired power stations.

It says the renewable component, which will supplement Eskom's added generation capacity of 10 000MW, should include gas, wind, solar, imported hydro-electricity and lastly, "possibly a nuclear programme from about 2023".

In response to widening concern about the country's ageing distribution network, and a maintenance backlog of some R35bn, the commission proposes ring-fencing the distribution business of the country's 12 largest municipalities and developing a finance plan to tackle refurbishment gaps.

It further proposes that Eskom take over the electricity distribution functions of poor, struggling municipalities, but allow medium-sized municipalities that are doing reasonably well to continue distributing.

The commission concedes that electricity prices will have to continue to rise to enable Eskom to service its debt and expand its operations. Government, it says, is close to the limits of fiscal support it can give the utility.

To protect economic growth, the commission calls on the national regulator Nersa to "create a smooth path over a longer term" so that consumers face more predictable and manageable tariff hikes.

It maintains its call for an economy-wide carbon tax, but acknowledges that Eskom and Nersa will have no option but to pass the cost of such a measure on to captive consumers.


It says a carbon tax will have to go hand in hand with exemptions in some sectors, including a conditional reprieve to the electricity sector provided it progressively moves to a lower fossil fuel mix.

The plan also turns its attention to electricity use in the mining sector, which has seen its contribution to GDP drop to only 6% in 2010.

It cites research that shows mining output can be increased, while, at the same time, be made less electricity intensive.

It warns that beneficiation of mineral resources is highly energy intensive and therefore not necessarily a panacea for the economy.

"As long as electricity is scarce, there will be a trade-off between beneficiation and other more labour-absorbing activities."

The commission forecasts that despite difficulties surrounding the sector, it should be able to create about 300 000 new jobs, including indirect jobs.

  • georgina.orwell.1 - 2012-08-15 15:12

    Penny wise, pound foolish.

      alan.gernet - 2012-08-15 15:20

      or in this case - just Foolish

  • spookhuis - 2012-08-15 16:06

    Will all these people please make up their minds...shale gas = fracking = more protests = 'we will wait forever to get power from our pre-paid meters. We are not Japan and do not have the same geo problems they do.

      Werewabbit - 2012-08-15 16:46

      Spookhuis I couldn't agree more: Japan has 4 huge fault lines running through it, while our nearest is 1000's of kms away. stick a plant up the west coast somewhere far from major centres- unlike Koberg- and I would be more than happy. never understood how they can call Gas "renewable"

  • Justin.D.Glenn - 2012-08-15 16:25

    Jacob Zuma does not listen to anything the advisers say. He just does his own thing wether it is good for the country.

  • pages:
  • 1