Storm over skin colour app

2010-07-15 13:16

New Delhi - A Vaseline face-whitening application for Facebook in India has sparked an online controversy and pushed the racially-loaded issue of skin colour out into the spotlight.

Anglo-Dutch skincare group Vaseline launched the application "Transform Your Face On Facebook" to promote its range of skin-lightening products for men, advertised by Bollywood star Shahid Kapoor.

It enables users to digitally whiten their profile pictures and remove dark spots - an idea that has evoked a largely negative response in the blogosphere since news broke earlier this week.

"Vaseline's latest marketing campaign, largely targeted at south Asia but accessible globally, will probably make you uncomfortable," wrote columnist Alexis Madrigal on the website of US magazine The Atlantic.

"Modern humans' desire to make their skin darker or lighter is a rather icky reminder of the pigment-o-cracy that exists in many countries."

Cultural preference

The market for skin-lightening cream in India is estimated to be worth about $500m a year by market research group Nielsen. Sales of products for men grew by 25% in 2009 and by 17% for women.

The first cream for women was launched 27 years ago, while the Indian cosmetics group Emami was the first to see potential in the male market in 2005 when it launched "Fair and Handsome" with Bollywood superstar Shah Rukh Khan.

"The adverts play with the minds of men," said Radhakrishnan Nair, the editor of Indian men's magazine MW. "The message they send is: 'If you have fair skin, you will get a good job, a promotion and a beautiful and faithful wife'."

The matrimonial adverts that appear in Indian newspapers are also a vivid illustration of the cultural preference for paleness. A widely-understood lexicon has been developed to talk about skin tone.

Somebody described as having a "wheaten" complexion is lighter in skin tone than somebody who is "dusky". It is commonplace to comment on someone who is beautiful and "very fair" in the same breath.

In shops for passport photos, the camera operator will frequently offer a "free lightening service" when the pictures are processed and printed.

"Indians believe that if you have fair skin you belong to the higher caste, the Brahmins," he added, explaining that a succession of light-skinned colonisers in India reinforced the association of fairness with power.

"The Aryans, who came from central Asia, in addition to the Portuguese, the French and the British colonisers ruled over the country and probably contributed to this negative perception of dark-skin."


The marketing campaigns for creams by Emami and other foreign brands such as Vaseline, Garnier or L'Oreal clearly reinforce the notion of whiteness and beauty.

Market-leader Emami has run into fierce criticism for its not-so-subtle advertising of "Fair & Lovely" for women and "Fair & Teen" for teenagers.

A campaign in 2003 featuring a dark-skinned woman who was unable to get married was branded "highly racist" by Brinda Karat, general secretary of the All India Democratic Women's Association.

The campaign was probably reflecting views held privately by many Indian women, however, particularly in the north of the country.

In 2009, a poll of nearly 12 000 people by online dating site, revealed that skin tone was considered the most important criterion when choosing a partner in three northern Indian states.

Creams range in price from about a dollar to $40 and can be bought in most pharmacies in India. They work by targeting melanin, the skin pigment that absorbs darkening UV light, and are not thought to pose a health risk.

"Face bleach" and frightening sounding "acid peels" are also widely sold across the subcontinent.

Ashu Kumar, 24, is one of the latest customers. The student began using the cream a few weeks ago and hopes to see a result in the next month, as promised by the manufacturer.

"My skin is too dark," he said. "If I don't make it fairer, I'm worried I'll have trouble finding a woman to marry me."

  • TurboChris - 2010-07-15 14:53

    I'm white and wouldn't mind having a tanned skin, does that make me racists? The fact is dark people want to be lighter, light people want to be a be a darker. People with curly hair want straight hair and people with straight hair want curly hair. Ladies with small breasts want bigger breasts and ladies with big breasts want smaller breasts. People will never be happy with their looks, it's not racist it's body image. The ads might be insensitive but the issue is perceptions and self body image not race.

  • RabidNick - 2010-07-15 15:10

    I agree with TurboChris whole heartedly. Everything is always made out to be a race issue, when its not really. All this hype about racism around the world is just making race become more of an issue... just my 2c.

  • Harsh - 2010-07-15 15:53

    Agreed with TurboChris - it has nothing to do with racism. Just let it be.

  • pages:
  • 1