Study: Smoker's lung better than none

2012-05-29 08:25

London - Patients who need new lungs are better off getting donated organs from smokers than none at all, even though they probably won't live as long as those who get a lung transplant from a non-smoker, a new study says.

Researchers say patients will survive longer if they are willing to accept lungs from anyone, including smokers. In Britain, that's a key issue, for about 40% of donated lungs come from people who have previously smoked.

Yet in recent years, several cases of British patients dying after getting lungs from smokers have sparked calls for the policy to be overhauled.

Doctors behind the new study said changing the UK transplant system would be wrong and lead to a spike in the number of people dying while waiting for donated lungs.

"That could deny patients the opportunity to get help," said Dr James Neuberger, associate medical director of the Queen Elizabeth Hospital in Birmingham and one of the study's authors.

Replacement lungs

Neuberger and colleagues analysed information from the UK Transplant Registry and the Office of National Statistics on the survival rates of 2 181 adult British patients waiting for lung transplants between 1999 and 2010. About two in five of those transplants came from smokers.

They found that patients who got lungs from smokers were about 46% more likely to die within three years after getting the replacement lungs compared to patients who got the organs from non-smokers.

But they had a 21% lower chance of dying versus people who were still on the waiting list. The research was published online on Tuesday in the journal, Lancet.

In the US, doctors also use lungs from smokers, although Dr Norman Edelman, the chief medical officer for the American Lung Association, didn't have any data on how often that happens. The US and the UK have similar overall smoking rates of about 20%.

Some experts said it wasn't realistic to expect organ donor systems to refuse lungs from smokers because the demand is such that nearly every usable lung is transplanted. The key issues in lung transplants involve the size of the lung and the donor's blood type, which must match the recipients.

"There is rarely an 'ideal' organ available," he said.

Most organs have defects based on factors like underlying disease or the age and circumstances of the donor's death.


"A smoker donor is really just one more factor to consider," he said in an e-mail.

In the UK, advocates have called for patients to be given more information about organ donors before accepting a transplant.

In 2010, the family of a 28-year-old woman with cystic fibrosis lodged a complaint when she died a year after getting lungs from someone who had smoked for three decades. They said she had not been told and would have been horrified to get a smoker's lungs.

Neuberger said patients had the right to refuse lungs from smokers as long as they understood the implications.

"I'd rather take the lungs from a smoker than get no lungs at all," he said.

  • spookhuis - 2012-05-29 09:27

    I read the head line and thought daaa. If they get none they die. And it took researchers how long to work that one out. (sigh)

  • KeenanMag - 2012-05-29 10:02

    Let's see... Smokers lungs? No lungs? Smokers lungs? No lungs? Smokers lungs? No lungs? Well done, researchers! I would NEVER have thought of that! :-|

  • Chris - 2012-05-29 11:35

    The research basically counts all the people who accepted smoker's lung or lungs to those who waited for a non-smoker's lung or lungs, and found out what the odds of those who died because they waited for non-smokers lungs.

  • Fredster - 2012-05-29 11:54

    If you get the lungs of a smoker, would you want to have a siggi? even if you never smoked?

      ludlowdj - 2012-05-29 15:34

      I doubt it? anyone have any facts?

      Jaco - 2012-05-30 13:31

      of course not, the addiction has nothing to do with your lungs

      Jaco - 2012-05-30 13:33

      the addiction is in your brain, your lungs absorb nicotine, blood travels to your brain and has a stimulating pleasure effect which you get addicted to. also influences your dopamine levels which cause withdrawal like symptoms when you quit. if the question was a joke, i apologize for explaining you never know in this country

  • ludlowdj - 2012-05-29 15:32

    Very true, if you don't accept lungs from a smoker then accept you will most probably die before lungs are found for you. If the lungs are in better condition than what you have whats the problem.

  • pages:
  • 1