Time to regulate lobbyists

2019-11-13 06:00

HOW do we distinguish a non-government organisation (NGO) from a lobby institution?

In South Africa it is difficult to make this distinction because our laws do not define a lobby institution. All we know is that NGOs generally act in the public interest, and often on behalf of those who are vulnerable.

Beyond this it is difficult to tell. The majority of NGOs fit the profile of acting in the public interest, yet they can do some lobbying, as recently alleged.

Before resigning from his position as the leader of the Democratic Alliance, Mmusi Maimane criticised the Institute of Race Relations (IRR), an NGO, for “trying to influence internal politics” of the DA.

In Maimane’s view, the IRR as a NGO is not supposed to influence internal party matters, including the outcome of leadership contests. Because it expresses preferences and works towards its realisation, Maimane regards the IRR as a lobby group.

The IRR was not happy with that characterisation; it is only AfriForum that seems to embrace being labelled a lobby group. Other organisations tend to view the term lobby in a negative way.

I am not very interested in the specific story of the IRR. What interests me is that in the complicated political system that involves non-government actors, including not-for-profit foundations, it is important that we are clear as to which organisation should be recognised as what.

Having worked in the NGO sector in the past, I am aware that this is a sensitive area given the high level of mistrust in our politics. I am of the view that the majority of NGOs and foundations fall within the category of institutions that are concerned with the public interest.

However, as our democracy advances, we should address the issue of organisations that propagate a chosen policy position, perhaps even a legislation, while receiving funds for achieving a set of agreed upon political goals. Such organisations would fall within the category of lobbyists.

The word lobby is not really part of South Africa’s policy discourse. The Collins Dictionary defines it “as someone who tries actively to persuade a government or council that a particular law should be changed or that a particular thing should be done”.

When it comes to lobbying, the work entails the achievement of a specific set of results; it can be legislation or an internal party leadership outcome. Lobbyists commit to specific results, hence they are often hired for a specified job that requires specific results.

Currently, any organisation can undertake the work of lobbyists, although our system and laws do not recognise political lobbying as a profession that needs to be regulated.

Political lobbying for specific political goals will certainly continue in South Africa, which means we need to regulate the conduct and the sector.

With the increasing use of money in politics, it will be necessary to distinguish lobbyist organisations or institutions from NGOs concerned with the public interest.

Soon we will need laws that regulate lobbying work and activities in our politics. It would be tragic if South Africa failed to recognise that different laws and even tax rules should apply to lobbying organisations, while NGOs should be exempt from such.

For South Africa to effect transparency when it comes to the use of money in politics, lobbyists will have to be regulated and identified properly. This is necessary to protect the integrity of our democracy and to ensure that voters always understand who is funding or sponsoring political campaigns pursued by lobbyists. If we do not regulate political lobbying, we might have to ban it altogether.

It will be difficult, if not impossible, to ban lobbying in politics; it is more realistic to consider wider regulation. If lobbying is not regulated, it will negatively impact on democracy, particularly the relationship between voters and political parties.

• Dr Ralph Mathekga is a political analyst and author of When Zuma Goes and Ramaphosa’s Turn.


Inside News24


Matric Results are coming soon!

Notify me when results become available

Traffic Alerts
There are new stories on the homepage. Click here to see them.


Create Profile

Creating your profile will enable you to submit photos and stories to get published on News24.

Please provide a username for your profile page:

This username must be unique, cannot be edited and will be used in the URL to your profile page across the entire 24.com network.