Dewani cop queried about statement

2012-09-11 20:29

Cape Town - A police officer was queried on Tuesday about his phrasing of a question while taking a statement from a man accused of killing Anni Dewani.

Captain Adolf Jonker was asked in the Western Cape High Court why he had amended the standard question about whether Xolile Mngeni first wanted to consult a lawyer.

In a video shown to court, Jonker was seen asking Mngeni whether he wanted to consult with a lawyer before carrying on, "or continue with the statement".

Mngeni had replied: "I want to continue making the statement."

Jonker said he altered the question to make it easy for the accused to understand.


Qalisile Dayimani put it to the court that the addition at the end of the sentence "induced" his client into making a statement.

The statement forms part of a trial-within-a-trial, in which the judge must decide whether the State can admit the statement as evidence to be used later in the trial.

The defence argued the statement was made under duress and questioned the authenticity of a video showing Mngeni making the statement.

Dewani was killed in Gugulethu on 13 November 2010, in an apparent hijacking while on honeymoon with her husband Shrien.

Mngeni has pleaded not guilty to charges of kidnapping, robbery with aggravating circumstances, murder, and illegal possession of a firearm and ammunition.


Jonker was asked whether the translator he used to interpret the Xhosa admission was qualified.

He replied that the translator was referred by investigating officer Captain Paul Hendrikse. He was happy with the way the translator had conveyed his questions to Mngeni.

The lawyer asked if Jonker had requested the translator's appointment certificate.

Jonker said he had not. He had looked only at his police identification.

Earlier in the day, the court watched a video of Mngeni making his statement, in which he described the details of a hijacking in Gugulethu.

He said he got a lift to the tourist spot Mzoli's, in Gugulethu, on the evening of 13 November 2010, and walked with a man named "Mawewe" to a nearby fourway-stop.

He was "taking a leak" when Mawewe saw a vehicle and shouted to him: "There it is".

Begged for their lives

Mawewe stood in the middle of the road, pointed a gun at the car and beckoned the driver to stop.

He sat in the front passenger seat while Mawewe drove the vehicle.

Mngeni told Jonker that a "white man and woman" were sitting on the back seat.

"They said please don't kill us... They took out two phones and a camera. I told them: 'You are not going to be killed'."

Mngeni said he asked Mawewe: "What are we going to do with these two people?"

Mawewe replied that he would separate the couple. At this point, the "white man" apparently said he could not be dropped off alone, because "this is his wife".

The vehicle came to a stop and Mawewe shouted to the man: "Voetsek, voetsek, get out, get out".


His wife then started crying.

They drove off again and stopped a while later in Kuyasa.

Mngeni said Mawewe tried to take a small bag from the woman, but she held onto it.

He heard a gunshot, and asked Mawewe what had caused him to fire.

Mawewe told Mngeni he could not tell him what to do and they got into an argument.

The vehicle was eventually abandoned in Ilitha Park.

Mngeni said they saw two policemen and ran away, hiding the phones and camera in a nearby bush.

The trial resumes on Wednesday.

  • lynda.pitcher.1 - 2012-09-11 21:03

    With all these clever lawyers working their magic i wonder if we will ever find out the truth and if justice will eventually be sorry for her family listening to all this crap

      jo.barton.92 - 2012-09-12 08:00

      You cannot have a conscience and be a lawyer at the same time.I really hope her family has the strength to go through with this.

  • zukie.mqwishi - 2012-09-12 20:09

    We need to understand that lawyers has a duty to do their job accompanied by presumption of innocent and prosecutors with their duty accompanied by proving criminal case beyond any reasonable doubt , so no one to blame but one must do his or her job. Z J Mqhwishi [Attorney]

  • pages:
  • 1