Dewani murder-accused tortured - lawyer

2012-09-17 16:26

Cape Town - A man on trial for Anni Dewani's murder was assaulted and tortured in the basement of a police building, the Western Cape High Court heard on Monday.

Xolile Mngeni was led to the basement of the Directorate of Priority Crime Investigation building in Bellville shortly after his arrest on November 16 2010 his lawyer Qalisile Dayimani claimed.

It was there that his hands were cuffed to the back of the chair and he was "severely assaulted and beaten by Constable Mbali".

"It was at this basement where the accused had his testicles slammed into the drawer of a desk that was there... and had an evidence bag placed over his head and was suffocated," the lawyer told the court.

Mngeni is on trial for the hijacking, robbery, and murder of Dewani in Gugulethu on November 13 2010. She and her husband Shrien were on honeymoon at the time.

Trial within a trial

The policeman who arrested Mngeni, Lieutenant Colonel Bonginkosi Kwinana, was under cross-examination by the defence.

Kwinana's testimony forms part of a trial-within-a-trial to determine whether a "confession" by Mngeni can be admitted as evidence.

The police officer repeatedly denied the assertions of assault put to him by the defence.

Kwinana said that, to the best of his knowledge, Mngeni had never been in any basement. He was also not assaulted while in his presence, which happened to be most of that morning before he was placed back in the holding cells.

Dayimani said it was his instruction that Mngeni was taken from the basement to a vehicle, to show officers where his accomplice "Mawewe" stayed.

"On the road to Khayelitsha, he was constantly beaten and you were sitting next to him at the back of the [charcoal or black] double cab bakkie," the lawyer put it to Kwinana.

The policeman replied that Mngeni was lying and that the unit had driven in a maroon Toyota RunX.

"I wouldn't allow anyone to assault him as I am a senior officer of the police," he told the court.


The lawyer claimed Mngeni had not led police to various places where his alleged accomplice "Mawewe" might be, as Kwinana had testified.

Dayimani said it was Mawewe's girlfriend who took police to C-section, in Khayelitsha, where the man could still not be found.

"He [Mngeni] is the one who took us to various addresses," Kwinana said.

Dayimani wrapped up his cross-examination before lunch and Kwinana was allowed to leave the stand.

Deputy director of public prosecutions Adrian Mopp said the defence continued to make allegations of assault and to link individuals to these allegations without advance notice. He said this had left the State unprepared.

The trial was adjourned until 14:00, for the State to track down its next witness.

The court heard the trial was set down to continue from October 8 to November 18, after a two-week recess.

Mopp said the trial could be completed before that time.

  • Rabbler.Rouser - 2012-09-17 16:39

    These thugs always claim that they have been tortured to evoke some kind of sympathy. This thug deserves none. He is lying as usual.

  • scott.barkley.376 - 2012-09-17 17:00

    Dewani knows he will not be allowed to be deported to SA to stand trial if there is a possibility he will be convicted on evidence gathered under torture as it will 'violate his human rights'. My money says he has paid someone to introduce this evidence to make sure he never gets to court to stand trial for this murder. A cunning and calculating villian!

  • Clayton Richard Delport - 2012-09-18 06:22

    So what string him up by his ankles and get to work on his feet with a cr

  • pages:
  • 1