Dewani trial: Accused went on shopping spree

2012-09-05 18:16

Cape Town - A man on trial for Anni Dewani's murder went on a shopping spree the day after she was killed, the Western Cape High Court heard on Wednesday.

Xolile Mngeni's childhood friend, 26, whose identity was being protected, said he, Mngeni and a friend went shopping together at the V&A Waterfront, in Cape Town, on 14 November 2010.

He said Mngeni bought himself green Lacoste "takkies" [running shoes] and a K-Way jacket.

Dewani was killed in Gugulethu on 13 November 2010, in an apparent hijacking while on honeymoon with her husband Shrien.

Paid in cash

Mngeni has pleaded not guilty to charges of kidnapping, robbery with aggravating circumstances, murder, and illegal possession of a firearm and ammunition.

The witness, who had been friends with Mngeni since primary school, said Mngeni paid for everything in cash.

"We took a taxi [to the Waterfront]. I paid [the fare] for myself. He [Mngeni] paid for himself and also for our friend."

He told the court he could not afford a pair of white Adidas trainers priced at R500, but Mngeni gave him R140 to help buy the shoes.

He could not remember how much Mngeni's jacket cost, but the Lacoste shoes were about R750.

He pointed out the items as being the same ones Mngeni was seen wearing in a photograph taken the day of his arrest.

The group ate a meal after shopping and went back home.

Shareen Riley, for the State, asked if the accused had any other money on him.


"The R180 which we had is the money which we drank. We were going to use it to buy liquor... Each person was to give R100 to contribute for the liquor," the friend said.

Riley asked if Mngeni was employed at the time of his arrest.

The witness replied: "No."

The witness told the court Mngeni was friends with one of Dewani's convicted killers, Mziwamadoda Qwabe.

"I've seen them now and then. I've seen them together."

The friend said Mngeni often used his cellphone and had added Qwabe's cellphone number to his contacts list.

"When Watti [Mngeni's nickname] lost his phone, he wanted to be in touch with this person and used my phone."

Qwabe is serving a 25-year jail sentence for his role in the murder.


Qalisile Dayimani previously told the court his client would deny ever being friends with Qwabe.

He would put it to the court that Qwabe was friends with Mngeni's older brother and knew of him only because they lived in the same area.

The State entered a download of the witness's cellphone contact list as an exhibit. It also added a download of Qwabe's cellphone contacts.

The witness confirmed to prosecutor Shareen Riley that the contact listed as "Spra" on his phone was Qwabe.

Riley asked if he knew Qwabe.

"He was staying in a street in C-section [Khayelitsha], but far from me. He's not a friend of mine," the witness said.

He was then asked to look at Qwabe's cellphone contacts and confirmed that the number under the contact "Mawatana" belonged to Mngeni.

Judge Robert Henney adjourned the matter until Thursday, to allow Dayimani time to prepare for cross-examination.

The lawyer had objected to the State providing him, on Tuesday, with two of the documents it intended using. He said this prejudiced his client's right to a fair trial as he could not adequately prepare and therefore needed a postponement.


The State said it had given him everything timeously; most documents had been handed to him months beforehand.

Henney had allowed the witness to begin testimony on the condition that cross-examination take place at a later stage.

The lawyer had also objected to the introduction of the cellphone records, and said he had not been given a copy. The State said it gave these to him last week.

Before Mngeni was escorted out the court room, the judge asked if he had received food. He has ordered that Mngeni be fed more often as he is on cancer medication and fell ill on Tuesday.

Mngeni stood up and showed Henney a wrapped sandwich and an orange. He then shook the items in the air and said something in Xhosa.

The translator told Henney: "He's saying it's plain bread."

Mngeni said the bread was dry and it was not suitable to take with his medication.

A policeman informed the court this was just a snack and that Mngeni would be fed a proper lunch in the holding cells.

Mngeni told the court he would be given exactly the same - a sandwich and orange.

"I can't order them to give you anything else," Henney said.

He asked Mngeni's family be contacted and told to bring other food.

  • PrettyUsefulArt - 2012-09-05 19:17

    Unflippingbelievable. How cheap is life, eh? Don't know why I thought there would be at least some thought for their victim. Silly me. *slaps own wrist* But no, it's clearly much more fun to go out and spend and drink at her expense. *shakes head sadly*

  • matete.k.seshwene - 2012-09-05 19:49

    He want McDonalds Burgers...

  • Peggy Mtengwane - 2012-09-05 22:22

    Lol@ plain bread. inoba ufuna i toasted cheese,ham & tomato

  • pages:
  • 1