General nod for crime stats

2012-09-20 21:35

Cape Town - The 2011/12 crime statistics released by Police Minister Nathi Mthethwa on Thursday have been broadly welcomed, but also evoked concern.

ANC chief whip Mathole Motshekga said the figures reflected a significant decline in various serious crimes, clearly demonstrating government’s crime-fighting efforts continue to bear fruit.

The regular year-on-year decline in serious crimes, such as murder, cash-in-transit heists, car hijackings, and bank robberies, showed that the crime-fighting achievements recorded during the 2010 Soccer World Cup were intensifying.

"We are confident that government will indeed continue to deepen its progressive crime-fighting strategies in this regard, to ensure that South Africans are not only safe, but also feel safe," he said.

Parliament's police portfolio committee has lauded the SA Police Service for "bringing down the crime rate in South Africa".

Govt getting value for money

The committee said in a statement the figures demonstrated that the hard work in the fight against crime by police was paying off.

It was commendable that the SAPS was improving every year, as this showed that government was getting value for its money.

However, the committee was concerned that sexual crimes had not significantly dropped, with only a 1.9% drop in the rape rate.

Dianne Kohler Barnard of the Democratic Alliance disagreed, stating the "minuscule" decrease in crime was no indication that government was doing everything it could to keep South Africans safe.

"These incremental changes are cold comfort to law-abiding citizens who live in fear of criminals. South Africans will certainly not feel any safer as a result of these crime statistics," she said.

Freedom Front Plus spokesperson Pieter Groenewald said the latest crime statistics showed South Africa remained a "violent" country.

However, the FF Plus welcomed a decline in most violent crimes, such as murder (by 3.1%), sexual crimes (by 3.7%), and robberies (by 1.9%).

Security threats

The Institute for Security Studies (ISS) believed the figures did not reflect the actual security threats facing citizens.

"Of course we welcome the ongoing reductions in most violent crime categories," said ISS crime and justice programme head Gareth Newham.

"However, these statistics do not reflect some serious endemic and emerging security threats facing South Africans."

These included corruption, public violence, group murders, political assassinations, and domestic violence.

Newham urged Mthethwa to allow the police to provide more regular and detailed information on these crimes.


Corruption Watch executive director David Lewis said the statistics did not assist in the fight against corruption and did not provide the information necessary to beef up the battle against corruption.

It appeared that the crime statistics categorised much of the reporting of corruption as common fraud.

"However, it is essential to isolate those reports of white collar crime which are, in fact, corruption."

Whenever a case of fraud involved the abuse of public resources it should be logged as a case of corruption.

"Hopefully, this will ultimately lead to an increase in prosecutions under the Prevention and Combating of Corruption Activities Act (Precca) which generally carries significantly more severe penalties than do most common law white collar crimes," he said.

Business Against Crime SA (Bacsa) and its associated partners applauded the overall reduction in crime levels.

Dedicated police officers

"Despite the increased level of reporting of crimes over the financial period in question, crime levels generally declined," Bacsa CEO Simi Pillay-van Graan said.

This success could be attributed to the commitment of dedicated police officials and leadership within the safety and security environment, as well as the structured partnerships between government and the business sector, as acknowledged by Mthethwa at the release of the statistics.

Bacsa saluted the thousands of dedicated police officers, who worked long, tireless hours to protect the country from crime, especially those who had been injured or lost their lives over the past year while serving the country.

The figures released by Mthethwa showed that the actual murder rate dropped marginally, with 331 fewer people killed this year compared to last year.

Most serious crimes

An analysis done by SAPS research task team head Mzwandile Petros showed totals for five of the country's most serious crimes for the period 1 April 2011 to 31 March this year:

- Murder: 15 609 (previous year 15 940);

- Attempted murder: 14 859 (previous year 15 493);

- Assault with intent to do grievous bodily harm: 192 651 (previous year 198 602);

- Common Assault: 181 670 (previous year 185 891); and

- Sexual offences: 64 514 (previous year 66 196).

Most murders a result of arguments

Mthethwa told journalists over 18 000 people were murdered in the 2004/5 reporting period.

"This translates to a 27.6% reduction in murder over an eight-year period," he said.

The minister said an analysis showed almost two-thirds of murders were committed as a result of arguments, fuelled by heavy drinking and drug abuse.

On the decrease in sexual offences, Mthethwa said this was not necessarily a good sign and could point to a trend of under-reporting crimes, such as rape.


"It is influenced by reporting behaviour; if victims trust the police, then you will get more reporting."

He conceded there were difficulties in policing rape and related offences.

"... as government, we still remain concerned about the conviction rate of criminals who commit such crimes," he said.

Re-instating the family violence, child protection, and sexual offences (FCS) units two years ago was helping to ensure more perpetrators were jailed.

"In cases where it involved children under the age of 18, the unit has secured convictions that resulted in a total of 10 345 years [in jail] for those criminals."

For sexual offences against people over 18, 131 life sentences were secured, Mthethwa said.

  • lauren.hartley.52206 - 2012-09-20 21:48

    The high crime rate leaves me cold.

      francois.olivier.108 - 2012-09-20 22:53

      Lauren , you can bet your life on it. Your body will definitely be left cold.

  • - 2012-09-20 21:55

    The rates are still significantly high.

  • Madhi - 2012-09-20 21:55

    The country is still extremely violent and until a professional policeman/woman is given the top job, there is limited hope. What a shame when people kill each other like this during peace time. God forbids there is ever civil war here, it will be the most violent and Congo/Mexico/somalia/iraq/syria/afghanistan will be serious contenders for nobel peace prize. The rest of the world will be heaven on earth.

      akaRags - 2012-09-21 00:46

      I agree with you re civil war - people are easily hyped up in this country, Zimbabwe will look like a picnic.......

  • charnelle.bester - 2012-09-20 22:03

    It never ceases to amaze me how delusionalnthese people are. How anyone can teust these figures baffles me.

  • NotBlackEnough - 2012-09-20 22:23

    Not 1 Not 16 Not 160 Not 1600 But 16000 Murders!!!! And this "PRIMATE" Minister of Safety & Security still holds his Job?

  • bertie.brink - 2012-09-20 22:54

    reinstate the death sentence!

      bertie.brink - 2012-09-20 22:56

      reinstate compulsory national service!!! Bring South Africa out of the dark hole it has fallen into!

  • francois.olivier.108 - 2012-09-20 22:59

    South Africa, be scared, be very scared. The same amount of people killed by the police in Marikana on one day is equal to the same amount of people who get killed by fellow South Africans in South Africa every single day

  • Portia - 2012-09-20 23:21

    police minister who are you fooling by saying the crime rate has decreased,please..there is so much more that you can do for rape survivors but the fact that you cant even put these scum behind bars and then you blame the innocent for not reporting it!! the crime rate in this country is extremely high,i dont think this goverment gives a damn about south africans,as long as they are safe and wealthy.why doesn't jacob zuma ever speak about the high rape statistics.......

      mikaelapace - 2012-10-12 10:10

      Portia I absolutely agree with you. The government does not even offer support groups for crime victims on a national level, and these are rather implemented and maintained by ordinary civilians who have a genuine interest. Take a look at the Victim Support Network at, its a perfect example of a great resource and forum for ALL South Africans, not just limited to victims of crime but anyone who would like to share their thoughts or experiences or advice. It is currently a small operation founded in September 2012 but its working on expansion. I think its great

  • hester.ferrezuelo - 2012-09-21 09:19

    Amazing!! People of SA wake up!! If you believe this you will believe anything. Three hundred people less murdered out of 16000!!! and now we are supposed to celebrate????? Give me a break!!!!!

  • pages:
  • 1