HRC receives Manyi complaint

2011-03-16 16:05

Cape Town - The SA Human Rights Commission received a formal complaint this week about government spokesperson Jimmy Manyi's ill-fated comments on racial equity and employment, CEO Kayum Ahmed said on Tuesday.

"We only received the complaint yesterday," he said at a briefing to Parliament's justice committee on the commission's budget.

Ahmed declined to say who had brought the complaint or whether it focused on Manyi's remark that there was "an over-supply" of coloured people in the Western Cape or an earlier comment that "Indians have bargained their way to the top".

Manyi said that in an address to the Durban Chamber of Commerce last year. The complaint is understood to have been filed in Durban.

Ahmed said the HRC would be able to give more information only in about a week once its legal committee had met to discuss the matter.

Divisive row

Manyi's remarks have triggered a divisive row in the top echelons of government and the ruling party two months before local government elections - with Planning Minister Trevor Manuel branding the former director general of labour "a racist in the mould of HF Verwoerd".

HRC chairperson Lawrence Mushwana suggested that the remarks were problematic because they were hurtful to the minorities Manyi mentioned and told MPs that the commission was debating the issue even before the complaint reached its offices.

"Our politicians can make points, yes, but without hurting other people's feelings."

He added however: "We don't want to be taking sides."

Opposition MPs seized on the matter as part of a broader call on the HRC to use its muscle to stop human rights abuses wherever they occur rather than worry about encroaching on the terrain of other Chapter 9 institutions.

Inkatha Freedom Party MP Mario Oriani-Ambrosini vehemently rejected concerns from commissioners that it was not sufficiently clear where their brief begins and that of other bodies ends.

'Meek, weak and a waste of money'

He said its task was to "fight for human rights in the trenches" and ensure rights abusers land in jail, not to compile reports that were rarely read.

"We are not going to turn into a human rights society by means of reports and road shows. You are not a collaborator, you are an opposer.

"You are our knight in shining armour and until that function is understood ... you are meek, weak and largely a waste of money."

"You must ensure coloureds in the Western Cape that their dignity will be protected by the Constitution," he added.

The Democratic Alliance's Dene Smuts said she believed the Manyi saga provided a perfect opportunity for the commission to produce "an authoritative document on equity" clearly explaining the dictates of the Constitution in this regard.

Mushwana later said her suggestion was "plausible, worth looking at".

Authoritative body

"We want to be an authoritative body," he added.

Citing the hate speech complaints against ANC Youth League head Julius Malema, he insisted however the HRC needed clarity on "how far we go" and when it would interfere with issues before courts or other bodies.

"It is not an easy matter. We want to see what we are dealing with and what is already in court."

The commission complained about budgeting difficulties given its allocation of R87m, well short of the requested R115m.

ANC and DA MPs however appeared reluctant to push for an increase. The DA last year suggested the commission was being used for political ends after it found against the party in the Cape Flats open toilets saga.

Smuts raised the issue again on Wednesday, accusing the HRC of being hasty in that case and dragging its feet on similar cases in ANC-run areas.

"You make yourself vulnerable to accusations of bias," she said.

  • Melly30 - 2011-03-16 16:14


  • kungfupanda - 2011-03-16 16:21

    There is an over-supply of Jimmy Manyi's in South Africa

  • Slapper - 2011-03-16 16:25

    Watch the spin on this. Blame Trevor and the Racist media. The clown will at best be "redeployed" into another cushy job.

  • Jayjay001 - 2011-03-16 16:26

    Why do we bother, he'll be cleared and made President of South Africa tomorrow. What the hell happened to our constitution and Freedom Charter stating Freedom for all, Black and White.

      Jayjay001 - 2011-03-16 16:29

      Unbelievable that we've walked so far away from our Rainbow Nation we all believed in. ALL minorities are under oppression. And it's only to get worse. We should all study law in the evenings and sue our country back into a Rainbow Nation, this country must be FREE of all this racism once and for all!

  • ntombzam - 2011-03-16 16:28

    Thes comments made early last year and only now some people lay a charge?! This is a publicity stunt by whoever and i'm happy they wont mention they names.

      Jayjay001 - 2011-03-16 16:50

      They won't mention names as they know they'll end up like the White Farmers! Killed by we mention no names .... . It's the same old business as before, just a new face, with full government backing.

  • Mahasana - 2011-03-16 16:31

    Very interesting the complain took a year to be lodged.

      CheekySod - 2011-03-16 17:21

      What period of time before a human rights offence expires?

      kleindeef - 2011-03-16 17:59

      @Mahasana Yes. Agreed. Sort of like old Zoompie taking Zapiro to court after a looooong time.

  • Blikskottel - 2011-03-16 18:02

    This HRC is not worth the money they get paid or what they spend. They are biased and clearly do not have any teeth.

  • Bachbabe - 2011-03-16 18:20

    Now let's see how effective this Chapter 9 institution is, Mr Zuma.

  • pages:
  • 1