Hofmeyr blamed for SIU labour dispute

2012-10-11 16:03

Cape Town - The acting head of the special investigating unit suggested to MPs on Thursday that she had to settle a controversial labour dispute because her predecessor, Willie Hofmeyr, had acted improperly.

"The conduct of the employer was unbecoming," Nomvula Mokhatla told Parliament's portfolio committee on justice.

"It was going to be a very embarrassing situation for the SIU and perhaps for the country at large."

Mokhatla came under fire from the opposition for reinstating senior manager Miseria Nyathi, who was sacked by Hofmeyr for refusing to take a lie detector test in a probe into allegations of misconduct made against her.

It was alleged that Nyathi had penned an anonymous letter calling for Hofmeyr's resignation, though this was never proven, and that she had committed time-sheet fraud that amounted to R70,000.

Nyathi was reinstated shortly after Hofmeyr's departure, after more than a decade in the job, and was not only given back-pay, but a sizeable performance bonus.

Democratic Alliance MP Dene Smuts asked why Nyathi was given back her job against the advice of the Labour Court and the advice of advocate Tim Bruinders, who represented the SIU in the case against her.

Smuts argued that the settlement - reported to come close to a million rand - might amount to irregular and wasteful expenditure, because it ran contrary to legal opinion given to the unit.

Finally, she also asked Mokhatla point-blank whether there was any truth in allegations that in fact the letter demanding Hofmeyr step down had been written by herself on her daughter Cora's computer.

Mokhatla responded: "There has not been any finding that there is any letter that comes from a computer of a daughter."

She said the allegations of fraud against Nyathi had not been proven, and added that she would not go as far as considering Bruinders' advice a formal legal opinion, and had been within her rights to disregard both his and the Labour Court's view.

The court ruling held that there were procedural lapses in the way the unit handled the disciplinary case against Nyathi, but that her refusal to sit a polygraph test was a breach of her contract.

ANC MP John Jeffery came to Mokhatla's defence, pointing out that the court had merely said Nyathi could be dismissed, but did not order that it be done.

"I just think this a storm in a tea cup. Nyathi could have been dismissed, but it is a question of should she have been," he said.

Smuts asked whether the committee could be given a copy of Bruinders' opinion on the case, but Mokhatla demurred.

"My initial sentiments would be no, I would not want to go there," she said.

"If we could just lay the matter to rest," she added.

Mokhatla also dismissed a contention by Smuts that the SIU seemed to have lost some of its operational vigour since Hofmeyr left late last year, and that competent staff followed him due to internal strife.

"It is business as usual since I started at the SIU," she said.

A written parliamentary reply by the presidency last week showed that the SIU was probing allegations of maladministration involving billions of rand in 32 municipalities, six central government and 12 provincial departments, and three state-owned companies.

Several of the investigations were in an advanced stage.

On Thursday, the unit's chief financial officer Garth Elliot warned that the unit faced renewed funding constraints in coming years.

Its budget allocations would be decreasing in the short term, meaning that it would have to rely on fees paid by other state entities for its investigative services "to pay our salaries, not to mention the phone[s] and rent".

He pointed out that this system did not always make for a carefree cashflow, as other departments might take a while to settle their bills. In September, the SIU debtors' book was standing at R33m.

  • larry.piggott1 - 2012-10-11 16:10

    Typical, blame the guy who is no longer around.

      christelle.james.7 - 2012-10-11 16:11

      The white guys who is no longer around - like Verwoerd etc!

      Blackpoison - 2012-10-11 16:16

      precisely....Aways someone else's fault.

      lownabester - 2012-10-11 16:28

      Anything to discredit Willie,

  • Andrea - 2012-10-11 16:15

    "busienss as usual", we can see that. How is it possible that the SIU has no funding but we can spend millions on two roads at the Zu's kraal? To hinder their performance, I suppose.

      godfrey.welman - 2012-10-11 16:39

      They must become a self funding unit, salaries, telephone etc must be paid from the money they recovered.

      lionel.holder - 2012-10-11 18:07

      you took the words from my mouth "business as usual- my cronies can steal and defraud as much as they like and I will cover with my fat arse"

  • Gatvol Griet - 2012-10-11 16:17

    As a pig loves rolling in his own shyte, the ANC loves it's corruption!!

      lownabester - 2012-10-11 16:29


  • arno.walt - 2012-10-11 16:23

    @bhekifa, Viva your own demise :-)

  • taig.solomon - 2012-10-11 16:36


  • magomarele - 2012-10-11 16:59

    I think it would be better if we could be told what did Willie Hofmeyr do. Now, we're left speculating.

  • bibi.vanzyl - 2012-10-11 19:07

    Blame the white boy.

  • Erna - 2012-10-11 19:28

    The arrogance of these anc deployees is mind boggling! They stick together like glue, are not accountable to anybody, pay themselves whatever they think is appropriate, and believe that they are invincible. Hopefully, either the DA, media or Thuli will investigate. At least there are still some honest people in SA.

  • stefan.erasmus.756 - 2012-10-11 20:50

    Bhekifa bhekifa. You wount last 3 days without the whites. Dumb ass.

  • gerrit.vanpletzen - 2012-10-12 05:10

    What a damn shame! But, thats's what you can expect. Corruption is rife everywhere. Give her a performance bonus which she did not even earn. The gravy express is rolling, and the pigs are getting fat!

  • quartus.vanzyl - 2012-10-12 08:28

    Ja, in this racist country it is unthinkable that a white can fire a black. It is almost unlawful!

  • pages:
  • 1