AS IT HAPPENED: Mbeki testifies at arms deal hearing

2014-07-17 16:30

Mbeki: 'We wanted the nation to have a sense of ownership of new defence force, hence inclusive consultation on the arms deal.


Jump to

Last Updated at 02:17
17 Jul 17:51
Right, going off duty now. We will continue tomorrow. Follow News24 for further updates.

17 Jul 17:50
Mbeki: I am aware of the many many allegations ... but I'm not aware of any evidence of cabinet acting in a corrupt manner.

17 Jul 17:49
Mbeki: To this day, allegations are aplenty. You could fill books. But where is the evidence?

17 Jul 17:46
Mbeki says Hoffman should go to the ANC for an explanation on why certain decisions were taken (Mbeki being recalled).

17 Jul 17:43
Moerane says Pres. Zuma never said Former Pres. Mbeki manipulated the system and blocked inquir.

17 Jul 17:39
Seriti says the question by Hoffman isn't relevant to the the terms of reference of this commission.

17 Jul 17:34
Moerane says Mbeki won't be given homework, "this is not a school".

17 Jul 17:33
Hoffman: It's very clear you weren't weren't high up in this (the arms deal procurement). Thank you for your evidence.

17 Jul 17:31
Hoffman asks Mbeki to read the book, and specifically the bits that refer to him. Asks him to respond to what is said about him.

17 Jul 17:29
Mbeki says he has not read the arms deal book "Devil in the detail".

17 Jul 17:25
Hoffman brings up a third Sunday Times article.

17 Jul 17:24
Mbeki: I am not sure why I must respond to opinions of newspapers.

17 Jul 17:22
Hoffman brings up another Sunday Times report. It's dated 3 August 2008.

17 Jul 17:21

Hoffman, who brought the article to the commission as evidence, asks who the reporter of it was because Mbeki is accusing that person of lying.

17 Jul 17:18
Mbeki says the Sunday Times article "is a complete fabrication, from beginning to end". I don't know why you want to circulate what is a lie, Mbeki says.

17 Jul 17:16
Hoffman says Moerane anticipated the wrong article. He'll explain... The headline is "Come clean on the arms deal, ANC tells Mbeki".

17 Jul 17:15
Moerane objects to a newspaper article being used as evidence. He says it's not evidence, it's an allegation.

17 Jul 17:14
Hoffman asks Mbeki if he knows about the Sunday Times. Mbeki confirms. Hoffman shows the 16 March 2008 edition.

17 Jul 17:12
Mbeki confirms he remembers Schabir Shaik being convicted. The same Shaik who was freed on medical parole a few years ago.

17 Jul 17:11
Hoffman says he hopes he doesn't keep too many people away from their loved ones and dinner.

17 Jul 17:10
The commission resumes.

17 Jul 17:08
Mbeki having a lighter moment during the break as he laughs at something his advocate says.

17 Jul 16:57
And another adjurnment.

17 Jul 16:56
If I've wasted your time please tell me and let's get on with the show. - Hoffman

17 Jul 16:54

Seriti losing patience with Hoffman.

Manuel throws his head back and closes his eyes.

17 Jul 16:52

I think Hoffman was getting choked up again. He's not even asking a question now. He's just talking a lot about something.

Hoffman tells Seriti "you are entitled to to hear hear-say evidence"

17 Jul 16:42

In what's become a norm now, Moerane (Mbeki's advocate) objects to Hoffman's line of questioning concerning bribes.

This could go on for a while yet...

17 Jul 16:41
Hoffman: There's ample evidence of bribery in various parts of the arms deals.

17 Jul 16:40
Hoffman asked to put short questions to Mbeki instead of making long speeches.

17 Jul 16:40
Mbeki: Been waiting for years for concrete allegations of bribery against ministerial committee members, and nothing.

17 Jul 16:39
Hoffman says he must enlighten Mbeki as to what's in the ConCourt brief.

17 Jul 16:38
Mbeki says the issues of bribes being paid out is "speculative".

17 Jul 16:34

Hoffman AGAIN asked to withdraw a question about Moerane asking a "silly question". he tries to explain. Seriti stops him. After much back and forth from a rather testy Hoffman, he agrees to withdraw his comment.

Hoffman says Seriti should read the papers before the ConCourt. It's full of info that these "so-called" commissions were bribed.

17 Jul 16:28

Moerane stops Hoffman - I don't see the relevance of this line of questioning, he says.

Hoffman says he'll explain Moerane.

17 Jul 16:26

Hoffman: Gavin Woods resigned from Scopa in protest with the way the Mbeki government handled the arms deal investigation. Do you recall?

Mbeki: I do recall. Quite why I don't know. I'm sure it is a matter that was discussed in Parliament.

17 Jul 16:24
Hoffman asks if Mbeki remembers that Schabir Shaik was arrested for his corrupt relationship with Zuma and that Mbeki wrote a report attacking (or as Mbeki puts it, critiquing) the joint investigating unit.

17 Jul 16:22
Mbeki says the practice was to give an institution being audited the chance to comment, and there was nothing extraordinary.

17 Jul 16:16

17 Jul 16:13
The ConCourt had found that it was improper for Heath, a sitting judge to chair the unit reporting to the executive

17 Jul 16:11

Mbeki is doing the throat-clearing again.

Hoffman jokes that he'd rather not have Mr Moerane speak up again as they'd be there for a long time. Indeed so.

17 Jul 16:09

Mbeki says they have agreed that a press conference by Lekota, Irwin etc should be done at OR Tambo airport in Jan 2001.

The press conference defended the procurement of the arms.

17 Jul 16:05
Hoffman says JIT report argues that the SIU should investigate the arms deal.

17 Jul 16:05
Mbeki can't remember any of the details about complaints from Auditor General".

17 Jul 16:02
Mbeki says he doesn't know anything about the police investigation into the arms deal?

17 Jul 16:00
Mbeki says he doesn't remember Auditor general complaining or talking about auditing the arms deal.

17 Jul 15:57
Mbeki says he remembers the date the deal was signed.

17 Jul 15:56
Mbeki says he doesn't recall that the Auditor General or Minister of Defense raised the matter with him (to audit Arms Deal).

17 Jul 15:54
Hoffman insists he's not making this up "as we go along".

17 Jul 15:53
Moerane asks that Hoffman produce the documents ... Seriti "he is in a difficult position because he is reading from a book".

17 Jul 15:52
Mbeki speculates that the statement might have said Zuma was not involved in arms deal procurement.

Jump to

SHARE: publishes all comments posted on articles provided that they adhere to our Comments Policy. Should you wish to report a comment for editorial review, please do so by clicking the 'Report Comment' button to the right of each comment.

Comment on this story
Comments have been closed for this article.

Inside News24

Competition regulation for a growing and inclusive economy

ADVERTORIAL: The Competition Commission of South Africa is conducting advocacy work in the South African automotive aftermarket industry and has gazetted a Draft Code of Conduct for public comment.

Traffic Alerts
There are new stories on the homepage. Click here to see them.


Create Profile

Creating your profile will enable you to submit photos and stories to get published on News24.

Please provide a username for your profile page:

This username must be unique, cannot be edited and will be used in the URL to your profile page across the entire network.


Location Settings

News24 allows you to edit the display of certain components based on a location. If you wish to personalise the page based on your preferences, please select a location for each component and click "Submit" in order for the changes to take affect.

Facebook Sign-In

Hi News addict,

Join the News24 Community to be involved in breaking the news.

Log in with Facebook to comment and personalise news, weather and listings.