AS IT HAPPENED: Anni's sister - Justice system failed us

2014-12-08 13:17

Anni Hindocha's sister says she feels the justice system has failed her family after the Western Cape High Court threw out the murder case against him.


Jump to

Last Updated at 10:54
08 Dec 15:01

Anni Hindocha's sister says the decision to dismiss her former-brother-in-law Shrien Dewani’s murder trial will follow their family for the rest of their lives.

“We waited patiently for four years to hear what really happened to Anni, and to hear the full story of what happened,” she told reporters outside the Western Cape High Court.

“We came here looking for the truth, and all we got, was more questions. “We just wanted to hear all the events, and the hope of actually finding that out has kept us going as a family.

“Unfortunately, we believe that this right has now been taken away from us. Today has been really, really sad, because we never heard the full story from Shrien.

08 Dec 14:32

Ashok Hindocha further writes: "She gave herself to him, mind, body and soul and she hoped to have been cherished and loved.

"But she would not have married him if she had known about his secret sex life with male prostitutes and the activities he engaged in. Neither would we have, as a family, condoned a union with a man who indulged himself in such a sordid manner."

08 Dec 14:31
See the moment when Judge Traverso granted Dewani's application.

08 Dec 14:25

Anni's uncle, Ashok Hindocha has released a statement after the judge's decision to drop the case against Dewani.

"We would have preferred that Shrien Dewani went into the witness box and told in his words what happened after he was accused of her murder.

We know now that he was having gay sex with male prostitutes and declared himself bisexual on the first day of his trial. We would have preferred to have known about his sexuality before he married our precious Anni"," says Hindocha. 

08 Dec 13:24
Anni's sister Ami Denborg says she feels the justice system has failed them.

08 Dec 13:21
Latest pictures show Dewani calmly walking out of the dock and downstairs.

08 Dec 13:16
We must study the judgment - NPA

08 Dec 13:12

08 Dec 13:10

08 Dec 13:07
Hindochas, extremely emotional, pushed and pulled about in media scrum

08 Dec 13:03
Massive media scrum on the steps of the court as Anni's devastated-looking family read a statement.

08 Dec 13:02

08 Dec 12:55

08 Dec 12:53

The Hindocha family quickly left the courtroom.

Also remember, they're suing Dewani for marrying Anni under false pretences (namely, that Dewani lied to Anni about his sexuality).

08 Dec 12:51

08 Dec 12:47
Dewani family embrace as Dewani's case is thrown out.

08 Dec 12:45
Judge grants defence's application. Dewani is found not guilty.

08 Dec 12:45
Judge questions whether further public money used in pursuing trial would result in conviction.

08 Dec 12:44
Traverso: The only way of convicting Dewani of being part of conspiracy would be if he incriminated himself, which isn't allowed.

08 Dec 12:43
Dewanis are on the edge of their seats.

08 Dec 12:42
No reasonable court can convict the accused, says judge. Even if Dewavni was a weak defence witness, I'm still left with a weak State case. - JT

08 Dec 12:41
There are many unanswered questions about what happened on that fateful night. I've heard Hindocha family's plight. But I've taken oath to uphold rule of law. I can't let public opinion influence my judgment. - JT

08 Dec 12:40
Traverso refuses to grant Monde Mbolombo indemnity from prosecution.

08 Dec 12:36

Judge: All 3 witnesses are more than capable of twisting evidence to implicate the accused...

This is not sounding good for the State...

08 Dec 12:35
Judge:there are stark contradictions on all material aspects between Tongo, Qwabe and Mbolombo.

08 Dec 12:33
Traverso: Mr Mbolombo opened up about lies in previous statements given to the court.

08 Dec 12:26
Judge Traverso (JT) understandably needs a sip of water. She's been reading for quite a while now.

08 Dec 12:25

08 Dec 12:23
Dewani shakes his head as Judge recites evidence from conspirators about him wanting 'wife killed'.

08 Dec 12:18
Judge moves onto Monde Mbolombo's evidence.

08 Dec 12:18
Judge says Qwabe's evidence, "disintegrated into a garbled mess".

08 Dec 12:16
Mngeni could not have shot the deceased, says JT. These marks undoubtedly indicate some sort of struggle, she says. Primer residue was found on the web area of the glove worn by Qwabe, JT points out.

08 Dec 12:14
Qwabe's evidence as to how the deceased was shot does not explain the right hand marks on the deceased's leg.

08 Dec 12:14
Judge: Qwabe, a self-confessed liar.

08 Dec 12:12
Qwabe said Mbolombo was just a link. Traverso: "With this attitude he persisted even when confronted with audio recordings".

08 Dec 12:09

08 Dec 12:09
Judge on the evidence of the hitman, Qwabe: During cross-examination it became clear that Mr Qwabe was a self-confessed liar.

08 Dec 12:08
Judge Traverso dealing with Mziwamadoda Qwabe's evidence.

08 Dec 12:06

08 Dec 12:01
Judge now recounting the evidence of Qwabe and Mbolombo. This could be a while longer.

08 Dec 11:59
Tongo's evidence so poor, one can't tell where lies end and truth begins.

08 Dec 11:59
Tongo's evidence of a very poor quality - JT

08 Dec 11:58
Judge states Zola Tongo earned between R30-R40 000 a month with his car service. Questions R5000 figure for his involvement.

08 Dec 11:57
Mbolombo's evidence never included the accused as 'one of the five' involved, contradicts Tongo.

08 Dec 11:56
Judge: Even more improbable that Tongo who had never been involved in crime would immediately agree to contact his friend.

08 Dec 11:54
Traverso: His evidence was contradicted on material points. The entire story by Tongo is highly improbable.

08 Dec 11:53
JT: It would have flown in the face of Tongo's story had he revealed earlier that he received R1 000 from Dewani.

08 Dec 11:51
Tongo denied there was anything inside the plastic bag, and it only appeared rigid because of the way he held it, recalls JT.

08 Dec 11:49
Judge - Common cause that Mr Tongo never asked accused for his R5000

08 Dec 11:47
Tongo's testimony at this point "virtually incomprehensible", conflicts with affidavit, says JT.

Jump to

SHARE: publishes all comments posted on articles provided that they adhere to our Comments Policy. Should you wish to report a comment for editorial review, please do so by clicking the 'Report Comment' button to the right of each comment.

Comment on this story
Comments have been closed for this article.

Inside News24

Traffic Alerts
There are new stories on the homepage. Click here to see them.


Create Profile

Creating your profile will enable you to submit photos and stories to get published on News24.

Please provide a username for your profile page:

This username must be unique, cannot be edited and will be used in the URL to your profile page across the entire network.


Location Settings

News24 allows you to edit the display of certain components based on a location. If you wish to personalise the page based on your preferences, please select a location for each component and click "Submit" in order for the changes to take affect.

Facebook Sign-In

Hi News addict,

Join the News24 Community to be involved in breaking the news.

Log in with Facebook to comment and personalise news, weather and listings.