News24

Mdluli suspicion not enough - court

2012-11-02 17:21

Johannesburg - Suspicion that former crime intelligence boss Richard Mdluli orchestrated the death of a love rival was not sufficient grounds to charge him, the Boksburg Magistrate's Court found on Friday.

"What appeared to be a skeleton in the cupboard for Mdluli, was, with respect, only a ghost," said magistrate Jurg Viviers.

"The only way of finding the answers would be with the assistance of the mythical Jacques Aymar and his divine rod."

Aymar, born in 1622, was a stonemason in France who claimed he could trace fugitives using a divining rod.

Facts

The magistrate said it did not make sense that someone involved in a love triangle would run the risk of bringing five others into a plan to kill the third person in the triangle and be successful.

"The risk of one of the five spilling the beans is simply too high."

Viviers found there was no evidence that implicated Mdluli and three others in the death of Oupa Ramogibe.

Ramogibe died in February 1999 after marrying Mdluli's mistress Tsidi Buthelezi.

The Ramogibe family had accused Mdluli of killing Oupa, but Mdluli claimed there was a plot to implicate him and that the Ramogibe family was working with the police.

Viviers said the theory that Mdluli was the one who organised Ramogibe's death appeared consistent with facts.

Logic

However, there was no logical conclusion that he was behind the killing, especially in the absence of one or both of the actual killers.

"The death was brought by an act, prima facie amounting to an offence, on the part of unknown persons," said Viviers.

"There is no evidence, on a balance of probabilities, implicating Richard Mdluli, Samuel Dlomo, Colonel Nkosana Sebastian Ximba, or Lieutenant Colonel Mtunzi-Omhle Mthembeni Mtunzi in the death of the deceased."

Mdluli was accused of the murder, with Dlomo, Ximba, and Mtunzi, but the charge was provisionally withdrawn in February pending the outcome of the inquest.

Also withdrawn were charges of intimidation, kidnapping, assault with intent to do grievous bodily harm, attempted murder, and conspiracy to commit murder.

Viviers said the inquest was about who killed Ramogibe.

Irrelevant allegations


He said other allegations, such as kidnapping, assault, and intimidation, were irrelevant to the inquest.

It was his job as the judicial officer holding the inquest to find whether there was evidence which would be credible and acceptable if a trial was to be held.

Mdluli's lawyer Ike Motloung said he was elated by the judgment.

"It is vindication," he said outside court.

"That [was] a well-reasoned judgment. It shows there is some hope in the judiciary. We feel particularly vindicated."

Motloung said he saw no reason Mdluli would not be able to recover his reputation.

"If people are not prepared to listen to the courts, who are they prepared to listen to?

"Despite the 1999 investigation and the avalanche of the investigation that came recently through the... so-called Hawks, nothing came of it," he said.

"If they don't believe in it [the court process] they must get lost."

Comments
  • osmaseko - 2012-11-02 17:30

    "If they don't believe in it [the court process] they must get lost." LMAO bwahahahahaah that's a sound of victory

  • buzzardfrey - 2012-11-02 17:56

    Is Richard Mdluli our version of Danny Roman(S.L Jackson)? Who is Niebaum in this case? Is our Danny destined for greater things?

  • richard.wynne.332 - 2012-11-02 18:26

    The magistrate said it did not make sense that someone involved in a love triangle would run the risk of bringing five others into a plan to kill the third person in the triangle and be successful. "The risk of one of the five spilling the beans is simply too high." Well if they come to this conclusion THEN THERE IS ABSOLUTELY NO RISK. So next time you kill somebody you must ensure 5 other people are involved and then you will be let off because ''it would be too risky to do it that way'' o, yes and you must be part of the ANC.Joke

  • rigel.bernard - 2012-11-02 19:39

    zuma and now mdluli and maybe malema. wonder where the dropping of his charges will elad him to. for zuma they led him to presidency, what of mdluli, surely he can managa mister of justice

  • nompithizelo.mapingana - 2012-11-02 21:52

    I know the pain you Ramogibe family to loose a family member the way happened is a very painful situation. I am in that situation too!!

  • nico.dejongh.90 - 2012-11-02 22:47

    The free roaming murderers makes RSA one of the most dangerous places in the world. Easy to pull a couple of strings especially that high in SAP force. Any other positive leads and why not?.

  • pages:
  • 1