Muslim radio station off the hook

2012-07-03 14:33

Johannesburg - A Muslim radio station was not guilty of hate speech during a religious broadcast, the Broadcasting Complaints Commission said on Tuesday.

Listener Moegamat Baboo had complained about a religious Q&A sessions hosted by guest presenter Mufti AK Hoosen on Radio Cii, broadcast on Multichoice's audio bouquet.

In response to a question about the hierarchy of Muslim prayers, Hoosen apparently said "jaahils" - ignorant people - had taken precedence over those who were well-versed in the Qur'an and its jurisprudence.

Baboo complained that the use of the term "jaahil" meant disbelief in God and religious ignorance, was derogatory, and had the potential to cause conflict.

In its response, Multichoice noted that the term "jaahil" was often used to refer to laymen without detailed knowledge of the Qur'an, or who interpreted religious tenets according to their own understanding, rather than Islamic jurisprudence.

"The response and remark made are clear and distinctive to the question posed thereof with no intention of any derogatory remark," it said.

It said the response had been derived from the quotations of the Prophet Mohammed.

The commission's complaints tribunal found the show was a "bona fide religious broadcast" and so did not constitute hate speech, according to the ruling released on Tuesday.

"The tribunal has taken note of religious sensibilities, but after careful deliberation we concluded that the word complained of does not constitute hate speech, and the broadcast does not, therefore, infringe the code," chairperson Kobus van Rooyen said in his judgment.

  • sameera.dawoodbhagwan - 2012-07-03 14:52

    Many religions refer to non believers - does that mean we must all feel insulted in some way? Maturity is necessary.

  • dawie.theron.5 - 2012-07-03 16:01

    Causing conflict for not believing in someone's invisible friend? How silly religion's are! "The invisible and non-existant looks very much alike" Call me Jaahil!

  • joe.hussain2 - 2012-07-03 16:48

    Multichoice certainly have misunderstood the word "Jaahil". It means ignorant, stupid, dom, mampara and is pure downright insulting.I have a serious problem with scholars who use the word "Jaahil" in this context, and who think they know it all.

  • pages:
  • 1