Tatane witness has axe to grind - defence

2012-05-18 19:17

Ficksburg - A police officer testifying about the seven policemen on trial for the death of Andries Tatane changed his version of events because he was fired, the Ficksburg Regional Court heard on Friday.

"You changed your opinion because you have an axe to grind with police, due to [your] wrongful actions within the police," Johann Nel, representing the seven men, told State witness Constable Kabelo Pule.

Nel wanted Pule to tell the court why he had been suspended from the police. Pule refused and said he was not there to talk about his suspension.

"I will not hold a debate over my suspension, because all is still hanging."

Nel submitted Pule was being investigated for armed robbery and that the criminal case was before a court.

The State objected to Nel's questioning Pule on his suspension. Magistrate Hein van Niekerk held that Pule did not have to answer Nel.

The court was hearing evidence in the trial of the public order policemen accused of killing Tatane during a protest march against poor service delivery in the Setsoto local municipality on 13 April 2011.

Unprovoked, brutal attack

The officers each face murder and assault charges.

Nel was cross-examining Pule on testimony he gave during the internal disciplinary hearing the seven faced after Tatane's death.

Nel submitted that at the hearing, Pule testified Tatane was overpowering a policeman and that the other officers rushed to help him.

But then in his testimony to the court he said it was an "unprovoked, brutal attack" on Tatane, Nel said.

Nel then wanted to know why his opinion had changed so dramatically.

The State alleges Tatane tried to protect elderly people from the police's water cannon by moving between the cannon and two elderly men.

The State argues that two of the accused fired rubber bullets at Tatane from close range. One of the shots penetrated his chest cavity, killing him, according to the indictment.

The policemen deny all allegations against them and deny that they acted unlawfully.

Van Niekerk put the matter off to August 6 for the policemen’s defence counsel to finish the cross-examination of Pule.

  • Florence - 2012-05-18 20:06

    What really happened to this gentleman left an endurable mark to me as an ordinary person, I absolutely cannot imagine about his family. Everything on camera. Soweto rape case of a mentally challenged girl. Criminals walked free... What evidence really is needed in the so called court of law... This is sickening

  • Mnguni - 2012-05-18 20:17

    I just feel for Tatane's widow ' watch the space no one will be convicted this is our government' more competent prosecutors should be roped in

  • Khetha Hlophe - 2012-05-18 20:21

    I am just wondering what was the post mortern report.Who fired/beat the killer wound.\r\nThen is the one who must bear the consequences of actions.RIP teacher

  • - 2012-05-19 19:12

    lies lies lies this so called police force is the same as the government they think they are above the law.

  • pages:
  • 1