Court rejects convicted Dros rapist Nicholas Ninow's version of events, finds him guilty on 3 counts

2019-09-16 14:13
Nicholas Ninow's grandmother, Pauline Gericke, takes his hand as he enters the courtroom. (Photo: Deaan Vivier)

Nicholas Ninow's grandmother, Pauline Gericke, takes his hand as he enters the courtroom. (Photo: Deaan Vivier)

Multimedia   ·   User Galleries   ·   News in Pictures Send us your pictures  ·  Send us your stories

Warning: This article contains graphic details

The Gauteng High Court in Pretoria has rejected Nicholas Ninow's claim that he acted impulsively when he raped a 7-year-old girl in the bathroom of a Dros restaurant in Pretoria last year.

Instead, Judge Mokhine Mosopa accepted the State's version that he followed her into the bathroom.

At the start of his trial, the State rejected Ninow's plea on the basis that his story contradicted the State's version.

A trial ensued and on Monday, Ninow was convicted of rape, the possession of an illegal substance and defeating the ends of justice.

He was acquitted of assault after Mosopa found that, while it was not in dispute that he used his belt to try to hit people who found him in the bathroom with the victim, he didn't actually hit anyone.

READ | Dros rapist Nicholas Ninow officially found guilty

In his judgment, Mosopa said he rejected the version in Ninow's plea explanation and said the State's case - that it was his intention to target a child - had been proven beyond reasonable doubt.

"The only reasonable inference the court can draw is that the accused saw the victim playing in the play area, saw her going to the bathroom, followed her and then undressed and raped her," Mosopa said.

He added that Ninow gave no reasonable explanations for moving closer to the children's play area, or for choosing to use the women's bathroom.

Mosopa found that Ninow's actions were premeditated in that he came to the restaurant and changed his seat so that he could have a clearer view of the children's play area to stalk his victim and strike when the opportunity presented itself.

Ninow's rejected version

News24 previously reported that in Ninow's plea explanation, he said he went to the women’s bathroom to take a drug called methcathinone (also known as CAT), hoping he would not get caught.

He lowered his pants to create the impression that he was urinating while snorting more of the drug that he was caught with when he was arrested on September 22, 2018 – the day when the rape occurred.

READ MORE: Nicholas Ninow details rape in Dros bathroom

"While I was busy taking the CAT, the complainant pushed open the door," he said.

"The complainant indicated that she wanted to urinate, and I got off the toilet, pulled her pants down and put her on the toilet.

"In that moment, I acted impulsively, and took my penis and forced it into the complainant's mouth. Thereafter, I penetrated the complainant’s vagina with my finger.”

Victim’s version

However, the victim, who previously testified in camera (behind closed doors) and via an intermediary, said she went to the bathroom and that Ninow entered after her.

State advocate Dorah Ngobeni told the court that the victim even recalled that she was on the toilet and urinating when Ninow entered the bathroom.

In his judgment, Mosopa recounted the victim's testimony that, she could not respond to her mother's calls for her because Ninow threatened to kill her if she spoke.

ALSO READ: 'No parent should see what I witnessed' - mother of Dros rape victim

This testimony was not disputed by the defence, Mosopa added.

The victim eventually called out for her mom for help after, as her mother and employees at the Dros were trying to force the toilet door open.  At that point, Ninow, who was trying to keep the door closed, yelled out that they should not "disturb" him.

National Prosecuting Authority spokesperson (NPA) Phindi Mjonondwane said they were happy with the judgment.

"We are satisfied with the court's decision to accept the State witness' version, especially the version of the minor, [about] how the sequence of events unfolded," Mjonondwane said.

"It is indeed what we wanted to achieve as the NPA. That was our goal; to place the court in a better position to make an informed decision."

Read more on:    nicholas ninow  |  crime  |  rape

Inside News24

Traffic Alerts
There are new stories on the homepage. Click here to see them.


Create Profile

Creating your profile will enable you to submit photos and stories to get published on News24.

Please provide a username for your profile page:

This username must be unique, cannot be edited and will be used in the URL to your profile page across the entire network.