Listeriosis class action case could be delayed 'for years'

2019-10-09 05:36
Tiger Brands (File, News24)

Tiger Brands (File, News24)

Multimedia   ·   User Galleries   ·   News in Pictures Send us your pictures  ·  Send us your stories

The class action brought against Tiger Brands following a listeriosis outbreak caused by some of its products could take years before it finally gets to court. 

In April, Tiger Brands received the summons for a class action linked to the listeriosis outbreak from the Gauteng High Court in Johannesburg.

In February, the court determined that Richard Spoor Attorneys could go ahead with the class action, representing more than 1 000 people affected by the listeriosis outbreak in 2017 and 2018 that claimed more than 200 lives.

READ | Listeriosis outbreak: How it started, how it was traced, and how it was finally stopped

On Tuesday, Spoor said the class action could be delayed "for years" as Tiger Brands had issued subpoenas against food-testing laboratories to obtain information about the identities of people or parties who submitted samples for testing listeriosis and the results of those tests during the period of the outbreak.

Two laboratories - Aspirata and Deltamune - have indicated that they would oppose this as the information is confidential. In a worst-case scenario, the matter could go all the way to the Constitutional Court, which could take years, Spoor said.

Tiger Brands has lodged an application in the High Court to compel the disclosure of the documents.  

'Fishing expedition'

"This is a fishing expedition," Spoor said. "There is no reason to believe that anyone other than [Tiger Brands] is responsible for the outbreak."

Spoor said his firm might participate in the litigation of the matter between Tiger Brands and the laboratories to speed up the matter. 

"Foremost, is the question of public policy and privacy. We want companies to submit products for testing. From a health and safety point of view, it is desirable for corporations to test often for any signs of contamination and to respond appropriately. 

"But when these companies send their samples to private laboratories to be tested, at their own expense, and the results become public knowledge, it creates a strong disincentive for them to do so."

Products found to be contaminated are not sold to the public. Spoor said chicken, for example, may contain traces of listeria, but this is not a "train smash" as it will be cooked, killing the bacteria.

"But in the eyes of the public, it sounds appalling. So here you have a small manufacturer that submits its products, listeria is found and appropriate measures are taken, so there's no risk to anybody. However, the fact that listeria was found could be very bad for [the company's reputation] if it comes out in public. 

"People could become terrified, even if there is no risk involved." 

This is the reason the laboratories want to keep their records confidential, Spoor said. "It could cause reputational harm that just isn't justified." 

That said, the subpoenas are causing a delay in the class action.

Constitutional matter

"One of the important issues is that this is a constitutional matter. It's about the right to privacy. So this is a matter that could, conceivably, go all the way to the Constitutional Court and that process can take a few years.

"We really don't want that to happen."

This is why Spoor is contemplating intervening by joining Tiger Brands as an applicant to "find a solution that is in the interest of the claimants and justice". 

Spoor said a decision on this would be made by Friday.  

ALSO READ | Listeriosis: Tiger Brands to cooperate with class action - but maintains it's not guilty yet

News24 has approached a spokesperson at Tiger Brands for comment. This will be added once received. 

In a statement in December last year, the company said it would follow the legal process to bring closure to all parties.

"Tiger Brands reiterates that no liability has been established against the company for the listeriosis outbreak.

"However, should liability be determined, the company will respond appropriately to any legitimate claims," the statement read.

In the same statement, Tiger Brands chief corporate affairs officer Mary Jane Morifi said the R1m that the company extended to assist in supporting the class action process, and a hotline to facilitate it, was a sign that the company was committed to finding a resolution for everyone affected.

Read more on:    tiger brands  |  listeriosis  |  courts
NEXT ON NEWS24X

Inside News24

 
/News
Traffic Alerts
Traffic
There are new stories on the homepage. Click here to see them.
 
English
Afrikaans
isiZulu

Hello 

Create Profile

Creating your profile will enable you to submit photos and stories to get published on News24.


Please provide a username for your profile page:

This username must be unique, cannot be edited and will be used in the URL to your profile page across the entire 24.com network.