As it happened: Alleged hitman’s girlfriend arrested after testimony in Panayiotou trial

2016-10-27 14:30

On day 12 of Christopher Panayiotou's murder trial at the Eastern Cape High Court, the alleged middleman's girlfriend Babalwa Breakfast has been declared a hostile witness and was taken to the holding cells by police when court adjourned for lunch.


Jump to

Last Updated at 22:27
27 Oct 16:03

Court is adjourned for the day.

Back tomorrow.

27 Oct 16:02

No further questions from Price.

And none from Daubermann.

27 Oct 16:02

TP: The person you saw walking down to the gate, you also describe her as petite wearing a grey coat. Did you know her? Did you know the people living in 19 Stellen Glen?                       

TS: No                        

27 Oct 16:01

TP: Now if you look at this slide, this block of flats opposite looks onto the gate.                       

TS: Yes that is correct.

TP: And which unit is yours?                       

She points it out.                        

27 Oct 15:59

TP: And you work shifts, or same every day?                       

TS: Same every day.      

TP: So you leave around the same time every day?                       

TS: Yes                        

27 Oct 15:58

TP: Can I accept that you told Captain Fry this?                       

TS: Yes                       

TP: You say that you saw the same vehicle driving in the early hours of the morning with three males inside?                       

TS: Yes

27 Oct 15:57

TP: Hang on, here you say a white Opel Corsa. I am just saying that this statement is probably a more accurate version. 


27 Oct 15:57

TP: All over this statement you refer to a white Opel Corsa.

TS: I said it was similar to.                        

27 Oct 15:56

TP: You say here that you can’t remember what he looked like. Here you say he was wearing blue jeans.                       

TS: I don't recall today.                        

TP: I'm not expecting you to recall, I am just trying to jog your memory. Do you recall if he was big or small?                       

TS: He had a slight built.                       

TP: And height?                       

TS: I can't remember.                        

27 Oct 15:55

TP: And they gave you an opportunity to read it?

Price calls up the statement.

TP: Is that your signature?                       

TS: Yes

27 Oct 15:54

Over to Terry Price.

TP: Ms Smith on the 21st the police took a statement from you, is that correct?                       

TS: Yes                        

27 Oct 15:53

The State has no further questions for this witness.

27 Oct 15:53

TS: There were 4 people in the vehicle.                       

MS: Did you note the registration at any time?                       

TS: No                       

MS: So a white vehicle without a boot?                        

TS: Yes                        

27 Oct 15:52

MS: And did you remember how many people ?                      

TS: On the first occasion it was on on the corner of Deacon Street and Ritchie Crescent. I thought it was waiting for someone to give a lift to.

She says the second time she saw the vehicle she took note of the vehicle.

27 Oct 15:51

MS: You made mention when I asked how many people were in the vehicle, you said no not that morning.     

TS: I saw that vehicle on two occasions that I can clearly remember.

MS: Can you remember when that was?                       

TS: No, I can't remember the exact time.                       

MS: Can you narrow it down to months, weeks, days?                       

TS: I remember definitely the week before.             


27 Oct 15:49

MS: Besides the one person at the keypad, did you see anyone else?                       

TS: No                        

27 Oct 15:49

MS: Do you remember how many were inside the vehicle?                        

TS: No                        

27 Oct 15:48

MS: Did you say it was?                       

TS: No                        

27 Oct 15:48

MS: The vehicle that drove past, can you remember?                        

TS: It was a white vehicle.                       

MS: How good are you with vehicle makes?                       

TS: Not really.                        

MS: In your affidavit did you give an indication of the type of vehicle.                       

TS: I said it looked like the new Opel Corsa hatch.                        

27 Oct 15:47

MS: And the lady approaching the gate?                       

TS: It was a lady, she was petite built, that's about all I can say.                       

MS: Time?                       

TS: Anytime between 6:20 and 6:25.                        

27 Oct 15:46

MS: The gentleman who was at the keypad, were you able to identify him?                       

TS: I didn't get a good look.                        

MS: Male or female?                       

TS: Yes it was a black gentleman.                        

27 Oct 15:45

TS: So we stopped at the gate, exiting. There was a car approaching.                       

MS: Then?                       

TS: We stopped because it was slowly approaching our car and the gate was also not closing behind us. My mum said he wants to turn in, but I said no because he is not indicating. When he drove past we turned.  As we pulled away, there was a lady approaching the gate.                       

MS: From where?                       

TS: It was a silver car.                       

MS: And then?                       

TS: We drove off.                        

27 Oct 15:43

MS: I want to take you to the morning of April 21. Do you remember that?                        

TS: So as I was approaching the gate, the gentleman was standing on the side of the gate where the keypad is.                       

MS: If we look at the photo A3 slide 11, is that the keypad you refer to?                       

TS: Yes. As the gate was opening, he moved from that side to the other side.                       

MS: So at that stage, you are on the inside and he moves across?

27 Oct 15:41

MS: And what time do you leave in the morning?                       

TS: I leave around 06:15 in the morning.                        

27 Oct 15:41

MS: What work do you do and what time do you work?                        

TS: I'm a nurse and work a 7 - 7 shift.                        

27 Oct 15:40

MS: Ms Smith is it correct that you reside in Stellen Glen?                       

TS: I have since moved out, I moved out in March.                       

MS: But in April last year you resided there?                       

TS: Yes                        

27 Oct 15:39

27 Oct 15:39

Court is back in session.

The State calls Tracy Smith, no 3 on the state witness list.

27 Oct 15:25

Chetty adjourns court for a short recess. 

27 Oct 15:24

Daubermann has no further questions for this witness.

27 Oct 15:24

MS: It is recorded on my copy. On the last page in the written document, it is there.                         

PD: I withdraw that question.                        

27 Oct 15:23

Stander interjects.

27 Oct 15:23

PD: That is the first time you mentioned that.                       

YK: I did ask her my lord.                       

PD: Why did you not record that you asked her to swear so help her God?

27 Oct 15:22

PD: And that is exactly how you asked her to take the oath?                       

YK: Yes                       

PD: Did you ask her to swear if the info is true, how did you do that?                        

YK: I asked her.                       

PD: When did you do that?                       

YK: After writing.                        

27 Oct 15:21

PD: Okay and then? Why did you not record on your statement that you asked her to take an oath?                       

YK: This is how I always write my statement.                       

PD: You asked her to raise her right hand and say so help me God?                       

YK: Yes                       

PD: Can you recall that this is what you did?                       

YK: Yes

27 Oct 15:20

PD: An then?                       

YK: I asked her to take an oath.

PD: How?                       

Kumla explains the process.

27 Oct 15:19

PD: Up to where did you write the statement before she read it?                        

YK: All of it.                       

PD: Up to the last paragraph?                      

YK: Yes

27 Oct 15:18

PD: And did you ask her if it was correct?                       

YK: Yes                       

PD: And then?                       

YK: I gave her the document to read.                       

PD: Why?                       

YK: So she could read it.                       

PD: But why was it necessary?

YK: So she could confirm that everything is correct as I had read it.                        

27 Oct 15:17

PD: And what procedure did you follow?                       

YK: I read it back.                       

PD: In English or Xhosa?                       

YK: Yes PD: Did you read it to her paragraph by paragraph?                       

YK: Yes

27 Oct 15:15

PD: If we look at the statement, is that all she had to say?

YK: Yes

27 Oct 15:15

Chetty: We will cross that bridge if we come to it.

27 Oct 15:15

PD: Well I hope that my learned friend will ask you at a later stage to accept this version as true.

27 Oct 15:14

MS: The two goes hand in hand. I am proving an inconsistent statement. In order to prove the statement, then I am also proving the content.

27 Oct 15:12

PD: If it is the content then the evidence being led is hearsay and I have to object.

27 Oct 15:12

PD: But which is it, to prove the statement was made by her or is it to prove the content?

27 Oct 15:12

MS: That is why I am calling the witness.

27 Oct 15:11

Peter Daubermann asks to clarify: Is it to prove that the statement was made or to prove the content?

27 Oct 15:11

Price has no further questions for the witness.

27 Oct 15:10

TP: You were at Kabega Park Crime Office, and the investigating team was also based at Kabega Park?                       

YK: I was not aware.                       

TP: You knew nothing about the case?                       

YK: Nothing                       

TP: I find that very hard to believe.

27 Oct 15:10

YK: No, my lord.                        

TP: If you don't there's a problem.                       

If you turn over the page, you will notice in the first statement to Mayi she refers to Sizwe's white car and yet to you she only refers to a white car. Is it correct she never mentioned Sizwe to you?                       

YK: Yes

Jump to


Inside News24

Competition regulation for a growing and inclusive economy

ADVERTORIAL: The Competition Commission of South Africa is conducting advocacy work in the South African automotive aftermarket industry and has gazetted a Draft Code of Conduct for public comment.

Traffic Alerts
There are new stories on the homepage. Click here to see them.


Create Profile

Creating your profile will enable you to submit photos and stories to get published on News24.

Please provide a username for your profile page:

This username must be unique, cannot be edited and will be used in the URL to your profile page across the entire network.


Location Settings

News24 allows you to edit the display of certain components based on a location. If you wish to personalise the page based on your preferences, please select a location for each component and click "Submit" in order for the changes to take affect.

Facebook Sign-In

Hi News addict,

Join the News24 Community to be involved in breaking the news.

Log in with Facebook to comment and personalise news, weather and listings.