AS IT HAPPENED: ‘What are the things that worried you?’ – Justice Moseneke asks Mahlangu

2018-01-22 16:00

Justice Moseneke adjourns the Life Esidimeni hearings by asking former health MEC Qedani Mahlangu ‘Why did you think things had gone so wrong that you think you ought to fall on your sword?’ Hearings will continue on Wednesday.

For the latest updates follow News24 reporters: 

 - Jeanette Chabalala: @J_chabalala 

 - Nation Nyoka: @Naewizzle


(Courtesy of SABC) 


Jump to

Last Updated at 11:50
22 Jan 17:02

22 Jan 16:57

22 Jan 16:57

22 Jan 16:56
Mahlangu tells Moseneke she can’t remember what they were dealing with for her to decide to take the route of getting lawyers.

22 Jan 16:54
Hassim tells Mahlangu, instead of dealing with the contents of the letter you asked to get the legal team involved to respond to civil society groups, because NGOs are "dishonest".

22 Jan 16:50

Hassim asks Mahlangu if she was ever suspicious of SADAG?

Mahlangu: I am not sure why I would be suspicious of them.

22 Jan 16:49

22 Jan 16:49
Mahlangu says it is impossible to know of every correspondence that comes to the office but had no reason to doubt information that was given to her.

22 Jan 16:45

Moseneke: "Why would Selebano and Manamela lie to you so openly?"

Mahlangu: " I really don't know, Justice."

22 Jan 16:43

22 Jan 16:42

Hassim states that the information provided in November by Mahlangu at Legislature on availability of beds was not correct.  

Mahlangu says yes and information was provided by officials. She says she is shocked and disappointed after Moseneke asks if she was shocked at this.

22 Jan 16:35

22 Jan 16:34

22 Jan 16:32

22 Jan 16:31
Justice Moseneke allows Mahlangu time to find information to questions she has to answer.

22 Jan 16:28

22 Jan 16:26

22 Jan 16:25

22 Jan 16:22

22 Jan 16:21

22 Jan 16:16
Former Gauteng Health MEC Qedani Mahlangu told the panel at the Life Esidimeni arbitration hearings on Monday that she also did not know that there were challenges with the marathon project of moving patients to other non-governmental organisations (NGOs).

22 Jan 16:15

The letter ends with asking when Mahlangu will be urgently available to discuss matters of email.

Mahlangu says she is not sure if her visit to Precious Angel was triggered by the email.

Mahlangu says she is not aware who she asked and how the matter be dealt to take the matters forward.

22 Jan 16:11
Advocate Hassim is going through the email written by Section 27.

22 Jan 16:03
Hearing adjourned for 10 minutes.

22 Jan 16:02

22 Jan 16:02

Reverting does not necessarily man responding by email, it may mean responding via someone else, Mahlangu tells advocate Hassim.

Mahlangu asks for time to read over letter in question.

22 Jan 15:58

22 Jan 15:57
Mahlangu says she did not withhold information from the Legislature. Hassim reads quote from Mahlangu saying she has to walk on “eggshells” and to think before she speaks, questions why she said that.

22 Jan 15:56

22 Jan 15:53

22 Jan 15:50
Mahlangu is asked if she agrees that there is a link between the manner in which patients were transferred their deaths. Mahlangu says she thinks it is appropriate.

22 Jan 15:48

22 Jan 15:38

22 Jan 15:33

Hassim asks Mahlangu if it's true that she initiated the investigation, and not Professor Makgoba. "Yes, it's true," Mahlangu responds. 

22 Jan 15:29

Moseneke once again reminds Mahlangu to keep her answers simple, and to "reduce her emotions". "I'm here to protect you," he says, to get answers. 

22 Jan 15:27

Hassim: "Is government paying for your studies abroad?" 

Mahlangu: "No." 

Hassim then asks if Mahlangu went overseas because she knew it would make it harder for people to contact her. 

22 Jan 15:25

22 Jan 15:25

22 Jan 15:22

22 Jan 15:22

Hassim now refers to Mahlangu's resignation letter, and the ombud's report, saying its contents amounts to culpability on Mahlangu's part.

Mahlangu disagrees. 

22 Jan 15:20

Hassim: "Do you agree that Section 27 of the Constitution binds you as an MEC?" 

Mahlangu gives another prolonged response, before Moseneke interrupts her once again just to remind her that a simple "yes" or "no" would suffice, and thereafter she can explain her answer. 

Mahlangu: "Yes, sorry Justice (Moseneke)." 

22 Jan 15:15

22 Jan 15:14

Advocate Hassim once again firmly asks Mahlangu to stop evading questions, as it could end up prolonging the whole process. 

22 Jan 15:13

Mahlangu: "My resignation was subjecting myself to accountability..." 

22 Jan 15:11

22 Jan 15:11

Advocate Hassim asks Mahlangu to please specifically answer the questions she is asked. 

22 Jan 15:07

22 Jan 15:06

22 Jan 15:03

Proceedings resume. 

Jump to


Inside News24

Traffic Alerts
There are new stories on the homepage. Click here to see them.


Create Profile

Creating your profile will enable you to submit photos and stories to get published on News24.

Please provide a username for your profile page:

This username must be unique, cannot be edited and will be used in the URL to your profile page across the entire network.


Location Settings

News24 allows you to edit the display of certain components based on a location. If you wish to personalise the page based on your preferences, please select a location for each component and click "Submit" in order for the changes to take affect.

Facebook Sign-In

Hi News addict,

Join the News24 Community to be involved in breaking the news.

Log in with Facebook to comment and personalise news, weather and listings.