AS IT HAPPENED: Tim Noakes found not guilty of professional misconduct

2017-04-21 09:10

Professor Tim Noakes has been found not guilty of misconduct, a professional conduct committee found.


Jump to

Last Updated at 03:51
21 Apr 13:18

21 Apr 12:42

Professor Tim Noakes has been found not guilty of misconduct, a professional conduct committee found on Friday.

The majority of the conduct committee found him not guilty.

21 Apr 12:34

21 Apr 12:32

21 Apr 12:30

21 Apr 12:27

21 Apr 12:20

21 Apr 12:19
The HPCSA has also not proven that Noakes was giving medical advice.

21 Apr 12:18
HPCSA has not proven Noakes gave unconventional advice or that the advice was not evidence based, Adams says.

21 Apr 12:12

21 Apr 12:10

21 Apr 12:08
Nothing to suggest that Noakes suggested that mother cease breastfeeding and go on LCHF diet.

21 Apr 12:08
Nothing in Tim Noakes' tweet suggests that he intended to dilute the breastfeeding message says Adv Joan Adams.

21 Apr 12:05
Not reasonable inference that he was undermining breastmilk. Nothing suggesting he advocated immediate cessation of breastfeeding.

21 Apr 12:02
Committee agrees Noakes never obtained background info on Ms Leenstra or her baby.

21 Apr 12:01

21 Apr 11:58
Can't assume Twitter users are ignorant and vulnerable and need to be protected from themselves, says Adams.

21 Apr 11:56

21 Apr 11:56

21 Apr 11:53
There's no way one can infer Leenstra was hoping for a free medical consultation, Adams says. Noakes was at best someone she'd heard of.

21 Apr 11:49
Noakes was happy for others to take part in discussion on his advice and express their opinions, Adams says, which they did.

21 Apr 11:48
Twitter account doesn’t say he is a registered doctor or acted as such. No evidence that she considered him her doctor, Adams says.

21 Apr 11:46
And baby winds - which Leenstra enquired about - is not an illness, Adams says. Giggles from audience.

21 Apr 11:45

21 Apr 11:44
She doesn’t address Noakes as 'dear professor or doctor', showing she did not regard him as her doctor. Could be due to character count.

21 Apr 11:38
Adv Joan Adams: At no stage did the respondents letter of reply say NO carbs for babies. He says low carbs, high fat.

21 Apr 11:36

21 Apr 11:33

21 Apr 11:32

21 Apr 11:30
Adv Joan Adams: The tweet is about breast feeding mothers. It is not babies that are tweeting. It is adult mothers.

21 Apr 11:27

21 Apr 11:25
Adv Joan Adams: This committee is bound by the HPCSA act. Its tasked with a unique set of facts involving social media

21 Apr 11:03
Final section of majority judgment to be delivered after a short break

21 Apr 10:49
The HPCSA committee is split over Tim Noakes. 4 of 5 members agree, 1 member holds a different view. The majority judgement being read now.

21 Apr 10:40

21 Apr 10:39
Dr Pienaar, a bioethics expert: Tim Noakes, although with good intent, did not act as a reasonable doctor when he gave advice on Twitter.

21 Apr 10:36

21 Apr 10:27
Pienaar said Noakes didn't act as a reasonable doctor. "Even if doctor acted in good faith, could have resulted in negative outcome."

21 Apr 10:27
Adv Joan Adams: An expert summary was submitted to the committee suggested "maybe it was a deed of good intent on his part"

21 Apr 10:25

21 Apr 10:12
HPCSA says Twitter is a 1-on-1 conversation, akin to doctor-patient relationship. Noakes is subject to ethical rules, good practice guidelines.

21 Apr 10:09

21 Apr 10:08
HPCSA said Noakes replying tweet is ambiguous to message of breastfeeding. Message to encourage this has been global initiative for years.

21 Apr 10:06
Noakes not an expert in infant nurtirtion, HPCSA said. Conventional is 6 months breastfeeding and up to two years and beyond.

21 Apr 10:05
Pro forma complainant, HPCSA, argued conventional advice is evidence based advice based on guidelines. Must be free of speculation.

21 Apr 10:04
Dietitians weighed in, challenging Noakes response. Former Association for Dietetics in SA chair Claire Julsing-Strydom lodged complaint.

21 Apr 09:59
Noakes response: "Baby doesn't eat the dairy and cauliflower. Just very healthy high-fat breast milk. Key is to ween [sic] baby onto LCHF."

21 Apr 09:59
Noakes has over 85 000 followers on Twitter, on which he regularly shares articles and research supporting the banting diet.

21 Apr 09:58
Tweet read, "@ProfTimNoakes @SalCreed is LCHF eating ok for breastfeeding mums? Worried about all the dairy+cauliflower = wind for babies??"

21 Apr 09:57
Unprofessional conduct is defined as acts deemed improper, dishonourable, disgraceful. Noakes was charged after a tweet to Pippa Leenstra.

Jump to


Inside News24

Traffic Alerts
There are new stories on the homepage. Click here to see them.


Create Profile

Creating your profile will enable you to submit photos and stories to get published on News24.

Please provide a username for your profile page:

This username must be unique, cannot be edited and will be used in the URL to your profile page across the entire network.