Sunday Times 'twisted' facts on child rescued from life of abuse – Mapisa-Nqakula

2016-05-22 15:36
Nosiviwe Mapisa-Nqakula (Thulani Gqirana, News24)

Nosiviwe Mapisa-Nqakula (Thulani Gqirana, News24)

Multimedia   ·   User Galleries   ·   News in Pictures Send us your pictures  ·  Send us your stories


WATCH: Political not military solution, says Defence Minister

2016-04-04 15:18

The Defence Minister says South Africa needs a political solution, not a military one.WATCH

Johannesburg – The Minister of Defence and Military Veteran Nosiviwe Mapisa-Nqakula has responded to a report that alleged she had transported a young woman from Burundi into South Africa using state resources.

In a statement, Mapisa-Nqakula said she had "noted" the report, and was "saddened" by it, claiming the Sunday Times had deliberately twisted the facts of the matter.

Mapisa-Nqakula said she found it particularly hurtful because despite her "sharing the circumstances involved in the unfolding of this matter with the Sunday Times, the reporter chose his obvious bias and sensation, without any regard for the protection of a child rescued  from a life of abuse and abandonment".

She said the reporter, Mzilikazi wa Afrika, may have reversed "months of progress the child has made in healing and rebuilding her life".

The minister said she wanted to set the record straight by placing on record the facts of her involvement in the matter.

1. “For more than two years now, my family and I have been living with a young woman, a Burundian national, that was forced to leave her home to escape a life of abuse at the hands of her father. Her mother died, having committed suicide due to abuse when the little girl as three-years-old.

2. The young woman had become friends with my children during their various holiday visits, between 2013 and 2014, to Burundi, where my sister lived during her diplomatic tour of duty for the SA government.

3. During this period, Mimi, as we all call her in the house, visited my family in South Africa twice, including spending the festive holidays of 2013 with us.

4. As required by our immigration laws, my family and I provided letters of invitation and confirmation for living expenses in order for her visa to be issued. On both occasions that she had visited us in 2013, Mimi was issued a visa (visitor’s permit) on the presentation of her Burundi passport.

5. It was only after our children had returned with Mimi to Burundi for the January leg of the holidays that we became aware of the circumstances under which she had been living and that since her childhood, she had lived a life of abuse and had lived with various relatives and foster families in Europe, the US and Burundi, since her mother died.

6. She had expressed a wish to live in South Africa to pursue her studies and to live in a safe environment. Her father initially allowed her to travel to SA and also gave her passport which he normally kept.

7. On the day the children were to travel, her father followed her at the airport with security personnel and demanded that she not travel. Mimi was already over 18 years of age and protested that she can no longer continue to live in a secretive life of abuse and that with her father’s powerful connections she will not receive protection in Burundi. (This traumatic conversation of the confrontation in the Airport security office is recorded by the children and is available.)

8. Since her father could not legally stop her from travelling, he once again confiscated her passport, which still had a valid three months South African visa from her  previous travel to SA 

9. From this moment, Mimi resolved to seek refuge with friends and other families and seek help to obtain papers to leave Burundi on her own.

10. She approached the UNCHR who registered her case but could not assist her as their scope was limited to assisting refugees who were entering their Burundi seeking protection from other countries. They did not have the ability to assist her to leave the country, but given the seriousness of her case, they advised her to seek entry into the Democratic Republic of Congo and advised her to contact the Congolese embassy in Bujumbura. 

11. She was then advised she could be assisted to obtain a temporary Congolese passport. In order to avoid the risk of alerting her father of the impending escape, she had to assume a false name at the Uvira border, she was assisted with temporary travel documents to travel into the Congo and present herself to the South African Embassy and reveal her true identity for assistance and protection.

12. Having concern for her destitute situation, and worried for her safety in a foreign country, I had once again, in my individual capacity, written an assurance letter to the SA embassy in the DRC to assist her in obtaining a visa so that she can travel to SA. In this regard she had become a classical case for refugee assistance and protection.

13. She was, however, arrested in the Congo on suspicion of holding a fraudulent document as she couldn’t speak French or any of the Congolese local languages.

14. This young, frail and vulnerable woman, known to my family and a friend of our children, became destitute and vulnerable to further abuse, possibly even sexual harassment. She was in detention for a total of 10 days.

15. It was also around this time that I was supposed to travel on official business for the 26th AU summit in Addis Abba towards the end of January 2014. My delegation and I were also due to meet with my counterpart in the DRC, in preparation for the ministerial consultation of countries dealing with the Great Lakes crisis, on the side of the AU summit.  

16. Given this opportunity, after the meeting, I had brought the matter of Mimi’s plight to the minister to enquire if there is a way for her to be assisted. 

17. The minister in the DRC, then consulted the immigration office to enquire about her circumstances, and was informed that she had not committed a crime and was only detained to verify how she obtained a Congolese travel document and that they had concluded there investigation in that regard. They also confirmed that my account of her circumstances collaborated her written statement at the time of detention and that she could be released.

18. To avoid her being deported back to her country, I offered to take her with me and to assist her in gaining her lawful travel documents. It is therefore completely misleading, as reported by the Sunday Times, that I had organised a trip and assembled a delegation of senior military and government officials, simply to travel to the Congo to illegally “smuggle” a child. Mimi had been lawfully released by the Congolese government after my clarification of her circumstances and the conclusion of their own investigation.

19. Fortunately Mimi had kept a copy of her passport with a South African Visa on a memory stick, and it was through this document that she was able to travel with me to Addis Ababa and return to South Africa, legally. Why the Sunday Times report chooses to claim that she travelled with fraudulent documents, is beyond comprehension. The copy of this document is also available. 

20. She has since applied and obtained a study permit and enrolled at a college in South Africa while living in my house.

21. Mimi is finally on a path of healing and living in conditions of safety and it is my hope that she will find stability that will help to prepare her for a full and productive future life

22. Over this period, she has re-established contact with her family, and recently, we recently also received a request from her father to meet with her, and with her consent advised that he can come and see her at the house where she can be comfortable.

23. It is my hope that she can continue to study and complete her studies with our support and that this will prepare her to be a stable and independent woman, when she finally leaves our home on completion of her schooling.

24. I have no regrets in the actions that I have taken and my involvement in assisting this child. I would never have been able to live with my conscience if something had happened to her when I knew that I could have done something to help her. I believe it was the right thing to do.”

The minister said she would like it placed on record that the Sunday Times reporter, Wa Afrika and the the editor-in-chief, who both interviewed here, were given the facts as outlined in her statement. 

The ministry said it had initially recorded its concern with the editor that the minister was only informed at 14h00 [on Saturday] that there a story involving her was being written for the following day, and that wanted her response. "It was always our concern that such a last minute approach would jeopardise the integrity of the story as, so close to the deadline, the story had already been written without the minister’s side of the story, and that it would be difficult, at that late stage to rework the story to reflect the truth, even after obtaining the facts," it said in the statement.  

The ministry said the "sensational manner in which the report was finally written" confirmed their fears. It said the newspapers had insisted it would go ahead with their own story, resulting i the interview being granted. "The sensational headline for a front page story was however too tempting for them to take the time to verify all the facts that have been given, including contacting the UNHCR, the immigration departments and Mimi’s family back home. Once again, the truth suffered at the hands of unethical and unprofessional conduct of an enthusiastic reporter yearning for bygone glory. This in violation of the Press Council code," it said.

The minister said she reserved all her rights in seeking recourse on this matter for her, her family, including the protection of Mimi from abuse and harassment.

Read more on:    sunday times  |  nosiviwe mapisa-nqakula  |  media  |  child abuse

Join the conversation! encourages commentary submitted via MyNews24. Contributions of 200 words or more will be considered for publication.

We reserve editorial discretion to decide what will be published.
Read our comments policy for guidelines on contributions.

Inside News24

Traffic Alerts
There are new stories on the homepage. Click here to see them.


Create Profile

Creating your profile will enable you to submit photos and stories to get published on News24.

Please provide a username for your profile page:

This username must be unique, cannot be edited and will be used in the URL to your profile page across the entire network.


Location Settings

News24 allows you to edit the display of certain components based on a location. If you wish to personalise the page based on your preferences, please select a location for each component and click "Submit" in order for the changes to take affect.

Facebook Sign-In

Hi News addict,

Join the News24 Community to be involved in breaking the news.

Log in with Facebook to comment and personalise news, weather and listings.