Zuma cannot be the judge and the jury - court hears

2017-10-24 20:39
President Jacob Zuma. (Thuli Dlamini, Gallo Images, The Times, file)

President Jacob Zuma. (Thuli Dlamini, Gallo Images, The Times, file)

Multimedia   ·   User Galleries   ·   News in Pictures Send us your pictures  ·  Send us your stories

Pretoria – President Jacob Zuma risks playing the judge and the jury of his own court if he appoints a judge to oversee a judicial commission of inquiry to look into allegations of state capture, the North Gauteng High Court in Pretoria heard on Tuesday.

"The president does not have the inner workings of the judiciary. The Chief Justice is the most suitable to appoint a judge who will preside over the inquiry," said legal heavyweight, Vincent Maleka SC, who represents former Public Protector Thuli Madonsela.

Maleka told a full bench of the court in Pretoria that Zuma should not delay the establishment of a commission of inquiry any further.

He argued before Judge President Dunstan Mlambo and Phillip Boruchowitz and Wendy Hughes.

READ: Public Protector does not have powers to dictate to Zuma, court hears

Maleka said Madonsela's remedial actions should be upheld instead of reviewed and set aside, as requested by Zuma.

Madonsela had been looking into allegations of an improper relationship between the president and the Gupta family in relation to key appointments in Zuma's Cabinet and the awarding of contracts at state-owned enterprises.

She said she did not have the necessary resources to finish her investigation into state capture and recommended a judicial inquiry, which was to be appointed by the President.

Mlambo quizzed about whether the public protector had acted constitutionally. He responded: “The public protector has powers to investigate improper conduct. She did that. She did not find conclusive findings because she did not have the necessary resources and funding."


Economic Freedom Fighters lawyer, advocate Tembeka Ngcukaitobi, told the court that "no one could be a judge in their own court," and thus it would be improper for Zuma to appoint a judge to oversee the inquiry.

He said such a move could also create doubt in the public's minds. "The reason the public protector asked Chief Justice Mogoeng Mogoeng to appoint a judge was because of a perceived conflict of interest," said Ngcukaitobi.

He submitted that Zuma would be acting rationally if he appointed someone who had been recommended by Mogoeng. Ngcukaitobi reminded the court that Zuma, on more than one occasion, announced publicly that he would establish a commission of inquiry.

"The President did not make pronouncements in front of his friends. It was in Parliament… and in public," he said.

He said Madonsela was well within her rights to ask Zuma to establish a commission of inquiry.

"The public protector not only acted lawfully, she also acted correctly by recommending remedial action."

Zuma should not use the courts to reverse his commitments on complying with statements he had been making in public, he said.

"The scheme of the remedial action is perfectly consistent with the Constitution."

Ngcukaitobi said it was critical that the person appointed be independent and added that “it is not enough for the President to give us his assurance that there will be independence."

He submitted that Zuma should pay legal costs personally.

The lawyer representing the United Democratic Movement and the Congress of the People, advocate Dali Mpofu SC, began his submissions by saying the case was one of the most important cases to grace South African courts.

"It can never get worse than state capture. It cannot get worse that the head of state is implicated in what amounts to criminal activity," said Mpofu.

On the question of Madonsela's observations, Mpofu said the former public protector's observations were serious enough to warrant an investigation because, at the time, Madonsela "believed she had enough to stop the rot".

Mpofu agreed with Ngcukaitobi’s submissions that Zuma “could not be the judge in his own case”. The case continues on Wednesday.

Read more on:    jacob zuma  |  thuli madonsela

Inside News24

Traffic Alerts
There are new stories on the homepage. Click here to see them.


Create Profile

Creating your profile will enable you to submit photos and stories to get published on News24.

Please provide a username for your profile page:

This username must be unique, cannot be edited and will be used in the URL to your profile page across the entire 24.com network.