Final arguments in Oscar trial - As it happened

2014-08-07 14:50

Get all the details as final arguments were given in the Oscar Pistorius trial.


Jump to

Last Updated at 19:16
07 Aug 16:40

07 Aug 16:05
And with that we close updates. We'll be back tomorrow (Friday) as the defence continues giving its final argument. Cheers.

07 Aug 15:54

07 Aug 15:38
Roux asks if he can continue tomorrow (Friday). Judge shuffles some papers...

07 Aug 15:37
Roux: once you measure the evidence against objective facts, there's a difference between reliability and credibility.

07 Aug 15:36
Roux: Stipp tells us about accused shouting help help help at a time when no-one else heard it...that was after 03:30.

07 Aug 15:35
Roux repeats that Nel had to move gunshots from 1st to 2nd shots because it would destroy evidence of his witnesses.

07 Aug 15:33
Roux: If the shots were at 03:17, how would the accused have been able to do all things he had done? Its impossible.

07 Aug 15:32
Roux: what about the 1st set of shots? Heard by neighbours. This isn't fantastical evidence.

07 Aug 15:30
It's avoiding of material, objective facts that's causing the difficulties, says Roux.

07 Aug 15:30
Roux: All these difficulties appear in state's case because they were forced to vacillate.They had to say 2nd noise were the shots

07 Aug 15:28
Roux says the state's facts cannot reconcile.

07 Aug 15:27
Roux rejects Nel's claim today that RS and OP might have been arguing in kitchen in early hours. "It doesn't fit..."

07 Aug 15:25
Roux on Tashas shooting: Yes, the accused was negligent when handling the firearm. We will deal with that.

07 Aug 15:23
Roux now pointing to the "incorrect" translation that Van Merwe "woke up" when it was actually "she got up".

07 Aug 15:23
Roux defending his client strongly over this -  'You cant call the accused a liar because scene was disturbed'

07 Aug 15:21
Roux says he has more photos showing the police have been telling untruths about crime scene and trying to make OP "a liar."

07 Aug 15:20
Roux says defence now has photo that shows cord was long enough. Cord itself went missing.

07 Aug 15:19
Roux getting quite high-pitched. His frustration and anger making itself clear in his tone. 

07 Aug 15:19
Roux: it was put to accused that the extension cord cannot reach the plug...we asked for the cord to test it...

07 Aug 15:17
Roux: We know that police picked up and moved things, it happened. Now state demands we show conspiracy.

07 Aug 15:14
Roux: I show seriousness of this aspect...we're not talking about a conspiracy, but expect things to be there, and they're not...

07 Aug 15:13
Roux: You cannot dump a police official onto the defence... that's not what a criminal trial is all about.

07 Aug 15:12
Roux: We KNOW investigating officer Hilton Botha told blatant lies to incriminate.

07 Aug 15:11
As Roux speaks, Kenny Oldewadge sits back in his chair, his head held high as if he's thinking "Exactly. Take that, Nel".

07 Aug 15:10
Roux now mentions references where Nel said: "You were lying".

07 Aug 15:09
Roux argues the state is unfairly using OP's gun charges to bolster their murder case. Says they cannot be linked.

07 Aug 15:09
Roux: State said accused wasn't anxious, but it's not to say two hours later when he perceived danger he's not anxious.

07 Aug 15:05
Roux: what you cannot do in a criminal matter is ignore serious material facts.

07 Aug 15:04
Barry Roux says he wants to correct some 'material facts' made by the State. The advocate is speaking even slower than Nel.

07 Aug 15:01
Masipa says court can sit another half an hour. Roux begins...

07 Aug 15:00
Defence advocate Barry Roux suggests they start at 09:00 on Friday.

07 Aug 15:00
And with that, Nel concludes. "As the court pleases," he ends.

07 Aug 14:58
He had lots of time for reflection, he armed himself in the bedroom. That's pre-meditated, says Nel.

07 Aug 14:55
Nel: we have the accused armed and ready, with gun pointed at door. A reasonable man won't fire without cause

07 Aug 14:53
Nel tells judge that if she rejects state's version, she must still find OP guilty of murder.

07 Aug 14:51
Nel goes on - OP acted with 'dolus eventualis' i.e. he fired 4 shots into small toilet and must have known he would hit and kill.

07 Aug 14:50
Nel: His intention when he fired those shots, was to kill a human being.

07 Aug 14:49
Nel insists objectively assessed there was no imminent attack on the accused and he armed himself ready to shoot.

07 Aug 14:48
Nel: Even if you accept OP's version of intruder, he cannot escape conviction on murder with dolus directus' i.e. intent.

07 Aug 14:46
Nel: If the only person in the house was the accused, why would she hide herself?

07 Aug 14:45
Nel uses the baton in the relay race metaphor again. He talks about disqualification for dropping it.

07 Aug 14:44
Nel: It's strictly not allowed to hold onto ammunition if you don't have a permit. The intention is irrelevant.

07 Aug 14:42
OP's father frowns, his hand to his mouth, fixed on Nel as the prosecutor speaks of OP's possession of his dad's ammunition.

07 Aug 14:40
Nel: Count 4 - possession of the ammunition. OP wrote competency tests, he knew the law.

07 Aug 14:39
Nel says this all shows that the athlete is incapable of taking responsibility for his actions.

07 Aug 14:38
Nel: OP never said (after Tasha's shooting) 'what happened'? This gun just went off!

07 Aug 14:37
Nel on Tashas incident: The trigger safety prevents gun from firing if the trigger is not pulled.

07 Aug 14:35
Nel links OP defence on those charges to his behaviour on murder charge - evasion of responsibility.

07 Aug 14:34

Nel: the accused states he did not discharge the firearm, it went off in his possession.

There is no other finding that the accused pulled the trigger, says Nel.

Jump to

SHARE: publishes all comments posted on articles provided that they adhere to our Comments Policy. Should you wish to report a comment for editorial review, please do so by clicking the 'Report Comment' button to the right of each comment.

Comment on this story
Comments have been closed for this article.

Inside News24

Competition regulation for a growing and inclusive economy

ADVERTORIAL: The Competition Commission of South Africa is conducting advocacy work in the South African automotive aftermarket industry and has gazetted a Draft Code of Conduct for public comment.

There are new stories on the homepage. Click here to see them.


Create Profile

Creating your profile will enable you to submit photos and stories to get published on News24.

Please provide a username for your profile page:

This username must be unique, cannot be edited and will be used in the URL to your profile page across the entire network.


Location Settings

News24 allows you to edit the display of certain components based on a location. If you wish to personalise the page based on your preferences, please select a location for each component and click "Submit" in order for the changes to take affect.

Facebook Sign-In

Hi News addict,

Join the News24 Community to be involved in breaking the news.

Log in with Facebook to comment and personalise news, weather and listings.