DA MP ordered out of House

2010-11-11 16:01

Cape Town - DA MP David Maynier was ordered out of the National Assembly on Thursday, after refusing to withdraw a statement in which he accused Defence Minister Lindiwe Sisulu of "telling a big political fib" to Parliament.

Maynier, who has taken to using members' statement time in the House to call on Sisulu to release interim reports of the national defence force service commission, earlier questioned reasons given by the defence minister for not doing so

"One of the many reasons in the minister's arsenal of excuses (for not releasing the report) was that there was no link between the interim reports and the defence amendment bill, but... there is a link.

"The interim report itself contains a draft defence amendment bill. How is it then possible... if it is not linked?

"The fact is, the minister has been caught out telling a big political fib to this Parliament. And the minister should now take steps... to release the interim reports," Maynier said.

On a point of order from Deputy Basic Education Minister Enver Surty, who questioned whether it was possible to "attack the integrity of a member of this House without bringing about a substantive motion", Speaker Max Sisulu said he would study the matter and come back with a ruling.

At the end of members' statement time, he delivered one.

"Saying the honourable minister of defence and military veterans told this Parliament 'a big political fib' is tantamount to saying the minister lied to Parliament - a serious charge, and one that is definitely unparliamentary, and in this case, without any substantive motion," he ruled.

He then asked Maynier to withdraw the statement.

"Speaker, with respect, I refuse to withdraw the statement," Maynier told him, and was then asked by Sisulu to leave the chamber, which he did.

Maynier has used the past two members' statement times to controversially read extracts from a leaked copy of the interim report.

This has included reference to its findings that the combat readiness of the SA National Defence Force's state of combat readiness is "not quite as good as it should be", and that low morale in the force "could even threaten state security".

In a statement issued later on Thursday, DA Chief Whip Ian Davidson said the party stood fully behind Maynier and his statement.

"The DA stands fully behind shadow defence minister David Maynier MP, and the comments that he made in Parliament today regarding Defence Minister Lindiwe Sisulu's handling of the national defence force service commission report.

"Mr Maynier's expulsion from Parliament, by Speaker Max Sisulu, is unacceptable. It is Minister Lindiwe Sisulu's behaviour that is unparliamentary, and warrants rebuke.

"Minister Sisulu has repeatedly been uncooperative with Parliament, contravening her constitutional duties to uphold the principles of accountability and transparency."

Davidson said it was only fair and right that such conduct was brought to Parliament's, and by extension, the South African public's attention.

  • pointblankza - 2010-11-11 16:09

    Booring... who cares about politicians, they all a bunch of wankers.

      Nathan - 2010-11-11 17:05

      Well you definitely don't seem to care, so don't read the article.

  • GT - 2010-11-11 16:35

    Nothing like having brother protecting sister in parliament.

  • DeonL - 2010-11-11 16:35

    Minister Sisulu is a law on her own. She fired some soldiers a year ago illegaly and she is still fighting them while they are getting paid. She should have been axed too last month.

  • Chris - 2010-11-11 17:22

    @Smanga, I agree kick out the ANC oppressors.They think it is their time to do as they like and rip the economy and country apart by fraud and corruption and they are not accountable to anyone and that they are all above the law.The fact that parliament is in the Western Cape where there is discipline and good governance they feel inferior and there complete incompetence shows very clearly.They can fool their constituencies some times but not all the people all the time.They will therefore not be able to rule for ever and have the House forever.Not now ,not ever.They say the only insect that can survive even the atomic bomb is the cockroach.

  • Francois - 2010-11-11 17:28

    Sisulu is part of the gang and will not be expelled. All in Africa starts with gangs. The best gang and his buddies becomes the government at the end of the day. That is what all gangs strives for. They scare everybody else and with a nation where the majority has an IQ of 70, what do you expect?

      Sizwe - 2010-11-11 21:30

      IQ of 70 care to share how you reached that conclusion? Statistically ofcourse.... Oh and let me guess you believe in the Knights Templar and their control of global financial systems don't you? You are an idiot.....

      pointblankza - 2010-11-12 08:34

      The Knights Templar... hahaha.. nice Sizwe :)

  • geanann - 2010-11-11 18:01

    We all know HRH Lindiwe would have the unwavering support of brother Max. Remember these people carry corrupt comrades into and out of prison.

  • lebo7278 - 2010-11-17 22:04

    I would like to have a copy of the report, dont see any reason why it should be not realesed, as a soldier i thinks its only fair to know what the commision findings are.

      people.3000 - 2011-01-25 13:30

      agreed! - 2011-01-25 13:46

      Agreed why is every thing so top sectret what are they hiding again and who's pocket has benefited, I thinks all those people in service would benefit if put in to help them. cant pay penuts for professional work, lets all raise the standard.

      jiamalunga - 2011-01-25 14:21

      Lebo they are hiding those reports to protect their own bank accounts.

  • onetickie - 2011-03-24 00:32

    I was under the impression that most ministers and politicians are liars!

  • pages:
  • 1