'Inconsistencies in Easter 2017 road carnage spin' - JPSA

Cape Town - On April 21, Transport Minister Joe Maswanganyi announced that 235 people had been killed on South African roads during the the 2017 Easter holidays.

He said this was a 51% increase over last year's figure of 156. Maswanganyi announced the preliminary statistics at the GCIS head office in Pretoria.

Easter saw tens of thousands of South Africans taking to the roads for holiday and religious pilgrimages.

The Justice Project South Africa, questions the validity of the statistics and the cost of crashes in South Africa. The JPSA said: "This year’s Easter road fatalities represents an unmitigated catastrophe and trying to place spin on it in order to lessen the blow is both, disingenuous and extremely telling of the Department of Transport and RTMC’s complete failure to take ownership of the problem."

JPSA responds

Howard Dembovsky, JPSA chairman, said: "When the Minister of Transport, Joe Maswanganyi announced the 2017 Easter road fatality statistics on Friday 21 April, reference was made to the dramatic peak in fatalities which occurred in 2015 in order to pad the blow of this year’s 235 immediate fatalities, and wherein it was claimed by the Minister that “this year’s fatalities are still significantly lower than the 333 fatalities recorded in 2015”.

On 8 April 2015, the former Transport Minister, Dipuo Peters said: “The total crashes for the period under review is 208 resulting in 287 fatalities as opposed to the previous year during the same period when we had 148 crashes resulting in 193 fatalities”.

What did you think about law enforcement during easter? Do you agree with JPSA? Email us or get in touch via Facebook and Twitter.

Dembovsky said: "Just where the 16% (46) additional fatalities in 2015 Minister Maswanganyi refers to have come from is unclear, but presumably he is comparing finalised road fatality figures to the preliminary figures the current briefing and all such preliminary statistics briefings refer to.

"This was not the only inconsistency contained in the Minister’s briefing. When referring to the cost of crashes to government, the Minister said: 'If all road users prioritise road safety, the resources that government spends unwittingly on accidents amounting 147 Billion Rands annually, which is equal to 3.4% of the country’s GDP.

"Over and above this figure the Road Accident Fund spends R33 Billion annually on payments of claims, which could be redirected to other government priorities which will go miles to address the triple challenges of employment, poverty and inequalities, thereby assisting us to increase the pace to achieve government radical socio-economic transformation”.

Cost of crashes in SA

The JPSA says in September 2016, the CSIR published its report entitled the “cost of crashes in South Africa” which was commissioned by the RTMC and Department of Transport, wherein it was stated that the cost of road crashes to the economy in 2015 was R142.95-billion.

This was not “the cost to government”, it was the cost to the economy and included private insurance claims, the socio-economic impact thereof, costs incurred in scene management, as well as claims payments made by the Road Accident Fund, claims JPSA. 

Dembovsky adds: "By the assertions of Minister Maswanganyi, not only was the study his own department commissioned the CSIR to conduct incorrect in its conclusions, but the actual cost of road crashes to government is R37-billion higher than the total cost to the economy.

"Furthermore, the Minister has asserted that the occurrence of fatal crashes between “23h00 midnight (sic) until 05h00 in the morning” is a “new phenomenon [which] requires of us to spread our wings jointly informed by uniform working norms and standards”.

"There is nothing “new” about this phenomenon and the Department of Transport and the RTMC have been bemoaning the fact that the lack of 24/7/365 traffic law enforcement on a national basis in South Africa.

"Lastly, if the Minister is informed that it is in any way unusual for fatal crashes to occur during the hours of darkness when traffic authorities are sleeping, then it should be clear to anyone that he is severely misinformed."

Read the full report here.

We live in a world where facts and fiction get blurred
In times of uncertainty you need journalism you can trust. For 14 free days, you can have access to a world of in-depth analyses, investigative journalism, top opinions and a range of features. Journalism strengthens democracy. Invest in the future today. Thereafter you will be billed R75 per month. You can cancel anytime and if you cancel within 14 days you won't be billed. 
Subscribe to News24
Lockdown For
Brought to you by
Voting Booth
Do you think Mercedes will return to form later in the 2022 F1 season after two poor races?
Please select an option Oops! Something went wrong, please try again later.
Yes, don't discredit them.
33% - 456 votes
Who cares, F1 is exciting again!
44% - 593 votes
No, it's Ferrari's turn to dominate again.
23% - 314 votes