Ban on gay conversion therapy challenged

2012-10-03 13:01

San Francisco - A Christian legal group has filed a federal lawsuit challenging a landmark California law that bars a controversial therapy aimed at reversing homosexuality from being used on children and teens, calling it a violation of privacy and free speech rights.

California's Democratic Governor Jerry Brown signed the ban into law over the weekend, making the nation's most populous state the first to ban so-called conversion therapy among youth. Gay rights advocates say the therapy can psychologically harm gay and lesbian youth.

"This legislation is an outrageous violation of the civil rights of youth, of parents and of licensed counsellors, including clergy who are licensed counsellors," said Brad Dacus, president of the Pacific Justice Institute, which filed the suit late on Monday for a student who underwent the therapy and two counsellors.

"What we're advocating is for all to have the freedom and liberty to seek the counselling that meets their needs," Dacus said by telephone.

Enactment of the law marked a major victory for gay rights advocates who say the treatment, also called reparative therapy, has no medical basis because homosexuality is not a disorder.

The measure prohibits therapists from performing sexual-orientation change counselling with children and teens under 18 years old and was supported by the California Psychological Association and the California Board of Behavioural Sciences, among others.

Freedom of speech

The bill's sponsor, state Senator Ted Lieu, a Democrat from the Los Angeles suburb of Torrance, called the lawsuit frivolous.

"Under the plaintiffs' argument, the First Amendment would shield therapists and psychiatrists from medical malpractice and psychological-abuse claims simply because they use speech in practicing their medicine. That is a novel and frivolous view of the First Amendment," he said.

The suit says the law violates numerous provisions of the US Constitution, including the right to privacy, freedom of speech and the free exercise of religion.

"The statute involves government intrusion into an intimate zone of privacy," the suit says, adding that one of the plaintiffs, Dr Anthony Duk, frequently treats patients with a combination of counselling and prescription drugs, using the medication to help his clients control their sex drives.

Kate Kendell, executive director of the National Centre for Lesbian Rights, derided the lawsuit and said she would work with the state attorney general's office to defend the law, which is scheduled to take effect in January.

"It's a series of very artful dodges and red herrings and has really zero merit," she said. "This is a law that protects minors from a practice regarded by every mainstream mental health organisation as harmful, damaging and without any basis in scientific fact."

'Beyond common sense'

Representatives of the attorney general were not immediately available for comment. Meanwhile, another Christian group said it also planned to file a suit to block the law.

Mat Staver of the Florida-based Liberty Counsel said his group planned to sue the state on behalf of counsellors as well as two parents and their minor children who are currently undergoing the therapy in California.

"This new law has just gone way beyond common sense," Staver said. "Counsellors cannot counsel minors about reducing or eliminating same-sex attraction even if the client is asking for this counselling."

Dr Robert Spitzer, the psychiatrist who pioneered the treatment, has since renounced it and has apologised to the gay and lesbian community.

  • jody.beggs - 2012-10-03 13:21

    Stupid xians , just stay at home and i church and we wont laugh at you , that much ... Stop being homophobic , your not scared , your just being @rseholes ... Damn the man.

      charlesdumbwin.dumbwin - 2012-10-03 14:41

      Stupid atheists, just stop trying to sound so 'intelligent' and we won't have to laugh at you. Stop being such a religous atheist bigot! DamnYou'reStupid!

  • cathy.dejongh.5 - 2012-10-03 14:17

    Not only are we all riddled with 'sin' the day we are born, brainwashing appears to be a sinless activity to the religiously inclined. The mind boggles.

      charlesdumbwin.dumbwin - 2012-10-03 15:04


      JManAtheoi - 2012-10-03 15:50

      @CD - Look who's talking.

  • ivan.schoultz - 2012-10-03 15:38

    To the "therapists and psychiatrists" who claim their "speech" IS "practicing their medicine" ... you can't have it both ways. You cannot spew your education/institutions views as if they are your personal views and enjoy the protections of BOTH forms of speech, so please choose: - Either your "speech" comes at a very high hourly rate due to years or certifiable training and experience, and is classified as "medicine" and duly doctor-patient protectable because it has the backing of your education/institutions; or - It is "free", not-chargeable, not classified as "medicine", not doctor-patient confidential, has no educational/institutional backing, and is rightfully classified as your **Personal Opinions**, and thereby has the constitutional "free-speech" protection you seek. Which is it? Do you want to get rich and be legally protected from your **educations/institutions-views** or do you want to "affect change in the world" with your **personal-views** and be constitutionally free to do so? Or put another way: do you want **Institutional** protection or **Constitutional** protection - you choose, but you can't have it both ways. Yes, you may be a Pastor AND a Therapist, but it is WRONG to tell a patient that your education and institution both "agree" that the patient needs "fixing" simply because that is your PERSONAL view. (I know your education does NOT agree with your religion on the gay issue ... which leaves your personal opinions ... )

  • JManAtheoi - 2012-10-03 15:48

    Christians... typical.

  • irene.buthelezi.1 - 2012-10-03 18:13

    OMG but these people are sad to think they 'convert' anybody. Fools! Nobody has a choice, it's the way they are born.

  • pages:
  • 1