German nuclear village defends reactors

2011-04-19 11:07

Neckerwestheim - Ever since the Japan nuclear crisis began last month, yellow and red badges saying "Atomkraft? Nein Danke" ("Nuclear Power? No Thanks") with a smiling sun are everywhere in Germany.

But anti-nuclear activist Wolfram Scheffbuch has taken to removing his whenever he comes to the small village of Neckarwestheim in the southwest of the country.

"It's not the done thing here," the 40-something says.

Neckarwestheim is home not just to one nuclear reactor, but two - Germany's oldest, in service since 1976, and its newest, up and running since 1989. And villagers are vehemently opposed to shutting them off.

Much more than in other European countries, the spewing of radiation by Japan's stricken Fukushima plant since March 11's earthquake and tsunami has shaken to the core Germans' faith in nuclear power.

Recent weeks have seen huge protests, culminating on March 26 in a mass demonstration involving a quarter of a million people taking to the streets around the country, according to organisers.

The next day, Chancellor Angela Merkel's conservatives were turfed out of power in the southwestern state of Baden-Wuerttemberg, home to Neckarwestheim, after 58 years in charge.

Merkel reconsidering

The main reason was opposition to nuclear, allowing the ecologist Greens to double their score, not only in Baden-Wuerttemberg, but also in other local elections.

Merkel is reconsidering her 2010 move to postpone by more than a decade, until the mid-2030s, the date when Germany goes nuclear-free. The country's seven oldest reactors are switched off pending a safety review.

One of those is in Neckarwestheim, and it looks like it might never be turned on again.

But the inhabitants of the village are having none of it. Here the Greens fell well short of the 24% they scored in Baden-Wuerttemberg as a whole.

"They only got 13% or so," the mayor of the village for the past 15 years, Mario Duerr, proudly said.

And despite the fact that Merkel's Christian Democrats (CDU) scored 49%, 10 percentage points more than in the state as a whole, Duerr doesn't like the government's nuclear re-think.

Integral part of life

"I am not like the chancellor," he says. "I don't change my mind the whole time."

Looking around the well-ordered village, with its tennis courts and ultra-modern sports hall under construction, it is easy to see why its inhabitants are no fans of a nuclear-free future.

The operator of the nuclear reactors, Energie Baden-Wuerttemberg, better known as EnBW, accounts for 80% of the village's corporate tax receipts, and 250 villagers go to work at the plant every day.

The local nightclub where Neckarwestheim's youth goes to dance and hang out is called the Uranium Bar.

"You have to live well here," the mayor says.

Suntanned Elisabeth Rech, who has managed the village's Hotel am Markt for the past 20 years, is rushing off to play golf, but has time to tell AFP that her business would be ruined if the reactors go.

Ruining the view

"The power station accounts for almost 90% of my revenues," she says. "And what would be the point of shutting down our reactors if we end up importing electricity from France?"

France, which borders Baden-Wuerttemberg to the west, generates about 80% of its electricity using nuclear power.

Pensioner Maria Neubauer, tending her garden in full view of the reactors, feels the same.

"It's part of everyday life," she says.

She's not unhappy about the prospect of the oldest reactor never being switched on again, which seems likely. Because of the radioactivity?

"Yes, and also because there is less steam. Sometimes it really ruins the view."

  • horst.o.muller - 2011-04-19 13:02

    Looks like there are at least some people still able to think rationally when it comes to nuclear energy. And they live right next door to it.

      rammstein.f4n - 2011-04-19 13:49


      Madelane - 2011-04-19 15:08

      And there are people that live close to active volcanoes.....their choice as it only affects them.....nuclear reactors gone wrong affects the entire environment.

  • BugsyJamesy - 2011-04-19 14:07

    I've met am German anti Nuclear activist a few years ago. The feeling I got was that he was only campaigning because it was something to do, even with their good education system he knew very little about nuclear power and the planets energy needs. He even suggested that we go back to burning wood in our stoves. I Don't know if it was only him or if everybody had these ideas, but his arguments did not impress me very much although otherwise he seemed like a intelligent person. It's probably a agenda that is politically driven that has very little to do with Nuclear power.

  • rpretorius - 2011-04-19 16:11

    I've come to the same conclusion. People are simply protesting against it without suggesting any realistic or sustainable alternative. Neither are they aware that more people die at gas or coal stations around the world than have ever at nuclear plants. They also do not understand that reactors such as those in Japan, which use light water, cannot explode, etc. I always ask them equally stupid question like, would you sacrifice your child first, because without modern electricity how would we make medicine?

  • pages:
  • 1