No problems with circumcision in Germany

2012-07-01 20:32

Berlin - Germany's foreign minister on Sunday offered assurances that Germany protects religious traditions after a court ruled that circumcising young boys on religious grounds amounts to bodily harm even if parents consent.

A state court in Cologne ruled recently that the child's right to physical integrity trumps freedom of religion and parents' rights.

The ruling was strongly criticised by the head of Germany's Central Council of Jews, Dieter Graumann, who urged parliament to clarify the legal situation to protect religious freedom.

Muslim leaders also expressed concern.

Foreign Minister Guido Westerwelle said that a legal debate "must not lead to doubts arising internationally about religious tolerance in Germany.

"The free exercise of religion is protected in Germany and that includes religious traditions," Westerwelle said in a statement.

"All our partners in the world should know that."

Volker Beck, a senior lawmaker with the opposition Greens, left open whether a "correction" of the Cologne ruling should be sought through the court system or through new legislation, but he said the result should be clarity that circumcision on religious grounds is justified so long as hygienic and medical standards are kept to.

Graumann has pointed out that the circumcision of newborn Jews has been practiced for thousands of years.

Muslims also circumcise young boys, while many parents request it on health grounds.

The European Jewish Congress added its voice to the criticism on Sunday.

The case in Cologne involved a doctor accused of carrying out a circumcision on a 4-year-old, approved by his Muslim parents, that led to medical complications.

The doctor was acquitted, however, and prosecutors said they won't appeal.

Unlike female circumcision, there is no law prohibiting the practice and the ruling isn't binding for other courts - but it creates a potentially tricky legal situation for doctors who perform the procedure on parents' orders.

  • PeterAlan - 2012-07-01 22:13

    We need this kind of legislation to protect young men in South Africa. The number of 'initiation' complications leading to disability, AIDS-transference and death is utterly unacceptable.

      james.rossouw - 2012-07-13 21:20

      Jewish sage Maimonides in " Guide For the perplexed "writes Circ reduces bloodflow, growth, sensetivity, plaesure for both partners. Real objective, become more cerebral. Non Circ. people practice personal Hygiene and have no problem. In Monsey NY the Orthodox Jews give the boys Herpes when they lick the penis after Circ. The blood is not allowed to touch the ground. Barbaric.

  • hendrikvs - 2012-07-01 22:15

    Such a dumb practice. Even for the sake of so called religion it is dumb to mutilate a person that does not have the power to do anything about it!

      hendrikvs - 2012-07-02 14:19

      And then there are people who can think for themselves and not being brainwashed by religion.....

  • Ken Jay May - 2012-07-01 22:21

    I was never circumcised!...mine's just gone from wear and tear!

  • Preshen - 2012-07-02 08:27

    Circumcision is a rip off

  • frank.ohara.75 - 2012-07-02 19:15

    I'm not a German so I have some questions. (1.) Can a Foreign Minister over rule a German court? (2.) Can anyone else? (3.) Can a Foreign Minister set national laws? It would seem that some think they have far more power than they actually have.

  • pages:
  • 1