Nuclear stockpiles are not safe - study

2012-01-12 12:37

Washington - The world's nuclear stockpiles are far from safe and could fall into the hands of terrorists, the American non-governmental organisation Nuclear Threat Initiative said in a new study.

The research listed North Korea, Pakistan and Iran as holding the most vulnerable nuclear inventories.

The organisation, dedicated to nuclear non-proliferation, enlisted international experts to classify the security of atomic materials kept at hundreds of sites in 32 countries that hold more than 1kg of highly enriched uranium (HEU) or plutonium, which can be used to make nuclear bombs.

"Some of those sites are well-secured, many are not, leaving weapons-usable nuclear materials vulnerable to theft or sale on the black market to terrorist organisations that have publicly stated their desire to use nuclear weapons," the study's authors said.

The experts relied on public data to develop five criteria: The amount of HEU and plutonium available in a country and the number of storage sites; site protection and transportation access; transparency and application of international standards; the capacity and willingness of a state to apply the standards; and societal factors, such as political stability, corruption and existence of groups that seek to acquire nuclear materials.


The three countries with the highest rankings are Australia (94 out of 100), Hungary (89) and the Czech Republic (87).

At the low end of the scale were North Korea (last with 37) because of its lack of transparency and compliance with international standards; Pakistan (41) because of political instability, the existence of militant groups, corruption and the number of storage sites; Iran (46); Vietnam (48) and India (49).

The five "official" nuclear powers rank in a mid-range, primarily because of the importance of their stockpiles and because of corruption found in China and Russia.

Britain is ranked 10th (79), the US 13th (78), France 19th (73), Russia 24th (65) and China 27th (52).

Because of its lack of transparency and lax control procedures, Israel was ranked 25th (56). Israel has never confirmed it is a nuclear-armed state but is internationally regarded as possessing atomic weapons.

Japan was ranked 23rd (68), largely for its absence of an independent regulatory agency.

"The Index highlights how countries can take steps to improve the security of nuclear materials," NTI President Joan Rohlfing said in a statement.

"By offering recommendations for all states, it can be a valuable tool in helping set priorities. All states can and should do more."

Fifty countries adopted a work plan to better control "vulnerable materials" during a 2010 summit on nuclear security in Washington. The next summit is scheduled for March in Seoul.

The study is available on the website.

  • JamesLoretz - 2012-01-12 13:13

    I'm not too worried! We have Austin Powers and Johnny English!

  • anthony.weineck - 2012-01-12 13:51

    Thank you News24 for bringing us this report, and for once actually providing the link. If you had followed the link, perhaps to find where SA ranks on this scale - I think that might be interesting to SAns - you may have found that your link is not that useful. The link we need is here: SA is ranked at 19 with a score of 73 - on par with France and Mexico, and one step up from Kazakhstan.

  • pages:
  • 1