Plan needed for West Bank barrier - NGO

2012-12-13 21:45

Jerusalem - Israel's High Court ordered the military on Thursday to reconsider the route of a portion of its security barrier, which was to pass through the West Bank village of Battir, an environmental NGO said.

"The High Court this afternoon... ordered the military to present an alternative plan within 90 days," the Friends of the Earth Middle East (FoEME) group said.

"We are convinced that, due to the unique nature of the area under discussion, there is a need for the security officials to reconsider, in particular as regards the nature of the barrier and security arrangements of the problematic areas," the group quoted the court decision as saying.

The route of Israel's barrier in the West Bank has been challenged on multiple occasions, but the court decision comes after an unusual coalition jointly contested the portion due to pass through Battir.

FoEME, along with residents of the village and the Israeli Nature and Parks Authority, argued that that the planned route would damage a network of ancient terraces in Battir, calling on the court to force a reroute.

Battir, located west of Bethlehem, is famous for the terraces dating back thousands of years that the Palestinians hope will receive Unesco World Heritage status next year.

Israel's defence ministry argued that the route would not damage or affect the terraces, and urged the court to leave the plan intact.

FoEME's Israel director Gidon Bromberg said the group was "delighted" with the court decision.

"The military had failed to bring a single expert in the field of cultural and natural heritage to support their case, yet they constantly claimed that they were striking the right balance between the needs of security and heritage values," he said in a statement.

"We trust that this time the military will reconsider security options based on the advice of heritage experts."

The defence ministry had no immediate comment on the court decision.

  • jojo.balela.1 - 2012-12-13 22:01

    Killing people is one thing, but when you try to kill the natural vegetation then the courts will get you! LOL

  • fidelity.mcoshi - 2012-12-13 23:10

    Whenever I want to throw a dart at Israelis I remember there are people like these NGOs there!

      larry.lachman.54 - 2012-12-14 06:32

      Make a point to remember, Fidel, that there is also a government and legal system in Israel that gives people like these NGO's a fair hearing and even rules in their favor.

      duncan.gill1 - 2012-12-14 10:37

      yes larry this is civil society at work in Israel!Not government at work..a big difference,surely even you can recognize that civil society the world over are those that seek not the self gain trappings of being in elected office but rather seek to do good and serve societies interests from a selfless positron.The NGO'S are the real governments of the world nowadays,the real leaders!

      larry.lachman.54 - 2012-12-14 11:35

      Dunkie, the NGO's filed an appeal with the Israeli judicial system. If it was any other country in the Middle East, the regime would have steamrolled the court decision in their favor. The NGO's may have filed, but the democratic legal system ruled according to the laws of the land. Big up for civilised Israel.

  • pages:
  • 1