Rights group - Syrian rebels abuse too

2012-03-20 22:28

Beirut - An international human rights group on Tuesday accused some in Syria's armed opposition of carrying out serious abuses, including the kidnapping and torture of security forces, in a sign of the growing complexity of the year-old uprising against President Bashar Assad.

The statement by Human Rights Watch comes as Syria's rebellion transforms into an insurgency, with army defectors and other government opponents taking up arms to drive out Assad. The development has added another violent dimension to a conflict that already has killed 8 000 people since last March.

"The Syrian government's brutal tactics cannot justify abuses by armed opposition groups," said Sarah Leah Whitson, Middle East director at Human Rights Watch. "Opposition leaders should make it clear to their followers that they must not torture, kidnap, or execute under any circumstances."

The Syrian uprising began with mostly peaceful protests against the government, inspired by the Arab Spring uprisings across the region. But the regime cracked down violently, opening fire on demonstrations and rounding up thousands of protesters.

Assad has justified the crackdown by saying terrorists and foreign extremists are driving the revolt.

The regime has used the increasing attacks on security forces and military sites as vindication that it is facing an extremist threat.

But the opposition denies that, saying Assad's opponents have been forced to take up weapons because government troops used tanks and snipers on peaceful protests.

The New York-based Human Rights Watch made Tuesday's statement in an open letter to the opposition Syrian National Council. The group stressed that many of the anti-government groups reported to be carrying out abuses do not appear to belong to an organised command structure or to be following orders from the Syrian National Council.

But Syria's opposition leadership has a responsibility to speak out and condemn such abuses, Human Rights Watch said. The group also said it has received reports of executions by armed opposition groups of security force members and civilians.

SNC leaders did not immediately respond to calls by The Associated Press seeking comment.

The most potent armed force fighting Assad's regime is the Free Syrian Army, made up of army defectors and others. But there are other, smaller groups operating as well.

The report cited witnesses who told Human Rights Watch that armed groups identifying themselves with the opposition are kidnapping both civilians and members of the security forces.

An activist identified as Mazen said he learned that three people who worked with the government had been tortured to death in Idlib in northern Syria, an opposition stronghold.

Another Syrian activist identified as Samih told HRW that members of the Free Syrian Army were kidnapping soldiers.

"They would kidnap them and ask their parents to pay a ransom to let them go," Samih said, according to Human Rights Watch. The Free Syrian Army denied kidnapping soldiers, saying they were detaining them during military operations.


The UN says more than 8 000 people have been killed in the yearlong uprising, which has deeply polarised a country where the Assad family has ruled for more than 40 years.

On Monday, Syrian rebels battled regime forces in a heavily protected, upscale area of Damascus, activists said, in a sign that the country's outgunned opposition is increasingly turning to insurgent tactics.

Russia said Tuesday it is ready to support a UN resolution endorsing Kofi Annan's plan for settling the Syrian crisis, signalling it is prepared to raise the pressure on its old ally.

Russia's Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov warned that the resolution shouldn't turn into an ultimatum to the Syrian government, setting the stage for tough bargaining over the wording of the document at the Security Council.

But Lavrov's statement appeared to indicate a shift in Moscow's stance, showing signs of impatience with Assad.

Russia and China have twice shielded Assad's regime from UN sanctions over its yearlong crackdown on protesters. But the Kremlin has also offered strong support to Annan, the former UN secretary-general who is now a joint UN-Arab League special envoy to Syria.

  • Africa21stcentury - 2012-03-21 02:42

    The problem with popular uprisings is , that criminals and thugs start mingling amongst peaceful demonstrators. But what alternative did the oppositon have,to oppose the assad family, than to go onto the streets ?? ; NONE.

      Garth - 2012-03-21 09:28

      The abuse of one's situation for revenge or other is never to be condoned.

  • Paul - 2012-03-21 07:39

    Armed opposition financially supported by the west.

      Fred - 2012-03-21 07:48

      Paul = Fidel. Both blind and stupid.

      Africa21stcentury - 2012-03-21 12:30

      Muedes, Also go to : http;/rt/news/theworldisflat--09743tghurdbb3

      Fred - 2012-03-21 21:23

      Muedes/Gollum do you even care that the unelected Assad is butchering Syrians in their homes by the thousands?

      Fred - 2012-03-22 02:46

      I've just read this statement again by Paul, with the thumbs up by four people. It's so stupid, dumb beyond words. What's the matter with you. Do you expect Syrians to allow themselves to continue being killed, maimed, detained, tortured and raped? They're Muslims. Wake up.

  • Michael - 2012-03-22 09:40

    Very clearly there are other dimensions to this complicated problem, but expecting our dear friends Freddie and Anthony to acknowledge that? Not a chance! If only the pair could sit quietly and reflect on a feasible solution, rather than mouthing their expletives and shouting in the street. Pair of stirrers with nothing more to contribute to the discussion.

  • pages:
  • 1