UN 'unfit for purpose' – Amnesty

2012-05-24 14:01

London – South Africa, along with other emerging powers India and Brazil, has been singled out by rights group Amnesty International in its annual report, saying the countries were "complicit through their silence" on key rights issues.

"You've had people standing up, putting their lives on the line," Amnesty's Secretary General Salil Shetty said.

"Unfortunately that has been met by a complete failed leadership both at the national and global level," he said.

The UN Security Council has failed to match the courage shown by protesters around the world and is increasingly "unfit for purpose", Amnesty International said in the report on Thursday.

The rights group called for the signing of a strong treaty on the global arms trade when the United Nations meets on the issue in July, saying it would be an acid test for world leaders to place rights over profits.

Amnesty highlighted the failure to end the bloodshed in Syria and said repeated vetoes by major arms exporters Russia and China had left the UN's top security body "looking redundant as a guardian of global peace".

Crimes against humanity

Shetty said that in the 21st century the UN Security Council was "simply not fit for purpose. If they do not change the way in which they behave, I think there are going to be increasing questions about the relevance of the body".

In its 50th annual report, Amnesty said the vocal support by many global powers in the early months of the Arab Spring in 2011 had not translated into action, with many international leaders now looking the other way.

In Syria the group said there was a "clear and compelling case" for alleged crimes against humanity by Bashar al-Assad's regime to be referred to the International Criminal Court.

"The determination of some UN Security Council members to shield Syria at any cost leaves accountability for these crimes elusive and is a betrayal of the Syrian people," said Shetty.

Russia and China have vetoed two Council resolutions which condemned Assad, and they fiercely oppose UN sanctions.

"Two countries that are among the top six arms dealers in the world, who are permanent members of the Security Council, may have been voting much more with their pocket in mind," said Widney Brown, senior director of international law and policy at Amnesty.

Arms control

Amnesty said it was the conference on a global treaty limiting the arms trade in July that would really show whether UN member states were willing to take on serious challenges.

The conference is set for 2-27 July in New York. It follows an agreement in 2009 by most of the world's major weapons exporters, including the United States, to seek a treaty that strengthens controls on the trade.

"The UN meeting to agree an Arms Trade Treaty in July will be an acid test for politicians to place rights over self-interest and profit," the Amnesty report said.

"Without a strong treaty, the UN Security Council's guardianship of global peace and security seems doomed to failure; its permanent members wielding an absolute veto on any resolution despite being the world's largest arms suppliers."

The UN General Assembly passed a resolution in 2006 calling for such a treaty, but the United States, the world's biggest exporter of weaponry, voted against it, the only country to do so.

The report also focused on other areas, including:

- China, which Amnesty said had thrown the "full weight" of its security apparatus into suffocating protests.

- Russia, where civic activism grew amid the biggest protests since the Soviet Union, but opposition voices were "abused and systematically undermined".

- Myanmar, where the government allowed Nobel Peace Prize winner Aung San Suu Kyi to stand in elections and freed hundreds of political prisoners, although fighting with ethnic groups and fresh detentions showed "limits to the reform".

  • Tax - 2012-05-24 14:14

    Why do they always refer to SA as an "emerging power"? The only thing that is emerging is corruption. All the good things are going backwards.

      Bones - 2012-05-24 16:25

      Or something emerging out of the front of some pants

      Fidel - 2012-05-24 19:35

      Obviously you know little of geo politics and the context with which this term is used. South Africa is punching above its weight when it comes to intl relations, but you'd rather this were not the case,yes?

      Heinz - 2012-05-25 08:59

      Fidel, you are an idiot. Please shut your mouth.

      Fidel - 2012-05-25 09:11

      Obviously, knowing the word 'idiot' does not guarantee that you can see it in yourself.

  • faerrab - 2012-05-24 14:35

    Amnesty forgot to mention that the US is the largest weapons exporter in the world

      ludlowdj - 2012-05-24 14:56

      not to mention that US forces occupy bases in 90% of the worlds countries.

      AnthonyfromAfrica - 2012-05-24 16:22

      Faerrab, What the ones , with anti Western sentments, are masters in, is to confuse ! Amnesty Interntional's report reflects on the CURRENT world situation. Name just ONE country in the world, , besides Syria, where their armed forces have snipers on rooftops, shooting life amunition on ANYTHING that moves, including women and children, and where the army launches rockets from tanks into residential buildings....NOT ONE OTHER !!! And who supplies the military hardware PLUS their advisers and experts to Syria, to kill as many civilians as possible in the shortest possible time: ----------------------------RUSSIA and IRAN----------------------

  • Fidel - 2012-05-24 14:37

    Tell that to the Iraqis......

      Fidel - 2012-05-24 23:48


  • flysouth - 2012-05-24 15:34

    The UN started to become 'unfit for purpose' abut the same time that they let in African countries. These countries, including SA invariably support the evil dictatorships of this world, particularly in Africa and Asia, on the grounds of 'solidarity', taking no cognisance of morality at all!

      sven.gohre - 2012-05-24 18:10

      flysouth, so very true. What is even more worrying is not the African failures crying out for more AID, but their demand for more say at the UN, IMF and World Bank, institutions that they do not pay for, but only use to prop up their ruling Elite, aka the political thieves of the Dark Continent.

  • henkvdwatt - 2012-05-24 16:49

    SA goverment can only stand up for what is write if it will take the ANC powers away or paint a "rasist" picture of the naked president. Otherwise they dont care.

  • Fidel - 2012-05-25 09:13

    As Sir Humphrey Appleby use to say:- "the united nations is the agreed forum to wage war on one's enemies without having to fire a single bullet." (paraphrased of course.)

  • ludlowdj - 2012-05-25 10:55

    The UN is not a peace keeper or an unbiased observer, it has its own agenda's and is working toward a one government world, which will become a reality through agreement or war as the rich and famous have stated.

  • pages:
  • 1