Queen in 'candid camera' moment on Chinese

2016-05-11 22:06
Britain's Queen Elizabeth speaks to Prime Minister David Cameron during a reception in Buckingham Palace to mark her 90th birthday. (Paul Hackett, AP)

Britain's Queen Elizabeth speaks to Prime Minister David Cameron during a reception in Buckingham Palace to mark her 90th birthday. (Paul Hackett, AP)

Multimedia   ·   User Galleries   ·   News in Pictures Send us your pictures  ·  Send us your stories

London - Britain's 90-year-old monarch has made a rare foray into political affairs, being caught on film characterising Chinese officials as "very rude" in their dealings with British counterparts during a state visit last year.

Queen Elizabeth II made the unguarded comments on Tuesday while talking to a senior police officer at a rain-soaked garden party on the grounds of Buckingham Palace.

With uncharacteristic bluntness - rarely if ever heard in public - the queen said the Chinese had not dealt properly with Barbara Woodward, the British envoy to China.

"They were very rude to the ambassador," Elizabeth said.

The comments were recorded by a palace-authorised cameraman working for three British networks and distributed to broadcasters under a pool arrangement allowing them to use the material. Two reporters close to the queen did not hear the comments, but they were easily discernible on the videotape.

In the video, the Lord Chamberlain, a senior palace official, introduced the queen to police Commander Lucy D'Orsi and explained that the officer was in charge of policing for the visit of Chinese President Xi Jinping in October.

The queen quickly responded: "Oh! Bad luck."

The official told the queen that D'Orsi had been "seriously undermined by the Chinese" in the handling of the visit.

When D'Orsi asked if the queen knew it had been a "testing time", the monarch interjected: "I did."

The officer recalled a moment when Chinese officials walked out of a meeting with Woodward, the ambassador, and told the British the trip was off.

"They walked out on both of us," D'Orsi said.

"Extraordinary," the queen said.

"It was very rude and undiplomatic I thought," D'Orsi said.


It is not clear if the queen knew she was speaking loudly enough to be easily understood on tape.

Elizabeth's broadside was unusual. As a constitutional monarch, she is prohibited from being actively involved in politics. She has assiduously earned a reputation for great discretion, and it is completely out of character for her to publicly criticise another country's diplomats.

If anything, she has been so careful to adhere strictly to her defined constitutional role that some commentators say they have no idea what she thinks about world affairs.

It is now clear, however, that she was at least annoyed by some of the positions taken by the Chinese delegation during a state visit that was vital for Britain's political and business leaders, who seek ever-closer ties with China to bolster trade.

Kerry Brown, a former British diplomat in China who directs the Lau China Institute at King's College in London, said the comments strip away the "this is the golden age" rhetoric that prevailed during the state visit.

He said no one on either side had "breathed a word" about the difficulties.

Both sides responded quickly to the break in the queen's neutral approach - by downplaying its importance and asserting that the state visit had been a triumph.

China's Foreign Ministry spokesperson, Lu Kang, asked about the queen's remarks at a daily news briefing in Beijing on Wednesday, declined to address them directly, but said Xi had made a "very successful visit" to Britain last year.

"The working teams from both sides made huge efforts to make this possible. This effort has been highly recognised by both China and Britain," Lu said.


Despite Lu's comments, China appeared to regard the queen's comments as sensitive. Information about the remarks was difficult to find on China's heavily censored internet and government monitors cut the signal of the BBC when it reported on the comments.

British Foreign Secretary Philip Hammond said the visit "got a bit stressful on both sides" but had been "highly successful".

He said that "our relationship with China is very strong and has been greatly strengthened by the success of that visit".

The remarks were recorded at one of the queen's summer garden parties, where she traditionally greets a long line of guests as she makes her way to the royal tent for tea and sandwiches.

It is customary for Peter Wilkinson, a cameraman working for UK networks, to walk in front of the queen and record her interactions with guests. The material, rarely before deemed newsworthy, is later provided to the networks for possible use.

Both the Metropolitan Police and the palace refused to comment on what they described as private conversations. The palace stressed that Xi's visit had been "extremely successful".

British officials had added layers of pomp and splendour - including a state banquet at the palace - during Xi's four-day state visit.

Xi was welcomed with a 41-gun artillery salute, and taken to Buckingham Palace in a royal gilded carriage drawn by white horses.

The queen gave Xi and his wife a personal tour of the Royal Collection at the palace. She gave them a special collection of Shakespeare's sonnets and spoke glowingly of the two countries' "global partnership" at the elaborate state dinner.

There were no public hints of tensions at the time, although Prince Charles - the heir to the throne, and a supporter of the exiled Tibetan spiritual leader the Dalai Lama, shunned by the Chinese - did not attend the gala banquet.

The two countries signed more than $46bn in trade agreements during the trip, and Prime Minister David Cameron said Britain would be China's "partner of choice" in the West.

This is not the first time British royals have been caught making undiplomatic remarks about the Chinese. Prince Charles branded Chinese diplomats "appalling old waxworks" in a private journal entry that had described the 1997 ceremony to hand Hong Kong back to Chinese rule.

In 1986, Prince Philip reportedly told British exchange students in China they would get "slitty eyes" if they stayed in China too long.

Read more on:    uk  |  china

Join the conversation!

24.com encourages commentary submitted via MyNews24. Contributions of 200 words or more will be considered for publication.

We reserve editorial discretion to decide what will be published.
Read our comments policy for guidelines on contributions.

Inside News24

Traffic Alerts
There are new stories on the homepage. Click here to see them.


Create Profile

Creating your profile will enable you to submit photos and stories to get published on News24.

Please provide a username for your profile page:

This username must be unique, cannot be edited and will be used in the URL to your profile page across the entire 24.com network.


Location Settings

News24 allows you to edit the display of certain components based on a location. If you wish to personalise the page based on your preferences, please select a location for each component and click "Submit" in order for the changes to take affect.

Facebook Sign-In

Hi News addict,

Join the News24 Community to be involved in breaking the news.

Log in with Facebook to comment and personalise news, weather and listings.