Who killed Inge? 11 years later mysterious Lotz murder still haunts


It was Wednesday 16 March 2005, an ordinary day in the Boland. Brilliant Stellenbosch University student Inge Lotz said goodbye to her boyfriend, actuary Fred van der Vyver, at 8.15. He had to attend a class at the university.

The previous night, as he did every Tuesday night, he’d slept over at her flat, 21 Shiraz in Klein Welgevonden.

Read more: Prof Jan Lotz: 'Fred, I want answers'

When he said goodbye to her it was the last time he saw her alive. Inge’s body was found in her flat at 10.36 pm that night. Now, on the 11th anniversary of her murder, the question that still haunts her family is: Who brutally murdered their beautiful girl?

After a string of frustrating court cases, neither armchair detectives nor the authorities have been able to give the Lotz family closure. YOU takes a look at how events unfolded over the past 11 years:

16 March 2005

Inge Lotz’s bloodied body is found in her flat in Klein Welgevonden, Stellenbosch, by Christo Pretorius, a church friend of Marius Botha, Fred’s flatmate.

15 April 2005

Fred takes an ornamental hammer, a gift from Inge’s parents, from his bakkie and hands it over to the police.

15 June 2005

It becomes known that the police want to prosecute Fred for Inge’s murder and he hands himself over to them at the Cloetesville police station in Stellenbosch.

16 September 2005

The murder case against Fred is postponed for more than a year.

Read more: Fred van der Vyfer’s father sued for outstanding fees: report

October 2006

Fingerprint experts disagree over whether Fred’s fingerprint was lifted from a DVD container (Inge had taken out the DVD at 3.15 pm) or a glass. Fred’s team say the police are purposely trying to mislead them about the fingerprint, but their attempts to have the murder case removed from the roll fails.

February 2007

The murder case begins in the Western Cape High Court.

November 2007

Judge Deon van Zyl acquits Fred of Inge’s murder and in his judgement he rejects the state’s evidence on the blood stain on the bathroom floor, the ornamental hammer and the fingerprint on the DVD container.

May 2009

Inge’s parents drop a civil claim of R8,5 million that they’d wanted to bring against Fred.

August 2011

Judge Anton Veldhuizen finds in a civil case that the police had indeed maliciously prosecuted Fred and awarded damages of R46 million.

November 2011

The minister of police is given leave to appeal against Fred’s successful claim of malicious prosecution.

Read more: Fred van der Vyver vindicated

March 2012

Inge’s parents, Professor Jan and Juanita Lotz, offer a R1 million reward to anyone with information that will help solve the murder. They also appoint master detective Piet Byleveld to further investigate the matter.

March 2013

The state succeeds in its appeal to have the verdict that Fred had been maliciously prosecuted set aside. Fred’s legal representative, Advocate Dup de Bruyn, indicates that they will turn to the Constitutional Court.

May 2013

The Constitutional Court turns down Fred’s application to appeal against the Appeal Court’s finding.

June 2013

Professor Jan Lotz terminates Piet Byleveld’s mandate to investigate Inge’s murder.

November 2013

Jan asks the National Director of Public Prosecutions (NDPP) to reopen the murder case against Fred after physicist Professor Kobus Visser says in a report that Fred’s fingerprint was indeed lifted from a flat surface. “People tell me I should close the book and get on with my life, but how can I close a book I don’t understand?” Jan says of his struggle to come to terms with his daughter’s unsolved murder.

In the same month Fred turns to the United Nations Human Rights Commission in an attempt to obtain damages for his prosecution. The commission turned down his application.

6 December 2013

The NDPP lets Jan know that they won’t reopen the case against Fred.

We live in a world where facts and fiction get blurred
In times of uncertainty you need journalism you can trust. For 14 free days, you can have access to a world of in-depth analyses, investigative journalism, top opinions and a range of features. Journalism strengthens democracy. Invest in the future today. Thereafter you will be billed R75 per month. You can cancel anytime and if you cancel within 14 days you won't be billed. 
Subscribe to News24
Show Comments ()