In some ways it is.
But if we're judging strictly on the music — and not on the over-the-top, awkward and somewhat creepy public pleas by Thicke everywhere from the BET Awards to the Billboard Music Awards — Paula Patton might want to reconsider.
The 14-track Paula, where Thicke spills his feelings, confesses his sins and insists he's a changed man, is a return to Thicke's R&B roots. It is also a reminder that he was a talented, Grammy-winning singer-songwriter pre-Blurred Lines hysteria.
The sexy number "You're My Fantasy" helps the album start on the right foot, and the piano mixed with Thicke's aching voice on "Still Madly Crazy" is impeccable. "Lock the Door" is dramatic and theatrical, while the horn-heavy "Love Can Grow Back" is a winner.
Thicke ditched the glossy electro beats and catchy hooks on last year's Blurred Lines for a more stripped-down, acoustic and simple sound on Paula — a much better fit for the 37-year-old crooner.
Blurred Lines made Thicke an international star and helped him tap into a younger audience that constantly streams music, buys digital tracks and can determine today and tomorrow's next pop star.
But the song has also been a bit of a curse: It has pigeon-holed Thicke, propelled him to one-hit-wonder status (despite having success in the past) and alienated the singer from the R&B fans who help him reach platinum status. And the tracks on Paula don't sound like songs that will play on Top 40 radio per se.
"Get Her Back," the smooth lead single, has yet to chart on the Billboard Hot 100, but the song is still a winner: Even if he doesn't get Paula back, his old fans will return.
Listen to the album here: