Icasa asked to overturn Hlaudi’s blackout decision
Llewellyn Prince, Media24 Parliamentary Bureau
Hlaudi Motsoeneng. Picture: City Press
Several organisations have teamed up to submit an urgent
application to the Independent Communications Authority of South Africa to force
the SABC to immediately revoke its controversial decision to not broadcast
footage of the destruction of property during protests.
Media Monitoring Africa, the SOS Coalition – a pressure group
campaigning for an independent public broadcaster – and the Freedom of
Expression Institute were preparing to submit the urgent complaint to Icasa’s
Complaints Compliance Committee in Johannesburg later today.
William Bird, head of Media Monitoring Africa, said that the
organisation saw the ban as a violation of the Broadcasting Act and the public
broadcaster had also broken its own “licence conditions”.
“It is a fundamentally poor and illegal decision. It is profoundly
unfortunate that the SABC can take such a decision.
“It is also very confusing. First, the SABC is not clear what it
wants to do because on the one hand [in a press release] it says that it will
not broadcast visuals of destruction but on the other hand, it says it will
still broadcast protest marches.
“If you make such a decision, you must be clear what problem you
want to address.”
Bird said that decisions like this can also confuse the SABC’s own
He said that the question rather was whether the decision would
lead to a solution for the problem of violence during protests.
“The abuse of women and children is a bad thing. Are we going to
stop reporting on this too? People involved in violent protests don’t wait for
the TV cameras before they start protesting.
“The TV cameras were not there when schools were burnt down in
Vuwani in Limpopo. It was filmed after the schools were set alight.”
Bird said the decision restricted media freedom and there was no
evidence, as required by law, that justified the SABC’s decision.
The decision – announced on Friday – was welcomed by Communications
Minister Faith Muthambi “in the interests of nation-building”, but slammed by
the ANC’s alliance partner Cosatu, among others.
We live in a world where facts and fiction get blurred
In times of uncertainty you need journalism you can
trust. For only R75 per month, you have access to
a world of in-depth analyses, investigative journalism,
top opinions and a range of features. Journalism
strengthens democracy. Invest in the future today.