ANALYSIS: Europe energy crisis may deepen with looming liquidity crunch

accreditation
0:00
play article
Subscribers can listen to this article
The war in Ukraine is putting massive pressure on European energy prices Photo: Getty Images
The war in Ukraine is putting massive pressure on European energy prices Photo: Getty Images

Europe's problems in sourcing oil and gas this winter, after a dispute with Russia, may be exacerbated by a new crisis in the market where prices are already red-hot: a liquidity crunch that could send them spiralling higher still.

But European governments have only belatedly rallied to offer financial support to power providers on the brink of collapse, in an effort to ease pressure on a market whose smooth operation is vital to keeping people warm.

"We have a dysfunctional futures market, which then creates problems for the physical market and leads to higher prices, higher inflation," a senior trading source said.

We have a dysfunctional futures market, which then creates problems for the physical market and leads to higher prices, higher inflation

The problem first came to light in March when an association of top traders, utilities, oil majors and bankers sent a letter to regulators, calling for contingency plans.

READ: Coal rush! Energy crisis fires global hunt for polluting fuel

This was triggered by market players rushing to cover their financial exposure to soaring gas prices through derivatives, hedging against future price spikes in the physical market, where a product is delivered, by taking a 'short' position.

Market players typically borrow to build short positions in the futures market, with 85% to 90% coming from banks. Some 10% to 15% of the value of the short, known as minimum margin, is covered by the traders' own funds and deposited with a broker's account. But if funds in the account fall below the minimum margin requirement, in this case 10% to 15%, it triggers a "margin call".

As prices for power, gas and coal have risen over the past year, so has the price of shorts, with the resulting margin calls forcing oil and gas majors, trading firms and power utilities to tie up more capital.

Some, particularly smaller firms, have been hurt so badly that they have been forced to exit trading altogether as energy prices soared after Russia's invasion of Ukraine in February, which made a general global shortage worse.

Any such drop in the number of players reduces market liquidity, which can in turn lead to even more volatility and sharper spikes in prices that can hurt even major players.

Since late August, EU governments have stepped in to help utilities such as Germany's Uniper.

However, with winter price spikes lying ahead, there is no indication of whether or how quickly governments and the EU can back banks or other utilities that need to hedge their trades.

Norwegian state-owned firm Equinor, Europe's top gas trader, said this month that European energy companies, excluding in Britain, need at least R20 trillion to cover the cost of exposure to soaring gas prices

Exchanges, clearing houses and brokers have raised initial margin requirements to 100% to 150% of contract value from 10% to 15%, senior bankers and traders said, making hedging too costly for many.

The Intercontinental Exchange is, for example, charging margin rates of up to 79% on Dutch Title Transfer Facility gas futures.

Although market participants say that fast-disappearing liquidity could severely reduce trading in fuels such as oil, gas and coal, and lead to supply disruptions and bankruptcies, regulators still say the risk is small.

Norwegian state-owned firm Equinor, Europe's top gas trader, said this month that European energy companies, excluding in Britain, need at least R20 trillion to cover the cost of exposure to soaring gas prices. That compares with the R19 trillion value of US subprime mortgages in 2007, which triggered a global financial meltdown.

However, one European Central Bank (ECB) policymaker said that worst case scenario losses would amount to R530 billion, adding that the risk lay with speculators rather than the actual market.

'NEED TO HEDGE'

Some traders and banks have nevertheless asked regulators such as the ECB and the Bank of England (BoE) to provide guarantees or credit insurance to brokers and clearing houses to lower initial margining levels to pre-crisis times.

Doing this, sources familiar with talks said, would help bring participants back into the market and increase liquidity.

READ: Eskom wants you to pay 30% more

The ECB and BoE have met several big trading houses and banks since April, four trading, regulatory and banking sources said, but no concrete measures have resulted from the consultations, which have not previously been reported.

"It's too big a single point of risk for a bank. The banks have hit or are close to hitting their liquidity risk and counterparty risk levels," a senior banking source involved in commodities finance said.

Banks have a certain level of capital they can tie up to a particular industry or a particular player and the price spikes and a reduction of players are currently testing those levels.

The ECB has repeatedly said it did not see systemic risk that could destabilise the banking sector. The bank declined to offer fresh comment.

ECB president Christine Lagarde said this month she would support fiscal measures to provide liquidity to solvent energy market participants, including utility firms, while the ECB stood ready to provide liquidity to banks if needed.

READ: Slowbalisation will drive higher prices for goods

Britain's Treasury and BoE, meanwhile, announced a R813 billion financing scheme this month for "extraordinary liquidity requirements" and short-term support to wholesale energy firms.

A Treasury spokesperson said the measures were being taken at the appropriate moment after watching the market for some time and in line with European peers.

Yet the markets for energy and commodities remain opaque, with physical trades hedged with financial instruments depending on internal rules set by the various companies involved.

And, since no regulator or exchange maintains a central register for trades, it is impossible to see the full picture, sources at several large commodities houses told Reuters.

For some, however, the signals are clear to see.

"Open interest and volumes have come down significantly as a result of what is happening on the margining front," Saad Rahim, chief economist at Trafigura, told a conference last week. "It will ultimately have an impact on the physical volumes that are being traded because physical traders need to hedge."


We live in a world where facts and fiction get blurred
In times of uncertainty you need journalism you can trust. For 14 free days, you can have access to a world of in-depth analyses, investigative journalism, top opinions and a range of features. Journalism strengthens democracy. Invest in the future today. Thereafter you will be billed R75 per month. You can cancel anytime and if you cancel within 14 days you won't be billed. 
Subscribe to News24

E-Editions

Read the digital editions of City Press here.
Read now
Voting Booth
Cricket SA is considering replacing Mark Boucher with two coaches, one for red-ball and the other for white-ball responsibilities. Is this a good move?
Please select an option Oops! Something went wrong, please try again later.
Results
Love the idea
33% - 59 votes
Hate the idea
35% - 62 votes
They must just be local
32% - 56 votes
Vote